Rod White's Blog
November 16, 2026
We have made forgiveness too small: Three words to contemplate
The word “forgiveness” in the English translations of the New Testament (and I suspect similar cognates in other languages) is an unfortunate catch-all for several Greek words. Each of the words translated “forgive” have their own color and each communicates more of what the original authors wanted to say. Over a lifetime of Bible study, I have grown tired of discovering what well-meaning men have done to the Bible. But I have not yet grown tired of complaining about it, as you will see.
Well-meaning men and their Bible lessonsStarting with the Latin Vulgate by Jerome, then on to Tyndale, Wycliffe and the King James Bible, the translators of the New Testament made some decisions about how to accurately convey what the colorful, philosophical and metaphorical Greek language was saying. When it came to the various words in the writings now rendered “forgive,” they did not translate the material “literally.” Instead, they decided to use the single English word “forgive” because the idioms and metaphors of the Greek might sound confusing or unnatural when translated word-for-word into English. They probably had some ulterior motives, too, which I will suggest.
In defense of the Europeans, there is some wisdom in avoiding the “root fallacy.” Linguists note that a word’s actual meaning is determined by how people use it in a sentence, not by its historical etymology. For instance, if we translated the English phrase “he kicked the bucket” literally into another language, it would probably confuse people. Similarly, translating aphiēmi (one of the words translated “forgive”) as “send away,” when talking about sin, could obscure its plain meaning.
As a result of the decisions made by influential translators, I think the word “forgive” got overloaded and drained of the miracle it should contain. The English Bible’s description of dealing with sin and relational rupture became more functional, even legal. Early English translations, such as the Wycliffe Bible and William Tyndale’s New Testament, established “forgive” (from the Old English forgiefan, meaning to give up a claim or resentment) as the standard theological term. Later committees, like those behind the King James Version, preserved this familiar language so it would read smoothly and clearly in public worship.
Actual picture of Quaker author and translator Sarah Ruden and her dog.As usual, well-meaning men, bent on protecting Jesus from error or abuse, and making him presentable for the liturgy, assumed what they thought was best was probably best for everyone and adjusted the Bible to fit. They thought people could not handle “hyper-literalism” or the need to understand what Greek people at the time were trying to reveal, and went with a tradition I’m not sure does justice to the original writings. I think the translators may have been more interested in morality and conformity (and power) than meaning. I discovered I am not alone in this criticism and bought Sarah Ruden’s 2021 translation, The Gospels, which assumes we can handle all sorts of things.
Wrestling with the words took further unfortunate turnsThe well-meaning theologians of the late 1800’s faced a bunch of “scientists” who invented “historical criticism” and then applied it to the Bible and the tradition behind the translations. Such thinking is something most Bible readers assume they must do these days, I think. We don’t assume the Bible is just a text in a uniform book. We understand it is a collection of genres from a long stretch of history and know the people of those different time periods did not have the same outlook, assumptions or science that people have in the present day. But before historical criticism won the argument, for the most part, the “scientists” questioning what the Church said about the Bible scared the pants off the authorities (translate that!). Some of the well-meaning men did not adapt; they invented “inerrancy.”
In 1881, theologians A. A. Hodge and B. B. Warfield of Princeton Theological Seminary published a seminal article titled “Inspiration.” Facing the rise of higher criticism’s “attacks” on the Bible, Hodge and Warfield formulated the doctrine that the original autographs (the now-lost complete original manuscripts) were completely without error, arguing that an inspired God could not author falsehood. By the time my seminary was being divided by this argument in the 1980’s there were people like me asking, “Why would God have a sense of ‘error’ that is based on Enlightenment thinking?” In the postmodern era we just endured, people went a lot farther and decided God was irrelevant and science was a poor substitute, so what is now “true” is basically what the loudest influencer has sold to unsuspecting scrollers on Instagram.
I’m hoping that the post-Trump era, which is the ugly epitome of truthlessness and in which resistance to domination is “error,” we Christians can have a lovely restoration of Spirit-inspired church-building. Perhaps James Talerico will lead us. For me, this rebuilding includes rescuing the wonderful and fundamental work of forgiveness we need to experience from the committee-work that created what most of us adopt when we read about it in the Bible.
Let’s contemplate forgiveness in new/ancient waysAs I continued to meditate on forgiveness last week, as I have been doing for some time, I came across a video which tried to make sense of the three main words translated “forgive” in the New Testament [link]. The creator, Tom Burger, is a pastor, former prison chaplain and missions director who now makes videos, too. Let’s work with the three words he highlights.
Like I said, in the New Testament, translators primarily collapse three distinct Greek words into the English word “forgive.” But each Greek word carries a colorful cultural metaphor and accompanying spiritual meaning that deepens how we experience it and enact it.
Aphiēmi (ἀφίημι).And forgive us our debts,
as we also have forgiven our debtors.
And lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from the evil one.
For if you forgive other people when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins. — Matthew 6:12-16 (NIV)
And free us from our debts, As we too have set our debtors free. And don’t bring us into the ordeal— No, rescue us from the malicious one.”
“If, then, you set other people free from their blunders, your father in the sky will set you free too. But if you don’t set other people free, your father won’t let your blunders go either. – Ruden, The Gospels
The basic, physical meaning of aphiēmi was originally to throw, like sending a spear toward the enemy. It evolved in a number of ways into to send away, to let go, or to release. It became the standard term for canceling a debt. But translators thought using “release our debts” instead of “forgive our debts” might sound overly mechanical to modern readers.
I am sorry we lost the part of the word that implies my sins are hurled into space like Superman taking the bomb to explode outside the earth’s atmosphere. Forgiveness is miraculous, as the Lord’s Prayer implies: “Give us our daily bread like you fed the 5000 and forgive us like you did on the cross.” Forgiveness is not just a matter of morality, conformity and being under the authority of the Church (which unwisely put a priest in charge of dispensing it through confession by the 300’s and codified the process in the 1200’s); it is wildly personal and powerful.
Apolyō (ἀπολύω).Be merciful, just as your Father is merciful. Do not judge, and you will not be judged. Do not condemn, and you will not be condemned. Forgive, and you will be forgiven. Give, and it will be given to you. — Luke 6:36-38 (NIV)
“Be compassionate, as your father is compassionate [as well]. And don’t give verdicts, and you’ll never have verdicts given on you; and don’t give guilty verdicts, and guilty verdicts will never be given on you. Pardon, and you’ll be pardoned. Give, and things will be given to you. – Ruden, The Gospels
Used in passages like Luke 6:37, apolyō means to untie, to set free, or to acquit. Even though the word paints a vivid picture of releasing someone from a legal bond or prison, English translators used “forgive” to keep the moral and relational focus clear. Ruden highlights its legal use, like Pilate does when he releases Barabbas. But Luke also quotes Jesus using the word when he releases a hunched over woman from her long infirmity.
Forgiveness is a miracle like being set free from what has bound my body, only it is my soul. Forgiving changes things; it heals things. It is freeing someone from their sin and being free from it. It undoes the defense systems that keep us apart. It violates the pride and isolation that keep people from God and in charge of their own destruction. It saves us from evil.
Charizomai (χαρίζομαι).Be kind and compassionate to one another, forgiving each other, just as in Christ God forgave you. – Ephesians 4:32 (NIV)
…becoming to one another kind, tenderly compassionate, gracing others, just as God in the Anointed One graces you. – Ruden, The Gospels.
The verb charizomai is probably the Apostle Paul’s favorite word – we are saved by grace and now live in grace. It comes from the root word charis (grace) and literally means “to show favor” or “to grant freely as a gift.” When Paul uses it in passages like Ephesians 4:32, the translators, like Ruden does, could have literally rendered it as “gracing” one another. Contextually, it could be forgiving one another, since that is the basic grace Jesus expresses on the cross. But, like most of what Paul writes, forgiveness has a bigger context than pardoning a wrong.
Forgiveness has the immediacy of creation. It is asserting the new creation with Jesus. The paramount act of Jesus on the cross is the energy of my life. I live in grace so I bless people with grace. In the face of sin and death, I grace. It is my joy to forgive you, even to suffer on your behalf. To share in the Lord’s death and share in his glory, to be crucified with him, is to be forgiven, and to forgive you, and to forgive myself — and so it is also to be one with Jesus in his resurrection, sharing his glory, even if the world calls it all “weak.”
When I learned Ephesians 4:32 as a child (and I still recite it in the King James), it was basically conveyed as “be a good boy.” I think most Christians have heard the Bible as “be nice” or “don’t be angry.” Many of my Christian clients are defended from any miracle associated with forgiveness because they are scanning the horizon for any conflict and skillfully avoiding it. They don’t want to be forgiven because it means they are guilty, and if they are guilty, they are not a good person, which feels intolerable. And they don’t want to forgive others because it would make other people feel as bad and imposed upon as they would feel. So they avoid being saved altogether, or they just believe in grace as a principle.
But I don’t think anyone writing the Bible thinks grace is just a principle, it is an experience; it is the out-of-control reality of losing one’s old life and being remade in the image of the new one Jesus freely provides. That’s what forgiveness is about. We wouldn’t want to miss it because it is obscured by the brilliant, well-meaning, opinionated and authoritative translators.
The post We have made forgiveness too small: Three words to contemplate appeared first on Development.November 9, 2026
Forgiveness is the reboot of love: Look at your marriage
I had a small disagreement with A.I. this morning. We were arguing about what is the primary command that defines Christian faith. I suggested it might be, after all the years I have been preaching love one another, actually be forgive each other.
I have been thinking a lot about forgiveness. My wife and I even wrote a little article about it. As we talked about the piece with our friends over dinner, I began to think forgiveness is the most fundamental act of being a follower of Jesus. Being given over to death was surely motivated by the Lord’s great love for us, but what he cried out on the cross was,
“Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they are doing” (Luke 23:34).
Forgiveness usually needs to be inserted into couples therapy. Many couples will say, “We know we love each other,“ and may tell me something like, “My mate may have trouble believing in my love, or absorbing it, day by day, due to the fragility they wear, but it is there.” When love is in a marriage, it is kind of an intangible reality — just like I experience God’s love. Love is a big tent kind of word. I feel something in my body and mind when I talk about God’s love. But that’s not everybody’s experience. Several of my friends have told me their belief in the principle of God’s love, demonstrated in history, also gives them reassurance regardless of their feelings.
Forgiveness in a marriage, on the other hand, is quite tangible — and the lack of it is hard to overlook. You might ask your mate, “Are we ‘good’ with each other?” You might not even want to ask the question for fear it is not so. But we are always checking to see if we are in good standing with each other. I have known several mates who tell me they love their spouse, but they are so distressed by the ongoing need to forgive them, even for things that hurt them 25 years ago! They believe in their mate’s love, as best they can give it, but their apparent lack of it, assessed by the way they behave, is hard to bear. They can’t express it like I need and even ask to experience! They give it and then seem to take it back! They keep pushing the button they have often been told not to touch!
My friend told me, “That’s probably why forgiveness is paramount in the Lord’s prayer.” Jesus tells his followers to love one another as he loves them. But when he teaches them to pray, this is part of the model prayer:
Forgive us our sins
as we forgive those who sin against us.
Save us from the time of trial, and deliver us from evil.
[For the kingdom, the power, and the glory are yours, now and for ever]. — TEC version of Matt. 6:12-13
After the model prayer, the teaching goes on to include some rationale, given in vv. 14-15, in case you missed the most important part:
For if you forgive other people when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins. — Matt. 6:14-15 NIV
That sounds primary to me. Forgiveness is what keeps our renewed and ongoing relationship with God going. If you are going to follow Jesus, this is your base prayer: “Forgive me as I forgive others.” Because you know if you are not a forgiver, you’re not good with God. You have not really got the point yet – the point he made on the cross.
I told my friends, “It is possible to blow off forgiveness by saying things like ‘In principle, I love everyone’ or ‘Of course I love you, how could I not?’ or ‘My love is inclusive,’” etc. But even if I am in love with you, that doesn’t mean you have forgiven me, necessarily. Forgiveness is a small tent kind of word. It happens in our tent, more face to face, usually with a specific situation in mind. I will probably love you more if we forgive each other (thus, “make-up sex”), because our love was enacted in real time (see Matthew 18). Forgiving and being forgiven gives me hope for reconciliation, and opens up the chance for the real repentance I need to make or witness. Forgiveness is the reboot of love.
While I think we must not forgive with a focus on outcome, just like God forgives, forgiving is meant to end with reconciliation and peace. It is designed to make an impact, to change people. It is resistant to sin and expectant of love. It is probably the act that makes us new and restores creation, day by day.
More quibbling with A.I.That may be enough for you from me today, but let me go on to describe a little more of my argument with A.I.
ChatGPT thought I needed to know that Christianity is not unique when it comes to forgiveness:
Virtually every major religious and ethical system promotes releasing anger and pardoning wrongdoing:
Judaism: Features foundational examples of person-to-person forgiveness, such as Joseph forgiving his brothers in Genesis. It emphasizes a pragmatic framework requiring the offender to actively seek out repentance and restitution before forgiveness is granted.Islam: Celebrates Allah as the All-Forgiving and encourages believers to forgive others as a virtue that earns spiritual reward, though it balances this closely with the principles of divine justice and retributive law.Buddhism and Hinduism: View forgiveness through the lens of karma and personal liberation. Holding onto anger is seen as a poison that binds a person to suffering; thus, letting go is required to maintain spiritual purity and compassion ( karuna ).Secular Philosophy: Ancient Greek texts and modern psychological frameworks treat forgiveness as a critical mechanism for personal freedom and healing broken relationships, entirely independent of a deity.But then it basically went on to prove Christianity is, actually, unique.
The Unique Framing of Christian Forgiveness
While the act of forgiving is not unique, Christianity frames the motivation for it in a distinct way.
The Flow of Grace: In the Christian faith, interpersonal forgiveness is not merely a tool for conflict resolution or emotional peace. It is a direct response to a vertical reality: humans must forgive others because God first forgave them through the sacrifice of Jesus Christ.A Condition of Salvation: Jesus taught that extending forgiveness is intimately tied to receiving it. In passages like the Lord’s Prayer, he explicitly states that if a person refuses to forgive others, God will not forgive them.In Christ, we share God’s spiritual reality incarnate. Grace draws us and moves us as we experience the forgiveness that leads us into love and leads us to share it.
As we talked about this over dinner, I thought, “We are so big inside!” I barely know the extent of my own experience of God’s love. How could I define it and measure it? I can’t really. But I can enact it, just like Jesus did with God’s love. I can forgive. To love is definitely the great commandment. But forgiveness is the experience and act by which we step into that grace.
My logic has become, “If you want love in your marriage it will follow forgiveness. If you are waiting for repentance and change, if you want justice, if your spouse needs enlightenment to free up their compassion, or a good therapist to send them home with more to give, it might be a long wait. Begin with forgiveness. If there is any good soil where love can grow, that is how you plant it.
If you want your stumbling spouse to love you better, keep in mind: It is easier to love a forgiver. It is easier to get somewhere better if you forgive all the times you have not been forgiven and forgive yourself for not being forgiving! Your grace probably won’t move someone on the NPD-to-psychopath spectrum, so be sure to check your boundaries. But everyone else has a heart that can be softened and forgiveness is the basic tool of that healing.
The post Forgiveness is the reboot of love: Look at your marriage appeared first on Development.November 2, 2026
Forgiveness: Five words at the heart of our journey
Gwen and I were asked to write an article for the BIC newsletter Shalom! about forgiveness, reflecting on the fracturing of Circle of Hope. With fear and trembling we did it. It was good for us and maybe it will help you, too. Here is a version for Development.
In 2020 and 2021, our ability to forgive was challenged. After lifetimes of teaching about it, we had to practice the heart of a Christian’s character in ways we never expected. Our story interested the editors of Shalom! since it all began during COVID and continued as our church, Circle of Hope, made a quick and dramatic descent into dissolution.
Our family moved to plant a church in Philadelphia in 1995 and the few who organized the first cells grew to 700 people and 5 congregations at one point. In 2015, Rod stepped down as Lead Pastor and became the part-time Development Pastor. By the end of 2020 his term was over. At that point there were four pastors at work serving an expanding faith community; one of them was our son, Ben. We looked forward to following their direction as members, having, in good BIC tradition, “arisen from the congregation” and were now returning. We began renovating a condo as part of our new direction.
Then came COVID. It disrupted the church and everything else, including our rehab project. We had hired a member of Circle of Hope to do the construction. It turned out to be a difficult process with many delays. By the time the COVID shut down came, he was already beyond the contracted completion date. We had sold our home and had nowhere to live. With the shutdown, the contractor said he could not work. Other contractors across Philadelphia considered their work essential and continued. We were stuck, so we decided to end our relationship with our now-uncontracted G.C. and find someone who was willing to complete the project. Then we discovered that materials we had paid for under the contract had never been purchased, not to mention the undone work we had paid for in advance. We lost over $54,000.
We wrestled with how to go forward with this brother. Taking him to court seemed unthinkable, but we kept wondering how to have our relationship with a fellow member of the Body of Christ. We turned to the pastor of the congregation of Circle of Hope we were attending and the pastor of the congregation the contractor was attending. No resolution was found. One of the church’s “containers” was formed to keep further processing within boundaries. It also proved unhelpful. We decided we would just forgive the debt.
We also decided we needed to tell our story to the church’s Leadership Team, since the tale was likely to make the rounds, and leave any next steps to them, since the contractor had created similar issues with other members. This is where another challenge for our forgiveness began. Some members of the Leadership Team were uncomfortable with the letter. One of the pastors decided to create a small group to discuss the way we used our power in this situation. We were never openly accused of wrongdoing, but what grew out of the Leadership Team’s discussion became, as they described it, “an investigation of the White family” and our inappropriate use of power. As far as we can tell, we were subjected to the wave of searching out racist and patriarchal attitudes that swept parts of the church at that time, all beginning with our vulnerability and story of forgiveness.
Ultimately, under the leadership of the pastor who initiated these things, we were asked to leave Circle of Hope for a year, which we did, under a cloud of innuendo. Our son was left to pastor during a troubling time in the church, burdened with guilt by association. He eventually resigned his pastoral position, as the Leadership Team had formed a very different church. Many hurtful things were said as power struggles emerged! Circle of Hope seemed unrecognizable from its long-term vision and culture. We grieved the losses, particularly to our family, and to the community as a whole. Again, we needed to forgive, even though no apology was offered — much the contrary, we were considered by many to be the offending parties!
After we were long gone, the attendance and contributions began to decline across all the congregations. The initiating pastor had very few people remaining in his congregation, so he interviewed for a pastoral position in a local Mennonite Church and left. Circle of Hope closed soon after due to conflicts with the denomination over LGBTQ+ issues. Remnants have gone their own way. Then the book came out. Eliza Griswold, of the New Yorker, had been invited into the middle of the process for years and ended up writing a fanciful book to sum up the process of the decline. Rod has not quite forgiven her for calling him “Evangelical.”
We miss Circle of Hope and our sons and their families still comment occasionally about missing the community that had embraced a vision of the church as a welcoming space to encounter God and to grow deeper in faith and action. It still hurts.
Ev Worthington’s process of forgiving.So what have we learned from God about forgiving?Gwen has read a lot of psychological research from colleagues who have been studying forgiveness for a couple decades now. Paramount among the conclusions these researchers have come to is that it is impossible to ignore the need to forgive. We have to acknowledge the hurt and wrestle with our intense feelings of betrayal, loss, and anger or our mental and physical health suffers.
What’s more, Christians, must listen intently to the Spirit of God and pray for the courage and strength to resist the urge for revenge or the impulse to prove ourselves right in the public sphere or our faith proves inauthentic and withers. Jesus shows us that forgiveness is at the heart of the new creation and our own transformation.
As we wrestled, five words have gained new meaning and helped us heal.
PowerSome advisors wanted us to sue our contractor and publicly fight our slanderers. We chose to forgive. Just writing this article threatens to undermine our conviction.
The last value standing in the U.S. is “the law” and the population’s main motivation, by and large, has become power. Forgiveness has been pushed to the edges of our minds in our culture. Justice, accountability, reparations, and fairness are front and center; the Bible’s language of love and forbearance are not. This cultural orientation brings with it an unconscious assumption about life: it ought to be just and I should insist on it.
LongsufferingWe were shocked to be unloved and hurt even though we teach and practice psychotherapy and know better. We know our brains are conditioned to avoid pain and everyone unconsciously forms irrational beliefs to soothe themselves. We don’t think directly about death or about our hurts unless we cannot avoid it. We believe we can avoid pain and suffering and we should – and we even resist confronting our thoughts about death.
The problem with these unconscious assumptions, besides that they are completely untrue, is that they cause us to miss the opportunity to suffer in love (love is longsuffering) and to learn to suffer creatively. Looking for ways to prove ourselves worthy, to defend our reputation or even to find avenues for revenge, filter through all our thinking, feelings and choices. We struggle to focus on anything other than how to correct others or ourselves, which leads to a swamp of despair.
We watched as good principles focused on being right and righting every wrong disabled our church. We, personally, became stereotypes in an argument after years of feeling loved! The church splintered, not because people were on opposite sides of an argument, but because the argument was paramount and the forbearance was gone. Love relationships are, unfortunately, as fragile as we are. Forgiveness is at the root of them if they are to flourish.
ReconciliationWe spent a year trying to figure out how to be reconciled to our contractor, who we had loved. And then we spent another year wondering if the wounds the church inflicted on us could be healed. No apologies were forthcoming. We were told the process Jesus calls for in Matthew 18 was unsafe and demonstrated an exercise of power over disempowered people. Thus we had to accept that the reconciliation we prized was not available.
But presently-unavailable reconciliation does not mean we cannot forgive. Forgiveness may not lead to a desired outcome, but it does lead to freedom. Forgiveness is the beginning of love because it is also the end of being dominated by justice and the preoccupation with unfinished relational business.
GiftForgiveness is a gift we can choose to offer. It was painful to choose it. The contractor was easier. The leadership team who changed the rules and ruled so harshly was harder. The long-loved pastor who used our distress against us and divided the church was the hardest. The exploitation of Eliza Griswold is probably ongoing.
The gift of forgiving means releasing these friends and insisting we will not see them only as an accumulation of their errors or fears. After all, we may all meet in the age to come and have a better chance to work things out! We reminded each other that God loves these folks dearly and is still at work in their lives. The outcomes are not our responsibility.
PassionOur clients are often dominated by who they have not forgiven. We can relate. As much as we thought we might “make a deal” with people who no longer spoke to us, we were still drawn to forgive, seventy times seven. After choosing 100 times, on the way to 490, we’re better at it. Jesus, our example and tutor, helps us to keep making the choice — and then making it again.
Forgiveness is our small version of the Lord’s choice. Rod’s spiritual director heard his story and said, “You’ve been handed over. It is a passion.” That really helped. Patiently enduring our pain in God’s presence released a lot of it, and left the door open for love to get out and hope to get in. We do not suffer to prove ourselves worthy. We trust that God makes something good out of all this, even if we don’t see it all yet.
It is fitting to say with Jesus, “Father forgive them, they don’t know what they are doing” even if you’re convinced they know what they’re doing very well! That choice aligns us with God, who is not dominated by our sin and keeps creating the world out of nothing, even miraculously healing what we destroy. We’re not Jesus, and we can still feel angry and hurt. But his call to let go, to resist blaming ourselves or others and to simply suffer, secure in his love, has proven life-giving. Forgiving is part of the joy we are promised, suffering the death and entering the resurrection.
*****************
Today is All Souls Day. Learn about the All Saints Day “triduum” at the Transhistorical Body.
The post Forgiveness: Five words at the heart of our journey appeared first on Development.October 26, 2026
It’s a difficult time to find deep peace: Try it.
We came home to Vance defending Ramaswamy’s nasty ad in Ohio.Are you hearing about difficult days?Someone just told me about their intricate and irritating process of moving to another country. They said getting their pet by the airline’s contradictory policy monitors was more difficult than navigating the treacherous waters of their new country’s bureaucracy!
I can sympathize. I just escaped the clutches of Frankfurt airport after endless lines and understaffed security barriers. When we first de-planed in Germany, after sitting delayed on the runway, I told Gwen I could not remember the terrible airport we had gone through one time with so many checkpoints and rude employees; and then I realized – “Oh, it is THIS one!”
What’s more, just before I heard my emigre’s story, I had called Citi (again!) about the huge fraud left on my account by the company they bought and from which I was transferred. After I got through the waiting period on the phone, a person came on to tell me to call back later; they were in the middle of an extensive system repair! That did not make my day.
We all seem to have an “it’s difficult right now” story to tell these days. For instance, after driving from Bingen to Budapest, one of my stories is that all European Union roads are apparently under construction right now. More rebuilding will follow once the rioters are done with France, then we can tell that story.
Looking back at the United States from our rearview mirror, it was difficult to look at how much has been destroyed in so little time. When will my country be under construction again?
The deconstructive Steve Bannon prophesied during the first Trump administration, “The Democrats don’t matter. The real opposition is the media. And the way to deal with them is to flood the zone with shit.” — WP 2/23/2017. Our zone is flooded with shit, all right. I can only hope that Ramaswamy is swamped by his own smarm in Ohio.
We were looking back on a government so ruined it will probably need to be reinvented, not just reconstructed. At the beginning of the second Trump term, Jamelle Bouie prophesied:
Under the cover of an audit, he has empowered Elon Musk, his de facto co-president, to take an ax to any and every program that helps ordinary Americans. The so-called Department of Government Efficiency has stripped funds or personnel or both from the National Institutes of Health, the National Science Foundation, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the National Park Service, the National Weather Service, FEMA, the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Social Security Administration, among others. It has degraded the federal government’s ability to deliver critical services to tens of millions of Americans and is endangering direct payments to millions more. There is no apparent rhyme or reason to these cuts, only a nihilistic drive to cause as much damage and to make it as irreparable as possible….
There is no evidence that Trump is a figure of deep thought or serious insight. There is no evidence that Trump is anything other than what he’s been for his entire time in the public eye: an ego-driven creature of boundless envy and vicious, overlapping resentments. Those resentments have led him on a grand tour of retribution against the public.
And his envy?
Well, if Trump wants anything, it is the untrammeled authority of the world’s autocrats. He wants to be a Putin or a Viktor Orban or a Kim Jong-un. He wants to rule with unchecked power. And if his psychology tells us anything, he will do everything he can to make that a reality, American democracy be damned. — Jamelle Bouie NYT 3/5/25
I guess Jamelle was right! Trump doubled down on the lie in Ramaswamy’s ad to help out with the damnation!
We came back with a little fear and trembling.Fortunately, in the midst of the rubble, I remembered our practice of visiting most of the church buildings we pass in Europe. There are so many beautiful, deeply prayed in, places to use! Sometimes, the the wind seems to be blowing through their spiritual aridity; many times they are cluttered with tourists and their barking guides. But they still call to us. We generally go in, kneel down and pray, empty or cluttered.
Jesus, Son of God have mercy on me…
Our father in heaven, hallowed be your name…
I am grateful to report, that such a lifelong practice of prayer is absolutely an antidote to the difficult things we are facing in the U.S. And it seems we will face more, as the match of more trouble has been lit all over the world by sociopaths seizing power, as they are wont to do when days are difficult and people are desperate.
Hotel Erbacher Hof in Mainz has its own chapel!In the face of it, try praying. Be still and know God. Jesus is walking with us.
If the church building we visit is empty, which is not that rare, we will sing our song – the same one we first sang on our pilgrimage to Santiago, now long ago.
I often come up with a mash up of the verses to “I Know My Redeemer Lives.” So I decided to look them up. I found out I did not have a traditional set of lyrics in mind. So I asked A.I. to find for me the 80’s guitarist who sang a variant version of this hymn. In less than thirty seconds, I had him: Bob Bennet, who I think my friend John Alfred introduced to our new church.
If you want to feel better about living in the rubble of post-war Pax Americana, sing along with us:
I know that my redeemer lives! What comfort this sweet sentence gives!
He lives! He lives, who once was dead. He lives, my ever-living head.
He lives triumphant from the grave; he lives eternally to save.
He lives my mansion to prepare; he lives to lead me safely there.
He lives and grants me daily bread. He lives and I shall conquer death.
He lives and while he lives I’ll sing. He lives my prophet, priest, and king.
He lives all glory to his name! He lives my Jesus still the same.
Oh, the sweet joy this sentence gives: I know that my redeemer lives.
I know that my redeemer lives!
October 10, 2026
Alarm at the Documentation Center

We visited the Documentation Center in Nuremberg. I hope they build one in Florida when Trump is finally gone. The centers in Germany are dedicated to the ongoing education of the public, so they can understand how their country ended up vilifying certain citizens and either imprisoning them or killing them. How did their country start an impossible war dedicated to world domination? How did a group of thugs from the south manage to scare the whole country into submission? Why did they let these incompetent, greedy, self-interested sociopaths wreck their economy? It is an honest and sobering account.
It sounded so much like our last twelve years I was shocked all over again. The image that stuck with me the most was Hitler’s picture on his famous book. It looked so much like Donald Trump’s official portrait hanging as a banner off the Dept. of Education, I shuddered.
I know people have scoffed at the comparison. But if you went through the Documentaion Center, I think you’d believe we’ve been living through the application of a playbook.
I have not stopped praying for the deported, fired and swindled people living under the wannabe fuhrer’s regime
The post Alarm at the Documentation Center appeared first on Development.
October 5, 2026
Turning Love Park into a sanctuary in the face of ICE
The vigil beginsOur church’s social action team, Voices for Justice, has been connecting with the New Sanctuary Movement in Philadelphia, here and there, since their good work intersects with our goals. They work out dignity, mutuality, community, and spiritual nonviolence as they make a place for the stranger in spite of our xenophobic federal regime. Thank God there are a lot of people who keep the light burning!
Tre Ford, a pastor with Bethel Church (out at Franklin Mills), is the Community Organizer & Congregation Liaison for NSM. He called us together for a prayer vigil at Love Park last Wednesday with the theme “Love Has No Limits.” He said,
After more than 40 weeks of consistently showing up at noon at 8th & Cherry [ICE in Philly], our work continues. On September 30, we will shift our weekly witness into an evening expression of prayer and unity at Love Park. This will be a special moment for our movement, and we want our clergy, congregations, people, and voices there. Please bring your people and come stand with us.
We did not fill Love Park. But we got a good number of people out at 6:30 to form a “sacred space.” It was not a “protest” per se. But there was a lot of protest in it and a group of winsome young teachers came prepared with some pithy posters they made.
The New Sanctuary folks are great at getting Christians and like-minded people out of their buildings and into the public in ecumenical gatherings. This is not small feat. They are persistent, insistent and overtly Christian/religious — right there in Love Park!
Love Park is a noisy place to create a sanctuaryThe organizers hauled in a lot of sound equipment, but it was still hard to hear certain speakers. Who really knows how to use a microphone, anyway? We stood at the edge of the group and to the side, so we missed quite a bit. But the point was being present, not just being informed. I kept noting the challenges we faced as we cordoned off some sanctuary:
The Broad St. Beer Garden has been operating in the square around the “flying saucer” pavilion they will later inhabit. I finally realized that loudspeaker was them broadcasting quizzo questions. Quizzo is so distracting.A man about 20 yards away near Market St. had such a booming laugh he was louder than the speaker. Astounding and infectious.A passerby saw that an ecumenical peace band was set up and waiting to play, so he came into the group and shouted, “Play some heavy metal” a few times. My wife told him we wanted to hear the speaker, so he gave way. They were both mildly audacious.A group of preschool and early elementary kids used our gathering as a maze in a serious game of chase. They darted through our legs so many times they seemed like part of the family. Yes, I looked around for their parents.About a half hour into our vigil, servants from The Everywhere Project started setting up their tables and unloading their food and supplies on 15th St. to help the unhoused. Quite an undertaking.There are many purposely-loud cars and wild tricycles with blaring music on our streets, as you know.But we managed to do itWe have nice, quiet church buildings for a reason. Turning into the presence of God takes quite a bit of silence. But if we have turned and invited God to fully inhabit the holy center of ourselves, we can invite people into sanctuary almost anywhere. We’re like a special delivery. And, of course, where two or three are gathered in the name of Jesus, God is in their midst. So I think we did all right. Among the well-turned moments I remember:
There were pastors and a rabbi involved. I know how busy they can be, so I was impressed. And I know from experience they usually decide what is going to happen and it is not that easy to fit into someone else’s program. They did well.From what I could hear, a soft-spoken Haitian woman told TPS stories. In an unspeakable act of cruelty, the USCIS announced that Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for Haiti officially terminated on July 27 following a U.S. Supreme Court decision ( Mullin v. Doe ) that allowed the Department of Homeland Security to end the designation. That means about 350,000 (!!) more people now being hunted by ICE.A representative from Asian Americans United (AAU) couldn’t help but weep as she talked about accompanying people through the immigration injustice system. The ICE office in Philly is, essentially, in Chinatown. AAU provides case support for families impacted by ICE detention, connects individuals with legal resources, and distributes emergency aid. They were a primary coalition member pushing for the city’s “ICE Out” legislative package, which restricts ICE from entering city-owned spaces without judicial warrants and limits local cooperation with federal agents.Then there was the interfaith band, full of joy and cajoling us to sing simple songs right out there in Love Park. Just getting themselves electrified and amplified was a deep expression of commitment and hope.And I must give a shout out to Will O’Brien and Dee Dee Risher who were present. I went over to Will and reminded him that he had welcomed strangers to Philadelphia when we showed up at the offices of The Other Side in Germantown as soon as we arrived in town from California in 1995. Their magazine had been a guiding light for our Sierra St. Household and church planting efforts. Sadly, they had to stop publishing in 2004. I told my wife, “Those are people who have always lived out their convictions.”Remembering our super-diverse collection of brilliant people and hangers on, like me, gives me hope. I’m encouraged, even though It has been a terrible year for people singled out for oppression by the government. I’m shocked, and I think it is important to stay shocked by how ruthless they are in principle and action.
In the face of that reality, many people are giving their lives to lead us. They are living out their convictions and revealing Jesus in the process. The gospel has always re-emerged after dark times, usually stronger and clearer than before. I am looking forward to that and praying for the tide to turn right now.
The post Turning Love Park into a sanctuary in the face of ICE appeared first on Development.September 28, 2026
Should I forgive someone if they won’t apologize?
Gwen and I are getting ready to write an article that responds to some of the unreconciled relationships we recall and how forgiveness has worked in those places. I was reminded of this post from 2022 when the need to forgive was very fresh and Joe Biden had some issues with reconciliation to deal with too!
The Washington Post surprised me the other day with an op-ed featuring Warren G. Harding – the first president after World War I, who is most-remembered for the corruption in his administration. That’s him, above, throwing out the first pitch. So it has been a weird week. First, I liked Dick Cheney, of all people, for accompanying Liz to the Jan. 6 commemoration. Then I read WaPo and ended up admiring the super-capitalist, Teapot Dome president!
I did not know that Harding forgave Eugene V. Debs! He commuted the sentence of the Socialist who ran against him from prison! Debs’ crime was doubting-out-loud the validity of WWI — he called it a diabolical capitalist war (I guess I would have voted for him). For his free speech, the Woodrow Wilson administration threw Debs in jail with a dubious application of the Espionage Act. When Harding followed Wilson, he decided to forgive Debs, against the advice of his advisors. He even made sure the “traitor” came to the White House on his way home from prison, so he could meet him and form some kind of relationship.
Biden has been acting out a similar public drama for us all year. He’d love to forgive people. But he took the gloves off on Epiphany (which he also loves to to) and laid out Trump. For most of the year he had been restrained, trying hard to bridge the political chasm dividing the country. But that appears to be over.
Are you similarly conflicted by your own relational chasms? Do you rehearse snappy things you would say to your enemies in your head — the zingers you will never get a chance to deliver? What do you do when your offender will not apologize, much less reconcile?
Have you decided how you are going to handle the people who have undermined you, lied about you and then blamed you for what they did to you? Maybe you just wait to see what will happens when the drama starts.
You won’t have to wait long, apparently. A lot of us are having a lot of drama. All over the country divorces have gone up, families have been divided over politics, churches have split and pastors have resigned. You can’t look at the news, if you dare, without someone worrying about American “democracy” – which Eugene V. Debs did not think much of when he was jailed for saying something that 900,000 people voted for.
It can be hard to forgive sometimes, but if Warren Harding can do it, maybe we can too.
What if they don’t say they are sorry?This is always the big question when it comes to forgiveness. What if the person who hurt me is not sorry? It is not uncommon for someone to protest like this when forgiveness is suggested:
I can’t let my guard down. That would be surrendering and acting like they were justified in hurting me. They would get away with their crime! I would be just as vulnerable to more of the abuse I just suffered.
I will not forgive until the other person: 1) knows that wrong was done; 2) feels an inner sorrow for doing it; 3) apologizes to me; 4) and makes amends. Then I’ll know it is safe to forgive and enter back into the relationship.
Most of us are taught to apologize from a young age along the lines of those last four conditions. Maybe you bit your sibling (well, I did, at least), said something cruel, pushed someone around, and a well-meaning adult intervened and told you, “Now, say you’re sorry.” As kids, those half-hearted apologies, sometimes followed with forced hugs, were enough to help us move on. But something changed as we got older. Aren’t apologies a little harder to come by, now? Aren’t the issues cutting a little deeper than, “She took my Sports Diva!”
What are you supposed to do when someone intentionally hurts you, rips your heart wide open, and then leaves you to pick up the pieces? What if they move on with their lives, and there is no well-meaning adult to come along and demand they apologize?
From our playground lessons, we’ve been conditioned to think forgiveness follows an apology. But things change and people forget how to apologize or think they are avoiding the problem by never having relationships deep enough to matter. We protest that someone is letting our hurt and their perfidy go unnoticed and all we hear is, “That’s your problem. Deal with it.” We get the unspoken message we’re wrong for being hurt. But living wronged with that prickly disconnection installed is a recipe for bitterness and it might even make us sick.
When hurt remains unforgiven, when the memory stays unprocessed, it sits in our hearts as if it is still happening. A lot of us are waiting for an apology in order to get some relief. Do you have anyone on whom you are still waiting? Is it fairly easy to get all worked up when their face pops into your mind or someone speaks about them fondly or you see them succeed? Jessica Harris wrote:
“My dad left our family when I was in elementary school. The pain caused by his abandonment ran deep. I couldn’t wrap my head around the fact that someone I loved could hurt me so badly when I didn’t do anything to deserve it. Then, as I got older, I couldn’t wrap my head around the fact that someone I loved could hurt me so badly and not care.
That ate away at my heart for years. The hurt remained unresolved as I waited for this man to return to my life and apologize for wrecking it. I thought my anger was my power. My ability to never forget was going to ensure I would never get hurt again. It was how I protected my heart.
That anger bled over into my other relationships. I became angry in general, always blaming it on my dad. If he would just admit he was wrong, my life would be better.”
I couldn’t tell that same story. But I have definitely had to work through similar hurts in the last few years. You probably have had some hurts too. My clients certainly share them every day: a trauma that is lodged in the memory and won’t go away, a loved one who betrayed their trust, an unscrupulous salesman or contractor who swindled them, a family member who hurt them but has since passed on. They still feel deeply about people who cut them deep but have never once breathed an apology. You might feel you have a right to hold a grudge, yourself.
What if anger is not strength?Bitterness is an enemy of resilience. It is the opposite of joy isn’t it? It is the taste of poison. You cannot be strong and move forward with your life while still dragging around chests full of bitterness from your past like you’re Jacob Marley.
What kids rarely learn is that an act of forgiveness strengthens the heart of the forgiver as much as it frees the offender. Forgiveness is not, “I am OK with what you did.” It isn’t even, “I accept your apology.” It is, “I am not going to hold this in me or against you anymore.”
The point of forgiveness and apologies is ultimately reconciliation. It is great when an apology is extended by the person who committed the hurt; then they can be free of what they are dragging behind them. It is an everyday miracle when forgiveness is extended by the person who was hurt; then they can get over what the offender did to them. If those things happen, then two people who have freed one another can move on to work out how to live together in love, and creation is that much less ruined.
But even if you can’t get to reconciliation you can still forgive, and bring some kind of closure to a wound. Adults take charge of their traumas all the time. You can forgive even if there is no apology.
If you’re too hurt to forgive right away, take time to scab over. But try not to hold on too long. The anger you nurse is just the hurt hanging on. Being angry is not being strong. Forgiving brings strength that lets us really heal and move forward with life without waiting for someone to let us out of our bitterness prison.
Go ahead and forgiveForgiveness is uncommon enough that it is actually studied — you can be a forgiveness expert. A growing body of research shows that best way to forgive comes from exercising the moral virtue of forgiveness, even if there is no justice or hope of reconciliation. When we are good, within reason, to an offender, we will reduce our anger, anxiety and depression and improve our self-esteem and hope (Robert Enright) — a good reason to forgive is to protect your health!
We dare not conflate forgiveness and reconciliation. People often do, but we dare not. Forgiveness is not dependent on reconciliation, restitution or justice. The offer of forgiveness can be unconditional, not dependent on the other’s response at all, including an apology. Forgiveness like that looks like Jesus, right? Reconciliation is much more likely if it begins with that kind of forgiveness.
Reconciliation, when at least one party is deeply and unfairly hurt, is the fruit of forgiveness and apology and is conditional; it depends on how the offending party or parties understand their hurtful ways and change. Reconciliation like that looks like what Jesus is trying to build, right?
A forgiver is motivated by their desire to be rid of resentment and act as good as is possible toward an offending person. If that person has no inner sorrow, never intends to apologize or to make amends, you don’t need to act as if they do. Yet, you can still have the intention to reconcile if the person changes and a relationship becomes safe. You can even show an outward quality of forgiveness, for example, by not talking disparagingly about the offender to others. If you do that, you’ll be working out Romans 12:18: “If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone.” If a person keeps abusing you, you can struggle for peace instead of just struggling against hurt. You don’t need to bear their responsibility.
Why not be healthy? If you reject forgiving because you conflate it with reconciliation, you deprive yourself of a chance to recover, lead a healthy psychological life, and even live a healthy relational life with others (if not necessarily with the offending person). Deep anger from injustices can lead to a lack of trust in general, thwarting potentially life-giving relationships.
How we think about forgiveness is important. If we make the mistake of waiting for an apology or holding out for an ideal reconciliation, we allow an offending person or a random act of cruelty dominate us for a long time, maybe even for a lifetime if the wound is deep enough. Forgiveness is a character trait healthy adults exercise. They can suffer the disappointment and loss of not being reconciled. They rely on faith, hope and love more than their capacity to create a preferred harmony. We are free to forgive, if we choose, regardless of the outcome, even if someone refuses to apologize.
*****************************
Today is William Seymour Day! Talk about a person who had a lot to forgive! He managed the trials with a radical faith fueled by the Holy Spirit! Read all about him at The Transhistorical Body.
The post Should I forgive someone if they won’t apologize? appeared first on Development.
September 21, 2026
Your pot of anger — a psalm
My pot boils.
I don’t attend it until the liquid is gone
and a dark, dead scum is left
to scrape off and wash away.
Whole kettles have been lost.
Sometimes a simmer
bubbles all day, attended and fragrant,
and a deadly anger turns to action,
into something to be savored
like a done just enough stew.
If one is evil, vengeance is food,
the feast of the grave
waiting by the door, unmastered.
If one is good, the feast is justice,
like a dug up garden
soaking up love to produce good fruit.
So don’t leave your pot untended.
Follow the fragrance up to your room.
Kneel on your bench and listen well,
or your heart will grow dry
and your mind imprisoned by your fears.
Anger needs to simmer.
Some days it is stew.
Some days it is death.
If not cooked in God’s kitchen,
who would know?
September 14, 2026
It is revenge week: Check your marriage and other loves
I have been shocked, at times, by married couples who are committed to revenge. For instance, I discovered part of the engagement ritual for over 50% of millennials includes making a pre-nuptial agreement — for one of my clients, at least, it was to pre-game the inevitable vengeance they expected when they divorced.
Bush vows revenge. Click for video.I wondered this week if such habitual revenge might be the American way. After all, it is 9/11 week and we paused to remember the thousands of people killed that day — and we’ve begun to remember who-knows-how-many first responders and others who were poisoned by the air they were encouraged to live in. What’s more, we endured the president trying to insert himself into the day as if he did something heroic in 2001– even if he did, no one would believe him at this point.
It is the week we are encouraged to reset our mind on revenge. Pete Hegseth connected the attack on the Pentagon on 9/11 to the present debacle in Iran, while quoting scripture inaccurately, saying the Pentagon is “ever vigilant” to “enemies who hate us.”
“We’re still sending terrorists where they belong—to hell. And tankers to the bottom of the ocean where they belong, and we are ensuring that Iran will never have a nuclear weapon. The economic pressure tightens every day.” – the gospel according to Hegseth
The ex-president, mayors, and billionaires came out to NYC so we could again be persuaded the 8 trillion dollars spent on the first 20 years of the Wars on Terror and the 900,000 people lost amounted to appropriate revenge.
Here in Pennsylvania, insult is added to injury since Senator Fetterman increasingly becomes some kind of Republican because he is convinced Israel’s ongoing genocidal revenge for the October 7, 2023 attack (by the ever-vengeful Hamas) on Israeli citizens is warranted. Maybe he is scared — if some politician questions the right of Israel to use overwhelming force in the cause of justice/revenge, they might be attacked by AIPAC. Although some Hasidic Jews are speaking out against it all.
It is obviously not just Americans who are vicious. I have Britbox now, so I know that one of the most popular shows is another remake of A Woman of Substance. The blatant theme of that story is revenge – what it does to ruin love and why the heroine does not care to be distracted from her purpose in spite of that fact.
Pray as you goI wish everyone, especially married couples, would listen to the Pray as You Go session we heard as we walked on September 10. “Love your enemies” is what Hegseth should be quoting. If one cannot master the Sermon on the Mount she can skip the rest of the Bible until she does.
I loved the sweet song they offered. I might have altered the chorus to plead with God directly: “Lover of enemies, even the children of your Father, who can’t love their enemies, teach us to love.” Here is the link, if you want to try it out: [link].
The enemy is not in faraway Iran where we can bomb them from Las Vegas. The enemy is not just the Emma Harte in your life vowing to destroy your family. It is also the person you are love the most, who hurts you the best and arouses the temptation to take revenge. Let’s not give in, even if it seems normal.
Marriage is the lab of loving enemies.Don’t get me wrong, I see people who have delightful mates who love them deeply even though they see them without rose-colored glasses.
But I am saddened by the many people I see who have been wounded, betrayed and even abused, deeply or slightly, who feel it is only right they should get even. Have we all been influenced by the War on Terror?
It is sad how petty we can be. We are tempted to monitor how we are being wounded, betrayed and abused in the most minute way. I hear people say,
“I know I am going to make them mad at me,”so they are predisposed to to be hurtand so feel justified to “get even”even before anything has happened!Their mate is under surveillance! What in the world is “even” in a relationship anyway? I can understand developing reciprocity, but let’s not measure it.
On our neighborhood group chat the other day, a wife suggested her husband should not go out and talk to the person shaking our windows with the bass they were blasting because, “There are too many hateful, crazy people out here!” So much for all you need to love.
Let me say again, being hateful to someone hateful results in more hatefulness. Assuming others are crazy before you know them is craziness. Keeping your sweet, religious husband from talking to strangers is stealing his joy. Avoiding the possibility of conflict or the work of reconciliation will not bring peace. We need to build love, sanity, joy and peace person by person, if necessary. Right? Marriage is a basic place to do it.
Is revenge how we “stay safe?”Revenge is about control and certainty — my own power to keep myself safe. We can see how nations failed to succeed at that in Afghanistan and Gaza. I regularly see the same goal unmet by married partners who won’t give up on it. These are a few questions I had this week when I thought about that:
Can’t such a person see they are making their mate afraid to commit some tiny infraction? Whatever they do is scrutinized. “You did not say anything after I weeded the garden.” or “You left your socks out.” A lot of sentences include “you.” And a lot of them imply, I need to be able to rely on you to not mess up what I require — or else.Do you really need to correct things your mate says? They seem to be in a competition for who is the rightest, as if being right will protect something. I am usually in a small group of married couples most weeks. It is common to have one partner tell a story and the other one to edit it. You need to defeat their sentence? Do you really need a pre-nup? One person said they were afraid to get married if they couldn’t nip the potential revenge in the bud. I am sad if it was already budding during the engagement! I am almost positive the relationship is going to have a high hurdle of mistrust to overcome on the way to a harmonious life together. You hired adversarial, U.S. lawyers to preside at your pre-marriage ceremony? Aren’t you spreading hopelessness when you can’t forgive you partner for not healing your childhood wounds? I was musing about someone wanting to “be found” last week. That desire is kin to being “seen” and “known” — experiences most people want. But digging in your heals in front of various doors to intimacy until you are satisfied your partner has met your demands may not be the best way to receive what you need. Certainty-or-else seems like a recipe for relationship disaster.We have a lot of ways to get even. Therapists call them “micro aggressions” when they are relational paper-cuts getting infected. Sometimes the aggression goes nuclear and activates the pre-nup! Unfortunately, a lot of us think that’s just normal life.
Preoccupation with getting and being even, staying safe, exercising control undoubtedly has many good reasons behind it; none of the reasons create trust and deepen love. We might want to start unraveling it by considering how the U.S. society has been promoting revenge for the past 25 years. Maybe we’re trained for it.
Some of your fear about being invaded and your commitment to preserve first-strike capabilities might be in league with The War on Terror. But any hint of relational terrorism in a marriage sets off the cycle of revenge everyone is already afraid of. To be happy, we could at least not meet revenge with revenge. At best, we could love our enemies.
****************
It is John Chrysostom Day! Get to know this famous leader in the early church at The Transhistorical Body.
The post It is revenge week: Check your marriage and other loves appeared first on Development.September 7, 2026
Being found: Six things we can do to get there
I have a love-hate relationship going with my memory of the entry closet of my childhood home. I remember it fondly because it was the first place I was given the privilege of painting (which might have been as soon as I could hold a brush in my situation). So it is symbolically a place where I was trusted and counted worthy.
But before I was painting it, it was a place I would hide. I think one of my earliest memories is hiding from my mother in the closet and waiting for her to find me. We weren’t playing hide and seek, I just disappeared. And she did not come to find me. I waited for what seemed like a long time in the dark before I peaked out the door. I could hear her voice in the kitchen talking on the land line. I came up to her and pulled on her dress. She looked down at me and did that sweeping up, “Shoo!” gesture and whispered, with her hand over the mouthpiece, “Go play.” I started to say, “But you did not find me.” But she had already straightened up and was laughing that wonderful laugh of hers. So I just went to my room to look around at the toys again.
I don’t think I ever told her about that. But as you can see, I never forgot that one small moment of being lonely, invisible, and not worth finding. It is no wonder we all seem to have shame sticking to the walls of our inner selves. The tiniest things collect and build up like plaque.
Maybe your mate wants to be foundI thought of myself not long ago when a woman was lamenting how her husband seemed uninterested in “finding” her. She used the word. And she was not the first to do so. So many partnered people have trouble when they feel their partner leaves them alone; they are like babies in the crib who woke up by themselves and aren’t sure someone is coming to get them. We really want our mates to meet us there. It feels like they should do something about this attachment issue that keeps popping up. Some of us might get anxious because we don’t want to risk the possibility that they won’t find us and will never share the deep fears and loneliness we might carry.
I hope you will be found by your loved ones. But I am not counting on it. I hope you will be sensitive enough to find people, even find yourself. But I would not be surprised if you had already blown so many opportunities to do that, you’re not sure you should make any promises.
The movies don’t help. Those people are getting found all the time! We love watching it happen — why else would we watch the Hallmark Channel so religiously? The first example that comes to my mind is “Dear Even Hansen.” That might be because I’ve seen a few choirs of young people giving their hearts to singing the main song: “You Will Be Found.” The hope of being found is apparently a universal feeling, so this song has been sung around the world a few times. The other side of the song is moving, too, so people feel terrible when they realize they didn’t look for someone before they got left alone. The the song has made a lot of people cry.
But I think the song promises too much. You might not be found and need to do something about it yourself. What’s more, everyone might be waiting for you to show up rather than looking for you, or might be kind of paralyzed by the idea you might not want to be found by them, or might not be too aware or even able to notice you’re gone. You might need more than what humans can provide. Wonder about those things as you listen to the song. I provided the lyrics for you.
Have you ever felt like nobody was there?
Have you ever felt forgotten in the middle of nowhere?
Have you ever felt like you could disappear?
Like you could fall, and no one would hear?
Well, let that lonely feeling wash away
Maybe there’s a reason to believe you’ll be okay
‘Cause when you don’t feel strong enough to stand
You can reach, reach out your hand
And oh, someone will come runnin’
And I know they’ll take you home
Even when the dark comes crashing through
When you need a friend to carry you
And when you’re broken on the ground
You will be found
So let the sun come streamin’ in
‘Cause you’ll reach up and you’ll rise again
Lift your head and look around
You will be found
You will be found
You will be found
You will be found
You will be found
The message most people latch onto when they hear Evan Hansen sing is “You are not alone.” For all you people feeling alone even though you are in good relationships, I can say “You are not alone” – maybe you are not together with your loved one the way you wish you were, but there is more than your wishes. And for those of you who didn’t find someone who needed you, you are not alone, either. We all carry a lot of shame, but that doesn’t mean you are alone with it.
What we can do to be found and findI remember thinking my mother decided not to find me and just left me alone. That hurt. I did not ask her about her motivation, but surely she could not have been unaware I was gone somewhere! – after all, she could hear me stealing candy from the cupboard a mile away! When I finally went out and pulled on her dress and got an irritated, “I’m talking on the phone!” That fact did not undo my feeling.
Your adult loved ones might be just as difficult. Dealing with your mate’s attachment issues can feel perilous, but it is so helpful if you do! Here are a few things to notice and try if you’d like to feel found and like to feel adept at finding people.
1) See one another. In my opinion, Mom should have put down the phone and given me some loving eye contact. That might have demonstrated I was important and not just a nuisance. Same for mates; they need validation and reassurance.
She also could have kept track of me. It is OK to keep track of your mate; you’re not impinging upon their freedom or losing your own if you do. You might need to negotiate how much closeness and how much distance your relationship needs in order to get to your “happy medium.” But you’ll probably be happier if you try.
I have known a few people who say, “I think I will be happier if I don’t try. That kind of noticing is way too much to ask.” In that case the song would be “You are alone.” Because everyone is working out how to attach their whole life. They at least need to be seen.
2) Be yourself, not God. If someone asks to be seen it does not make you God, as if you could be all-seeing, all knowing and the answer to someone’s prayers. Don’t say “No” because you already think you will fail. Everyone fails. You’re probably good enough, even if you are facing a need in your partner that demands more than you have.
Facing the “demand” is what a lot of people mean when they talk about “showing up.” You stop hiding and risk finding. Just don’t take on all those expectations as if you are responsible to succeed at them. Just keep moving into your true self.
3) Listen. Listening for someone matters. They might be making a distant noise in their closet. If it seems too demanding to be so intense, your heart might need to get bigger. All intimate relationships grow our hearts. For instance, a client assumed his wife was self-reliant, but she was really a person who had to fend for herself because no one else did. She would say how needy she was and then behave like she was not needy. It was easier to relate to the unneedy one. But she was left feeling the ancient feeling of being left alone she hated so much. He learned to listen better and to move into what he heard.
4) Try not to hide. When I expected my mother to find me when she did not have a clue about what I’d decided to to, it was a recipe for not getting what I wanted. Fortunately, I did not hide in the closet every day trying to train her to find me on demand! But it would not be surprising if you and I were stubborn enough to try something like that.
We feel it is unjust to have to change rather than someone else changing. “Others seem to get found, why shouldn’t I be cared for like that?” If we just suffer the injustice of it all, the person who is loving you the best they can becomes someone who just holds out on you, but all the while you’re the one in the closet. It may pain you to do so, but you may need to come out and make yourself known, rather than insisting someone else has to do the work.
5) Make sure someone is listening. It takes quite a bit of humility to ask for what we really want. When you dare to do it, be sure to help the one you’re asking hear you. If I say, “I want to feel found. I want you to see me” in a way they can’t hear, that’s not really their fault. If I am just hurt and angry and I make them seem like a fool or a fiend when I tell them, their defenses will spring into action. Then we won’t be on the subject of what I am really hoping any more. We need to help people hear us now that we are adults. The crib is long gone. Being weak in a strong way is rarely a good way to get what we need.
6) Be found by God. Jesus is well known for saying he is seeking the lost in order to give them life and joy. So there is ONE person who is interested in finding you. There is a hopeful verse in Jeremiah about this big part of God’s love:
For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, says the Lord, thoughts of peace and not of evil, to give you a future and a hope. Then you will call upon Me and go and pray to Me, and I will listen to you. And you will seek Me and find Me, when you search for Me with all your heart. I will be found by you, says the Lord, and I will bring you back from your captivity. — Jeremiah 29:11-14
I love “I will be found of you.” The best way to be found by some one is to be found of them. You are more likely to be found if you let them see you and struggle gracefully with them. To be fair to Evan Hansen, the movie goes on to teach just that. He needs to let himself be known and go through the pain of being accepted as he really is. He gets way down the road to being his true self, as a result.
Artists like the people who made “Dear Evan Hansen” keep coming up with ways to tell the parables of living in love because 80% of us are preoccupied with how to be known and loved and how to know and be loving every day. We’re the sought seekers we were created to be.
The post Being found: Six things we can do to get there appeared first on Development.

