AgentScully’s Reviews > The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall > Status Update
AgentScully
is on page 100 of 288
falling kinda flat now - gothic atmosphere has dissipated rapidly, servants too nice and accepting (where's Mrs Danvers when you need her?), mysterious disappeared H has reappeared too soon and is scarcely mysterious since we're privy to his every burbling thought, story badly needs a villain on-page
— Sep 04, 2022 09:32PM
3 likes · Like flag
AgentScully’s Previous Updates
AgentScully
is finished
3 1/2* rounded up, despite my snark it got more lively near the end, and I like to encourage newer authors to try different things
also was this actually marketed as a gothic? I feel part of my earlier disappointment was that it wasn't measuring up as a gothic read but was it actually sold as one?
— Sep 07, 2022 01:30PM
also was this actually marketed as a gothic? I feel part of my earlier disappointment was that it wasn't measuring up as a gothic read but was it actually sold as one?
AgentScully
is on page 260 of 288
villain has shown up with his strawberry blonde curls and he wants his favorite toy back dammit
— Sep 07, 2022 12:48AM
AgentScully
is on page 190 of 288
screwed and tattoo'd h and her family of mice servants are starting to bore me - and what's with Hal? depression? insanity? I've read it twice and still can't figure it out
— Sep 05, 2022 05:52PM
Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Sarah Mac
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Sep 05, 2022 12:01AM
YES. You are exactly on point with everything. *offers popcorn bag*
reply
|
flag

