David K. Shipler's Blog
November 12, 2026
Trump's Dictatorship Meets American Democracy
By David K. Shipler
A couple ofyears ago, Liz Cheney, the prominent Republican who broke dramatically withDonald Trump, told me that to restore traditional conservatism and alsopreserve constitutional democracy, Americans would have to defeat theRepublican Party all the way down the ballot. She was sure it would happen, andit just did.
But will it be enough? Euphoricrhapsodies perform very well right now. The rout of Republicans in the midtermsextended from Congress deep into state governments, even reaching some Trumpstrongholds. The surge of disaffected voters generated a political upheaval. Democracydemonstrated its formidable force.
But is this the end of theTrumpists’ march to autocracy? Or just a temporary pause in the decline ofconstitutional norms and pluralistic values?
In the first two years of hissecond term, Trump has mobilized like-minded minions in the executive,legislative, and judicial branches to award him one-man powers that underminethe Framers’ ingenious structure of checks and balances. He has created a semi-dictatorshipwith little accountability for the high crimes of political prosecutions and crueltyby thugs wearing ICE jackets. He has placed white supremacists in keypositions; peddled racist slanders; ignored court orders; exacted retributionfor dissent; destroyed scientific research; provoked a brain drain from thegovernment and the country; compromised national security; ravaged the militaryleadership; and punished universities, law firms, corporations, charities, andnews organizations that do not toe his line.
Whether these draconian policieswill change is a question. Predictions are unreliable in this age of volatility.The most valid insights are offered by the present, which is a complex balancesheet.
On the one hand, the sweepingDemocratic wins cracked Trump’s aura of authority; his unpopularity drove downRepublican votes and helped defeat his most visible hand-picked candidates, whichincluded those of damaged character.
Therefore, it seems possible, butnot certain, that his mafia-like threats against esteemed institutions andmembers of his own party will be taken less seriously. It’s possible, but not certain,that some Republicans will see their political interest in defying him. It’spossible, but not certain, that his political appointees who have populatedexecutive agencies will be less deferent, especially when they’ll faceoversight by Democratic-led congressional committees. Those less visible appointeeswill be important to watch, for no autocrat rules alone; every one relies on aphalanx of willing subordinates.
On the other hand, the firstpost-election reflexes have been combative. Trump’s new chief of staff, StephenMiller, has the sympathies and impulses of a white nationalist, denigrating generationsof immigrant cultures and declaring his wish for a regime without judges—thatis, without checks on executive power. His absolutism owes no allegiance to themiraculous competition of ideas that has been the precious nourishment ofAmerican society. He can be expected to wield dogmatic command over federalagencies.
Furthermore, Trump has virtuallyignored the legislative branch, spending funds that were not appropriated andwithholding funds that were. Now his White House is mobilizing lawyers to resistDemocrats’ subpoenas and fight in court any charges of contempt of Congress against officials who refuse to testify.
Then, too, the House Republicans havemade a statement of combative radicalism by electing Jim Jordan as their leader.Jordan, a former wrestler and wrestling coach, also knows no shades ofcontemplation or compromise. He is a firebrand, relishing the rhetoricaltriumph without the hard work of legislating. He is gearing for fight afterfight against Democrats who want to bring accountability to Trump’s WhiteHouse.
How this plays out for theRepublican Party is unclear. My conversation with Liz Cheney began with myasking how she thought true, traditional conservatism might be restored, withits principles of fiscal responsibility and small government—opposites of whatTrump’s revised party supports. Cheney, you’ll recall, lost the Republican primaryfor her House seat from Wyoming after becoming vice chair of the January 6committee, which detailed Trump’s attempt to block the peaceful transfer ofpower. Wyoming voters valued the Trump cult of personality over the monumentalprinciples of the Constitution.
Cheney’s prescription for immenseelectoral losses sounded like a wish for the party’s demise. The question iswhether something resembling the old, more moderate party can be revived. Sofar, just a week after the election, its surviving legislators in Congress showno signs of learning the lessons most voters sent.
As for those voters: On the onehand, millions of citizens, deeply resentful of the status quo, generated a majorpolitical turn not by going into the streets, as in France, but by using theestablished, orderly process of elections. They thereby engaged with a systemthat Trump has slandered and worked hard to undermine. And the system worked. “TheAmerican people” (the catch-all label politicians are so fond of using adnauseum) distinguished themselves from residents of typical autocracies, wheredefeated masses often withdraw into the sullen alienation that comes ofpowerlessness.
Furthermore, the high turnout ofBlacks, who rallied against the Republican gerrymandering and Supreme Courtrulings aimed at diluting their voting power, helped elect Scott Colom as thefirst Black senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction. It was a close call,but finally an inspiring surge of people power.
That’s on the one hand. On theother, most of the rebellion at the ballot box was driven less by worries aboutthe dying democracy than by transitory economic hardships brought on by Trumphimself—and by the unseemly spectacle of him and his family ostentatiouslyenriching themselves with more blatant corruption than any prior president.
Corruption is often the Achillesheel of dictatorships. Some Democratic candidates adeptly juxtaposed Trump’s lustfor luxury with the everyday struggles of ordinary folks. (It’s worthremembering that both the American and French Revolutions were also driven inlarge measure by economic anger.)
Yet for those of us worried aboutthe rise of authoritarianism, a more satisfying revolt would have favored therule of law, the Bill of Rights, the Constitution’s separation of powers, theinsulation of prosecutors from politics, and respect for the country’s reveredinstitutions of pluralism.
I used to tell Russians who wouldlisten during my four years covering the Soviet Union that while they valuedthe strength of a single idea, Americans valued the din of many ideas. I couldnot say that with such confidence now, given a president, elected twice, whodecries that din, and who has just named a chief of staff who does the same.
Trump’s zealous activists have notgone away, nor will they disappear from American culture even if a Democratwins the White House in 2028. They are well enough organized to sit on thesidelines waiting for the wheel to turn again in their favor. They have tastedblood in these two years—the blood of power and victory—and it’s easy toimagine them regrouping, as they did after Trump lost in 2020.
What’s most frightening about themis their totalitarian mindset. I use the term advisedly. I saw it in SovietCommunist days: apparatchiks who seek to infuse a narrow set of ideologicalprinciples throughout all of civil society, and to use whatever state powerthey can mobilize to coerce that society into conformity.
These Trump years have providedenough evidence of hero-worship and capitulation to caution against readingthis election as a permanent awakening. Despite Americans’ ideals of flintyindividualism, their weak civics instruction in schools and their susceptibilityto right-wing propaganda suggest a gullible electorate vulnerable to the nextautocratic demagogue.
As the New York Times columnist M.Gessen noted recently:
“The experience of other countriesshows that autocratic leaders are peculiarly difficult to unseat, and not justbecause they have a tendency to undermine the voting process itself. The moreinstability voters live with—the higher the gas prices, the more tenuous theiraccess to health care, the more palpable the threat of war—the stronger theautocrats’ appeal, even when it was their policies that caused theinstability.”
November 2, 2026
Israel's Opportunity
By David K. Shipler
It finallyhappened. Enough Arab citizens of Israel, who make up about 20 percent of thepopulation, voted in consolidated blocs last week to gain leverage over whogoverns the country. Now the question is whether Jewish leaders will let theminto a ruling coalition, and whether Arab parties want to join. The answer willdefine the scope of Israel’s democracy.
This is a rare moment ofopportunity for Israel, perhaps, to begin to redeem some of the moral authorityit lost in Gaza and reverse its growing repute as a pariah state. It has longtouted itself as the only democracy in the Middle East, but it has not been afull democracy for its Arab citizens, whose elected members of the Knesset, Israel’sparliament, have rarely been welcomed into the halls of executive power.
Arabs in Israel belong to familiesthat stayed in Israel during the country’s 1948 war of independence. Theyneither fled the fighting nor were expelled by the Jewish forces. While many nowprefer to be called Palestinians, their Israeli residence and citizenshipdifferentiate them from the Palestinian Arabs in Gaza and the West Bank—territoriesconquered in the 1967 war—who live under Israeli rule but cannot vote inIsraeli elections. Those inside Israel, who can vote, have faced decades offrustration.
With no single party ever winning amajority in the Knesset, every government has relied on coalition-buildingacross a range of religious and political affiliations. But Arab-led partieshave been included only in Israel’s founding government led by David Ben-Gurionin 1949, and then briefly in 2021. In accepting two Arab members of theDemocratic List of Nazareth (one of whom fought with Jews in Israel’s War ofIndependence), Ben-Gurion aimed “to show that Jews and Arabs could coexist inthe new State of Israel,” writesZach Rothbart, a journalist in Jerusalem.
Today, however, Arab parties are widely deridedas threats to the state’s security and Jewish identity, so vilified thatpolitical rivals have been willing to join together in Arab-free “unity”governments or settle for new elections instead of embracing Arab legislatorsas fellow cabinet ministers. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is claimingwithout evidence that Arab voters were bribed by foreign entities, that theelection was “stolen by Arab parties that support terrorism and the eliminationof the Jewish state,” and that any Jewish party inviting them into a coalitiongovernment will facilitate the “Islamization of Israel.” His son, Yair, calledArab citizens the second-largest threat after a nuclear-armed Iran.
The current backroom wheeling anddealing among the parties will be a lesson to Arabs on whether voting isworthwhile. After decades of boycotts, alienation, and fragmentation, they surgedto the polls out of “frustration and fear” accordingto The Times of Israel, and their two parties won a record 19 seatsin the 120-member Knesset. (Netanyahu’s Likud won 27; the party of his mainopponent, Gadi Eisenkot, won 21.)
Arab political leaders campaignedhard to raise hopes that the system might work for them; the highest turnout inIsrael was in the Arab town of Sakhnin, at 87%. If that hope is dashed duringthe Jewish parties’ negotiations, cynicism is likely to deepen and the cause ofdemocratic pluralism will suffer.
Netanyahusurely won’t partner with the Arabs, and if he did, he’d lose essential supportfrom Arab-hating parties farther to the right. If Eisenkot goes with Arabs, heand his supporting parties are like to pay a political price, especially inlight of the sharpened anti-Arab feelings in a country traumatized by the Hamasattack and hostage-taking of October 7, 2023.
To be an Arab citizen of Israel isto suffer crosscurrents of uncomfortable identities: in Israel, disdained as anArab; in the larger Arab world, disdained as an Israeli. Polls show largemajorities yearning for complete participation in Israeli society yetexperiencing discrimination. They are simultaneously apart and separate. Manycannot in good conscience sing the Israeli national anthem, in which “theJewish soul yearns . . . An eye gazes toward Zion.” Some stand silently whenit’s played, some stay seated, some walk away.
Yet pollingby the Israel Democracy Institute shows most Arab citizens regard Israel as “agood place to live,” (62%, compared with 66% of Jews); think Arabs shouldintegrate and be part of Israeli society (90%, compared with 50.5% of Jews); andare certain that they want their children to continue living in Israel (66%,compared with 55% of Jews).
Dramatic Jewish-Arab differences appear inother areas: Are Arabs discriminated against? Yes, say 82% of Arab respondentsand 30.5% of Jews. Is it better for Jews and Arabs to live separately? Yes, say25% of Arabs and 48.5% of Jews. For security, is it okay for the state tomonitor what citizens post online? Yes, say 47% of Arabs and 62% of Jews. Areyou proud to be Israeli? Yes, say 44% of Arabs and 83% of Jews.
The percentages of people who saythey’re afraid to express their political opinions rose from 2016 to 2025, from45% to 70% of Arabs, and from 37% to 53% of Jews, a measure of the intimidationfelt across the society since the October 7 assault.
Strong agreement that “the use ofviolence for political ends is never justified” was registered by 49% of Arabsand 68.5% of Jews. But a significant minority of Arab respondents, 26%, disagreedstrongly or “somewhat” with that rejection of political violence, compared withjust 8.5% of Jews.
Although both Arab parties condemnedthe Hamas attack, the Joint List, which won 11 seats, has called Israel’s massiveretaliatory war in Gaza “genocide,” and the status of Palestinians on the WestBank “apartheid.” Its leaders say that they would vote to support anopposition-led government headed by Eisenkot but do not want to be in thecabinet. The more moderate Arab-led party, Ra’am, won 8 seats with a Jewish ex-copas second on its list; its Muslim leader, Mansour Abbas hasaccepted Israel as a Jewish state and would presumably join a coalition ifinvited.
However, only27% of Jews favor Arab parties being in the government, according to a surveylast year. To override that sentiment would take a brave gamble by Eisenkot andother opposition leaders, not the kind of courage usually demonstrated bypoliticians. Therefore, the stage is set for the opportunity to become a missedopportunity.October 9, 2026
Fearing the Voters
By David K. Shipler
A paradoxof dictatorship is its vulnerability. The pinnacle of power feels precarious.The people must not be allowed to gather force.
Infull-blown dictatorships, such as China and the Soviet Union, the autocracy ispreserved by outright oppression: sham elections, imprisonments, politicalassassinations. In democracies evolving into autocracies, such as the UnitedStates, the methodology is more complex. Alternative power centers—the press,the judiciary, the legislature, the universities—are undermined and tamed,often by twisting legal tools into political weapons.
A key target is the voting process.
So it is that Donald Trump attemptsto rule the United States, with the upcoming midterm elections a specialproject of manipulation and intimidation.
In a term less than half over, hehas already grown the executive branch into a semi-dictatorship. Practically alone,he decides how taxes are spent, how wars are fought, how foreign trade isconducted, how allies are treated, what scientific research is pursued, which opponentsare prosecuted. He tries to decree what history is taught, what data iscollected, what genders exist, what vaccines are administered, what artportrays, whom law firms defend, what vocabulary is banned. Even in the privatesector, the noble aspirations of diversity, equity, and inclusion are forbiddenunder penalty of funding loss and investigation.
Trump rarely defers to Congress orthe courts. He evades both the legislature’s budgets and many rulings byfederal district judges. His Republican majority in Congress is cowed, and hisRepublicans on appeals courts and the Supreme Court usually acquiesce. As aresult, in the face of the Trumpists’ zealotry, the Framers’ ingeniousmechanism of checks and balances among government’s three branches has sputteredpractically to a halt.
And now comes an election. It is adanger point for the fearful at the top. Their totalitarian mindset, whichseeks ideological conformity throughout society, risks repudiation. Trump’saura of power, wielded with mafia-like threats, confronts the curse of obsolescence.A dirty fight is in the offing.
Although bullies like Trump arealso cowards, he has surrounded himself with acolytes who worship hisauthoritarianism, who are ruthless and contemptuous of democratic norms. How Americanconstitutional culture produced such people is a confounding question, but nowthat they govern, they have tasted blood and are poised to slash the electoralprocess with every available means. Do not expect retreat from mercilesscharacters who are backed into a corner.
They began immediately in Trump’ssecond term. His Justice Department droppedongoing lawsuits challenging restrictive election laws that worked againstBlack voters. The department’s voting-rights unit was decimated, from about thirtyofficials to fewer than ten. Security protections against Chinese, Russian, andIranian hacking and internet deception were downgraded or demolished: theCybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency gutted,the FBI task force to counter foreign influence dismantled,the system of intelligence-sharing with local and state officials on cyberthreats terminated.
Trump now seeks to intimidate localelection workers by threatening criminal prosecutions if any ineligible voterscast ballots, although hardly any such fraud has been identified. He calls forfederal control of elections whose conduct the Constitution explicitly assignsto the states.
Like a massive drone attack, someof his weapons get through while some are repelled by the corroded shield of checksand balances. His executive order requiring proof of citizenship to vote wasblocked by a judge, and his attempt to curtail mail-in ballots (used by moreDemocrats than Republicans) has been stymied in the courts. Nor has he beenable to get Congress to pass his proposed law mandating those and otherrestrictions.
His Justice Department has sued 30states for personal details on their registered voters; judges havedismissed 26 of the suits, while 16 Republican-led states have complied byproviding driver’s licenses, Social Security numbers, and other information onindividuals. He wanted the Postal Service to refuse to deliver any ballots instates that did not comply with his data demand, but a preliminary injunction againstthe draconian step was upheld by the Supreme Court.
Trump’s campaign to sow distrust inelections has continued unabated. Adherents of his lie that he won in 2020 nowpopulate the highest reaches of his administration, from attorneys general PamBondi and Todd Blanche to head of the civil rights division Harmeet Dhillon to FBIdirector Kash Patel. Driven by Trump’s obsession to prove his fantasy ofvictory, officials slavishly mobilize prosecutorial powers: The FBI seizedballots from 2020 in two Georgia and Arizona jurisdictions. The JusticeDepartment isseeking the names of all 2020 election officials in Fulton County, Georgia.And anyone who wants to be nominated for a federal judgeship must not speak thetruth and say that Joe Biden was duly elected.
The purpose is not just to rewritethe past but to lay the groundwork for the future, one that opens the public’sminds to false claims of vote-rigging and election corruption. Barrages ofTrumpist lawsuits are inevitable following narrow Republican defeats in Houseraces next month. Both parties are enlisting battalions of lawyers forprotracted court cases that will probably rise to a Supreme Court that has beenTrump-friendly on most election issues. Close election results tied up in courtchallenges could delay seating newly-elected Democrats.
In anightmare scenario sketchedby the conservative former appeals court judge Michael Luttig, “even a decisivevictory for Democrats and a resounding repudiation of Trump and the MAGARepublicans at the polls in November will not guarantee that a Democraticmajority-elect will be seated in the 120th Congress on January 3,” he writes inThe New Republic. House Speaker Mike Johnson could orchestrate a refusalto seat Democratic members, Luttig warns. He outlines the procedure Johnsonmight use, noting that the Constitution makes each house “the Judge of theelections, Returns and Qualifications of its own Members.” He calls it Trump’s“final unlawful rampage,” which would ultimately be settled by a Supreme Court thathas facilitated Trump, granted him broad immunity from prosecution, and permittedmost of his swaggering lawlessness.
This Courthas already assaulted the electoral system by neutering the venerable 1965Voting Rights Act, which broke down many obstacles to Blacks’ politicalrepresentation. Since many more Blacks vote Democratic than Republican, theRepublicans in state legislatures and the courts have worked assiduously torestore their power to discriminate by gerrymandering and other means.
In 2013, the Supreme Courtoverturned the law’s longstanding provision requiring states and districts witha history of racial discrimination to pre-clear with the Justice Department anychange in its voting laws and procedures.
Then last April, the Court dealtthe act a fatal blow by ruling that it was no longer enough to document thediscriminatory effect of a districting map. Now, intent wouldhave to be shown, a virtually impossible proof when legislators are cannyenough not to say so out loud. Several states rushed to redistrict in favor ofRepublicans, with California and Virginia doing so to favor Democrats. (The newVirginia map was thrown out by the state’s supreme court on a proceduraltechnicality, leaving the Republicans with a net gain thanks to theRepublican-dominated Supreme Court.)
Dire predictions are being made.Trump might declare a state of emergency and seize ballots and voting machines.Trump might deploy troops to polling places. He might station ICE agents there,intimidating even US citizens whose complexions are not snowy white. After all,being detained by ICE, even mistakenly, has been less than delightful.
Whether all these methods, takentogether, will undermine the integrity of the elections is the question.Whether they are a dry run for the 2028 presidential election is the largerquestion. They are forms of defensive aggression, prompted by fear at the top ofthe voters at the bottom.
Experts who have studied transitions fromdemocracy to autocracy see what Steven Levitsky of Harvard calls “competitiveauthoritarianism” taking shape in the US—where an opposition exists but cannotovercome a rigged system to gain political power. Does that describe the UnitedStates? A tentative answer—but not the final one—will come on November 3 andits aftermath.
August 24, 2026
The Fractured Jewel of Constitutional Democracy
By David K. Shipler
WhilePresident Trump has gilded the Oval Office in gold, he has sullied the crownjewel of the Constitution. He has done so with the collaboration of hisRepublican allies in Congress and the Supreme Court. The latest example is hisWhite House ballroom, a superficial symbol of his deeper dictatorial passion.
There are many things wrong with Trump’sself-indulgent ballroom project: Its gargantuan bad taste (in Soviet-stylescale). Its elitist, flamboyant luxury when millions of Americans barely makeends meet (“Let them eat cake,” scoffed Marie Antoinette). Its gateway forcorrupt private contributors seeking presidential favors (“an offer he can’trefuse,” said the Godfather). Its deceptive use of public funds for the privatepampering of the leader (Putin, Orban, Marcos, etc.)
But most significantly,the ballroom is his latest hammer blow to the precious gem of the Americanconstitutional system: the separation of powers, the checks and balances soingeniously designed by the Framers who feared, presciently, the concentrationof authority as they formed a central government. They created legislative,executive, and judicial branches (in that order in the Constitution) to watchand restrain one another.
Trump has bulldozed through thosebulwarks. He did not deign to seek the legislature’s required approval beforedemolishing the East Wing of the White House, as if he were the owner, when it actually“belongs to the American people,” as Jacqueline Kennedy noted. He solicited“donations” to build an enormous ballroom but did not bother seekingcongressional appropriations for the balance of the estimated $600 million cost,which will evidently be paid from the pockets of unwilling taxpayers. Neitherof the other two branches of government is stopping him, not theRepublican-controlled Congress nor the Republican-controlled Supreme Court,whose chief justice ruled last week that construction could continue for thetime being.
One wondersif the Framers had imagined how supine the legislative and judicial brancheswould become, how readily they would abdicate their roles.
“All men having power ought to bedistrusted to a certain degree,” James Madison told his fellow delegates to theConstitutional Convention in that hot Philadelphia summer of 1787. Defending the draft of the Constitution thefollowing year, Madison wrote in Federalist No. 47:“The accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in thesame hands, whether of one, a few, or many, and whether hereditary, self-appointed,or elective, may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny.”
And so wearrive at the edge of tyranny as the legislative and judicial branches combinetheir acquiescence to award Trump’s executive branch the power to remakegovernment.
As if the Constitution had neverbeen written, the president and his collaborators, including Elon Musk and hisso-called Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), unilaterally slashed thelegislature’s appropriations for foreign aid, domestic spending, and scientificresearch. By cutting off funds and firing employees, Trump and Musk effectivelyeliminated agencies Congress had created, including the US Agency forInternational Development; the US Institute for Peace (dwarfed and renamed forTrump); the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau; and the US Agency for GlobalMedia, which ran the international broadcasters, Voice of America and Radio FreeEurope/Radio Liberty. The legislative branch, under the thumb of Trump’s dominionover his fellow Republicans, slept through its constitutional duty.
No peep was heard from theRepublican-led Senate to defend the body’s authority to confirm presidentialappointees under the Appointment Clause of Article II, Section 2, whichrequires the Senate’s “advice and consent,” even for a temporary figure like Musk,given the extent of his power, as a lawsuit argued. A federal district courtjudge agreed,noting that without going through the Senate, “the Appointments Clause would bereduced to nothing more than a technical formality.” But the judge’spreliminary injunction was swept away by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.
Such has been a pattern in thejudicial branch, where many district judges have temporarily blocked Trump’sactions, only to have their injunctions overturned in the appeals courts andthe Supreme Court, which has acted hastily in its “emergency docket” whererulings are not justified by citing law, precedent, or the Constitution.
Emboldened by the higher courts’acquiescence, Trump and his officials frequently ignore lower judges’ orders,especially in immigration cases. At least 31 flagrant violations of courtorders (about 1 in 8 cases) involving widespread layoffs, funding cuts, and thedetention of immigrants were tabulatedin an Associated Press survey.
The administration’s defiance hadimmediate consequences. Even after a judge ordered the Education Department toretain mental health funding, for example, the Trump administration continuedto block the money, forcing the dismissal of mental health professionals fromthe school system in Eureka, California.
Similarly, Trump officials refusedto comply with a judge’s order to restore the longstanding practice of allowingimmigration detainees to post bond and be freed pending the resolution of theircases. Judge Sunshine Sykes, a Biden nominee, accused the administration oftrying “to erode any semblance of separation of powers,” as if “in a worldwhere the Constitution does not exist.”
The Supreme Court has blocked onemethod Trump has used to exact tariffs, but he’s using alternative means. Ithas blocked his executive order barring birthright citizenship for anyone bornin the US. But it has put few other obstacles in the way of Trump’s marchtoward autocracy.
The six Republican-nominatedjustices, three of whom were selected by Trump, have enhanced the powers of theexecutive to the detriment of both the legislative branch, and even of theirown. For while district court judges who have ruled against Trump haveconducted full fact-finding procedures, considered briefs and held oralarguments, many of those carefully reasoned findings have been dismissivelybrushed aside by the six “conservative” justices, often with one-sentenceorders vacating injunctions and allowing the unprecedented onslaught by theWhite House to proceed.
Some of those right-wing justiceshave long supported a stronger executive. They have long questioned the abilityof Congress to create regulatory agencies whose commissioners could not befired by the president without cause. Now they have ruled that suchreplacements for no reason at all are permitted—except at the Federal Reserve,whose politicization would delegitimize US economic policy, bringing disruptionfor the wealthy, i.e., themselves. This guarantees dramatic swings inregulatory schemes from administration to administration, as in undemocratic countriesthat see repeated transfers from dictator to dictator.
The label “conservative” is amisnomer. What is it that the Republican justices and the Republicanlegislators seek to conserve? Not the separation of powers, obviously. Not the crownjewel of the Constitution. Had they lived during the American Revolution, whichside would they have been on?
July 2, 2026
Slavery and the Declaration of Independence
By David K. Shipler
A paragraphdenouncing slavery, written by a slaveowner, was deleted from the final versionof the Declaration of Independence. Yet the remaining language contained asoaring promise that abolitionists put to instant use in their cause. Thereinlies the great contradiction of the United States, a nation inspired by idealsand twisted by practice.
There is noway to cleanse American history, not honestly. It is torn between morality andreality, a place where fine myths and base cruelty coexist. We see that everyday as the country becomes unwelcoming to outsiders, more hostile toward itspoor, and willfully blind to racial injustice.
Myths are useful, though; they sethigh standards and can drive self-correction if—a big if—the problematic pastis faced squarely and not sanitized as the Trump Republicans are attempting.Societies that rely on fictions rarely do well.
The UnitedStates has endured a multiple personality for all of its 250 years, beginningwith its origin story of liberty alongside the enslavement of Black Africansand the slaughters of Native Americans. Both are elements of national character.And both shaped the Declaration of Independence, so erasing one side of thestory or the other falsifies patriotism. Genuine American patriotism lies in whatis precious about America: the freedom to embrace disturbing truths, a love forthe din of competing ideas.
In the fall of 1775 and the springof 1776, five men formed a drafting committee to compose the ringing documentwe Americans now celebrate.
One of those, Benjamin Franklin, ownedseveral enslaved workers and had profitedfrom advertisements in his newspaper by slaveowners seeking to sell their“property” or to capture runaways. He later became an avid abolitionist.Another, Robert Livingston, used slave laboron his New York estate.
Slavery was opposed by two members of thecommittee, Roger Sherman of Connecticut and John Adams of Massachusetts. Butthe fifth, Thomas Jefferson, embodied the cross-currents of his society,holding transcendent ideas larger than he was. He owned hundreds in bondage atMonticello, his Virginia plantation, but excoriated slavery in the draft of theDeclaration:
He [King George III]has waged a cruel war against human nature itself, violating it’s most sacredrights of life & liberty in the persons of a distant people who neveroffended him, captivating & carrying them into slavery in anotherhemisphere, or to incur miserable death in their transportation thither. Thispiratical warfare, the opprobrium of infidel powers, is the warfareof the CHRISTIAN king of Great Britain. Determined to keep open a market whereMEN should be bought and sold, he has prostituted his negative for suppressingevery legislative attempt to prohibit or to restrain this execrable commerce.
Jefferson’s paragraph was to occupya prominent place in the Declaration’s litany of indictments against the King.Yet the drafters ran into trouble as they sought unanimity in the 56-memberContinental Congress, about one-third of whom were slaveowners. Slavery wasstill legal in all 13 colonies. The paragraph did not survive, much to thechagrin of Jefferson, who continued to include it in copies he sent withcorrespondence.
What survived, as is well known, isthe famous sentence, with an anti-slavery nuance insisted upon by Adams: “Wehold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that theyare endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among theseare Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”
Life, liberty and property had beenlisted as natural rights back in 1689 by the English philosopher John Locke. ButAdams rejected “property” as connoting an acceptance of slavery, according tohistorian Danielle Allen, and “happiness” was substituted. “Pushing the word ‘property’out, replacing it with ‘happiness,’ was an abolitionist moment in the Declaration,”she said. “Indeed,the abolitionists used it immediately, in Boston, to submit a petition usingthat language for an end of slavery in Massachusetts.” (Before the end of theRevolutionary War, Adams wrote the abolition of slavery into the Massachusetts stateconstitution. Franklin got slavery outlawed in Pennsylvania.)
The Declaration’s soaring promisefeatured in a stirring1776 sermon by Lemuel Haynes, the first ordained Black minister in the US,who argued that the natural rights applied to all, that “an African, or, inother terms, that a Negro . . . has an undeniable right to his Liberty:Consequently, the practise of Slave-keeping, which so much abounds in this Landis illicit.”
He continued: “Those privilegesthat are granted to us By the Divine Being, no one has the Least right to takethem from us without our consen[t]; and there is Not the Least precept, orpractise, in the Sacred Scriptures, that constitutes a Black man a Slave, anymore than a white one.
“Therefore is it not hygh time toundo these heavy Burdens, and Let the Oppressed go free? And while you manifestsuch a noble and magnanimous Spirit, to maintain inviobly your own Naturalrights, and militate so much against Despotism, as it hath respect untoyourselves, you do not assume the Same usurpations, and are no Less tyrannic.Pray let there be a congruity amidst you Conduct, Least you fall amongst thatClass the inspir’d pen-man Speaks of. Rom. 2.21 and on. thou thereforewhich teacheth another, teachest thou not thy Self?”
Slavery did not end with the Declaration’sfine sentiments, obviously. It actually spread and deepened its economic roots.And the strands of our varied histories are still entangled. According to myfamily lore, which is partially documented, three of my ancestors fought in theRevolution, one on my father’s side at Bunker Hill, and two on my mother’s sidein Pennsylvania. But I have also wondered whether any of my ancestors wereslaveowners. Some lived in Maryland and Virginia before the Civil War, soperhaps. I am not sure.
Jeffersononce called slavery America’s “one fatal stain.” A stain cannot be blithelywashed away.
“Weroutinely return to Jefferson and his era in order to discover the glory ofAmerica,” wrotea Jefferson scholar, the late Charles A. Miller, in 1992. “We should also bewilling to return in order to find early evidence of our distress. . . . Ibelieve that Jefferson was firmly—centrally and emblematically—in the stream ofAmerican anguish over slavery and race, and he knew it. I also believe that thepresent, in altered form, is like Jefferson.”
June 18, 2026
Trump's Next War
By David K. Shipler
The ShiplerReport has obtained a confidential memo from the Republican National Committee toall senior officials, excluding President Trump, recommending a war plan forfuture major military assaults. Here is the text:
PRIVILEGED ANDCONFIDENTIAL
EYES ONLY, EXPOTUS
To: VP, SecWar,SecState, DNI, DNSA, DDIA, DCIA, JCOS, DNSC, COS--EXPOTUS
From: RNC WorkingGroup on Imagery (WGI)
Re: MAD(Mutually Assured Deception)
Under no circumstances is this memorandum to be shownto the greatest president in the 250-year history of the United States ofAmerica. He must be an innocent and unwitting collaborator in this project.
1. Inconsultation with numerous MAGA activists, RNC-contracted pollsters, and voterfocus groups, the ongoing WGI project on MAD has developed a war plan for the nextmilitary “expedition” that will eliminate risk and maximize (appeared) victory.
2. Inlight of the steep costs of the Iran war and the President’s mercurial shiftsin rhetorical goals, empty threats, and unrealistic objectives, we suggest amethod to be known as Paired Fantasies (PF).
3. Thepurpose of PF in the next so-called war is to balance the President’s fantasiesabout victory, as against Iran, with equally potent fantasies about a waritself.
4. Towit: Rather than actually sending the US military into combat, the Presidentwould simply announce that attacks were being done. Stock video andAI-generated battle and bombing scenes would be distributed to the patrioticnews organizations compliant enough to be allowed to cover the Pentagon.
5. Togive this PF scenario verisimilitude, the President should truly think that thewar is happening, that he is actually commanding a military venture, therebyfooling himself and the gullible segment of the American public. (We know whothey are.)
6. Therewould be little chance of the President’s discovering the fictional nature ofhis “war,” even if the professional military and intelligence leaders let itslip. Since he gets most of his information from Fox, which would be fed thevideos, and tends to doze off during briefings, the occasional truthful remarkis likely to pass right by him—and if not, he would filter it out to hold hisconfirmation bias.
7. Incontrast to the war in Iran, this “war” would not result in a single Americancasualty, of course, and would stir no international outrage or demand for warreparations.
8. ThePF plan coincides with the Iran war at the conclusion, when the Presidentdeclares a false victory. However, we strongly recommend departing from the Irancase by having the President end his fictitious war with a fictitious peaceagreement that awards the U.S. substantial fictitious benefits. We do not wanthim to pretend, or to do what he usually does, to pretend that he is notpretending.
Please contact the RepublicanNational Committee’s Working Group on Imagery’s project on Mutually AssuredDeception, with any questions or comments.
This is satire. It’s all made up,a disclosure made necessary by the absurdity of current reality, which preventslots of people from telling the difference between truth and fiction.
June 10, 2026
Iran and Ukraine: The Illusions of Military Power
By David K. Shipler
The majorwars raging in the Middle East and Europe are teaching a lesson, which willprobably go unlearned. Two of the world’s strongest military forces are unableto defeat smaller countries that use asymmetrical warfare—that is, weapons andtactics less advanced than the arsenals they face. The United States and Russiaare bogged down by Iran and Ukraine, respectively, whose governments’ continuedexistence is tantamount to a loss for Washington and Moscow.
This is aninterim assessment to be sure, for wars are judged by their outcomes, which arerarely visible in the short term. Today’s still photograph doesn’t necessarilypredict the future. But so far, in failing to realize their ambitions, bothRussia and the United States have displayed surprising vulnerabilities. Their armedforces seemed most formidable before they fired the first shot. Once the warsbegan, their destructive power turned out to be inadequate. The Iranian andUkrainian governments, facing obliteration, had everything to lose unless theyfound inventive ways to fight back and survive, which they have done.
The parallel is not a moral one, obviously,for the world would be better without the Iranian regime and worse without afree Ukraine. But war is rarely virtuous, no matter the righteous pleadings of theperpetrators. Nor is the worthiness of a cause a guarantee of success.
The currentcases are especially instructive, because they are the product of two mainerrors made by both Russia and the US: unrealistic objectives and autocraticdecision-making.
The ambitious goal for VladimirPutin of Russia was to annihilate Ukraine’s national independence and distinctiveculture. He spelled out his rationale in a long essay in July 2021, sevenmonths before he invaded, when he wrote that Russia andUkraine were not separate but occupied “one historical and spiritual space.” Asa dictator, he had insulated himself from dissent by creating a bubble of sycophantsin the Kremlin. Nor did he consult his citizens about going to war.
The ambitious goal for Donald Trump(and his Israeli partners) was to demolish Iran’s military and replace itsIslamic government with one amenable to foregoing nuclear weapons. Among hisshifting demands, after the war grew frustrating, came his threat of genocide ashe declaredlast April that unless Iran capitulated, “a whole civilization will dietonight, never to be brought back again.” As an aspiring dictator, he had also insulatedhimself from dissent by creating a bubble of sycophants—in the White House. Nordid he consult his citizens—or even Congress, as the Constitution requires—aboutgoing to war.
It goes without saying that Iran isa serious menace and, with nuclear weapons, would be as untouchable as NorthKorea. Its ideological zealotry and projection of destruction through proxiesin the Middle East would be virtually unchecked. But the US-Israeli onslaughthas been a two-edged sword. While severely damaging Iran’s military and armsindustry, it has also demonstrated to Tehran how easily global trade can bedisrupted by drones, speedboats, and other small-scale threats to internationalshipping.
Those relatively simple tools arelikely to remain in Iran’s hands indefinitely. They cannot be completely eliminatedby the sophisticated, high-tech aerial assaults that the US employs. Nor can Iran’snuclear aspirations be destroyed permanently from the air, which cannot reacheither the country’s technical know-how or the enriched uranium stockpiledunderground. Cyber attacks, assassinations of scientists, and bombings by Israeland the US have slowed the nuclear program, but only Iranian leaders canabandon it. That requires either the regime’s replacement (as Israel and the USexpected), diplomacy with the current government, or a wholesale invasion andoccupation.
Iran is well-schooled in themethods of asymmetrical warfare, which are used by state and non-state actors.The key is leveraging inferior weaponry into attacks on the pressure points ofthe larger enemy. Here, as we’ve seen, the pressure point is the Strait ofHormuz, “Iran’s new weapon of mass disruption,” Tom Friedman callsit, through which 20 percent of the world’s oil is shipped. As the pricesof gas, fertilizer, and other commodities soar in the West and Asia, the powerof Iran’s smaller arms capability is magnified.
Another key to a lesser force’s survivalis the risk aversion of the larger force. Because Trump has not been willing tosend ground troops, especially in the face of substantial public opposition tothe war, casualties have been low; thirteenAmericans have come back from this war in body bags to date. The dangerousdepletion of US missile and ammunition stockpiles also imposes restraint, whichtakes the form of Trump’s embrace of the current on-and-off ceasefire.
The cost for Americans could be increasedif Iran managed (or chose) to attack inside the US, either by terrorism or cybersabotage. But that might not be necessary, for the most pervasive anti-war campaignin America is at the local gas station, with those big numbers staring you inthe face every time you take a drive.
Ukraine has also discovered how tohit some of Russia’s pressure points. Just as Iran has developed drones (andhas helped Russia build a drone factory east of Moscow), Ukraine’s advancementsin drone technology now enable strikes deep inside Russian territory. Oilinstallations on the Baltic coast have been hit, and last week Ukraine struckan oil terminal near St. Petersburg, sending a tower of pitch-black smoke tostain the background scenery of Putin’s annual showcase, his InternationalEconomic Forum.
On Ukrainian territory, Russia haslost its formidable reputation as the resistance has raised immense costs. Moscow’svaunted armored units were virtually decimated and proven ineffectual. Russian resolvedomestically is reportedly being eaten away by the use of non-Russian ethnicminority draftees and ex-convicts as cannon-fodder; the diversion ofmanufacturing to weaponry; and the worsening economy, with inflation and gasshortages. Putin has predicted an end to the war, and pro-Kremlin talkers arelaying the groundwork for an ersatz claim of victory.
The stakes are high. Ukraine, abulwark against Russian expansionism in Europe, is an essential line ofdefense. The greater the cost of the war to Russia’s invasion, the less likelyit is to be repeated elsewhere—so goes the calculation.
Unfortunately, Trump is a miscreantin both wars. His halt of military aid to Ukraine, his attacks on NATO, and hisincoherent negotiating tactics have given the impression that Putin need merelyplay the long game and wait for the irresolution of the West. The US has weakeneditself by losing the trust of its allies. Only Ukraine and the Europeans canhold the line, which they are doing so far.
In Iran, Trump’s impulsive lack ofstrategic thinking and empathy—and his contempt for experts—have disabled himand his advisors from the capacity to anticipate Iran’s moves. His impatiencefor a negotiated agreement, his flustered, empty threats, are obviously beingread in Tehran as the flailing of a helpless giant.
Trump is so eager to get away fromIran that he has conducted a public dispute with Israeli Prime MinisterBenjamin Netanyahu over Israel’s continued assaults on Hezbollah, Iran’s proxyin Lebanon. Iran has made a true cease-fire and serious negotiations contingenton a halt to Israeli attacks on Hezbollah. Therefore, in that labyrinth ofentanglements, Iran has gained leverage over Israel via the US. It’s an amazingdynamic, all above Trump’s head.
This is hardly the first time for agreat power to be defeated by an adversary weaker in conventional weapons butstronger in resolve: the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, the United States inVietnam.
In the 1960s and 70s, US officials thoughtthat bombs, defoliants, artillery, and massive infantry could overwhelm the lessadvanced weaponry of North Vietnam and the Vietcong. Twenty-two years after thewar, at a 1997 conference of former American and North Vietnamese officials inHanoi, former Defense Secretary Robert McNamara kept asking the Vietnamese howmany of their people would have had to die before they gave up fighting andnegotiated.
The Vietnamese, calloused by yearsof battle, kept answering that they were fighting an anti-colonialist war tounify their country in complete independence, and that no amount of sufferingwould have brought them to their knees.
McNamara couldn’t grasp this, andduring a break, he gave some of us his conclusion: that Vietnamese cared lessabout human life than Americans did. That was a classic slander thatpractically every combatant visits upon the enemy, as I told him. Never true,but always believed.
Lessons on the limitation ofmilitary strength usually go unlearned, especially by the next generation ofleaders. It must be so tempting to hold your finger on that trigger of immense power,and to imagine that once you pull it, destruction will bring just thereordering that you desire.
April 18, 2026
Instructions From the White House to the Cabinet
By David K. Shipler
TheShipler Report has obtained an internal memo from Susie Wiles, PresidentTrump’s chief of staff, announcing a significant exception to a standing order.The reversal pertains to statements on religion.
Previously, and in multiplereminders, Wiles had warned staff and Cabinet secretaries against upstaging thepresident. Now, she wants them to do just that. She is known as the most candidof Trump’s inner circle, hence her direct language.
On January 21, 2025, the day afterTrump’s second inauguration, she wrote: “You must not publicize yourself, takecredit for successful actions, or hint that major policy initiativesoriginated anywhere other than the President’s fertile imagination—otherwiseknown as his mind. You may not make public statements more outlandish than the President’s,or that provoke either more applause or more outrage than whatever thePresident has ignited. He is the Force, and no one of you must ever portrayyourself as more inspiring, more energizing, or more appalling than him.”
Then, inearly March of this year, Wiles issued this terse message to the Cabinet: “KristiNoem didn’t get the memo.” Days later, Noem was fired as Secretary of HomelandSecurity after spending $220 million on TV ads that featured herself, deckedout in a cowboy hat, riding a horse in rugged terrain like a marshal come tobring order to a turbulent land.
Last week, afterTrump trash-talked Pope Leo XIV (“WEAK on crime and terrible for Foreign Policy,”)Wiles sent this urgent memo:
MEMORANDUM TO CABINETMEMBERS
April 13, 2026
TO: CABINET SECRETARIES
FROM: SUSIE WILES, WHITE HOUSE CHIEF OF STAFF
SUBJECT: RELIGIOUS EXCEPTION TO MEMORANDA OF JAN. 21, 2025,MARCH 30, 2025, JULY 4, 2025, AND MARCH 3, 2026
The WhiteHouse, noting the President’s recent condemnation of the Holy Father, herebyreverses its previous order that staff and Cabinet Secretaries refrain fromstatements more excessive or inflammatory than the President’s. On the matterof religion, and on that topic only, Secretaries are instructed to fashion remarksthat are actually more extreme, more outrageous, and more arrogant than thePresident’s. We acknowledge that this could present a challenge. But it isvital in maintaining the President’s (self-) image as a stable genius.Everything is relative, as we know. The Vice President, who cannot becommanded, much to the President’s dismay, is nevertheless encouraged to speakin this vein as well.
I. For example, it is recommended that the VicePresident lecture the Holy Father on theology, notwithstanding Mr. Vance’s conversionto Catholicism just seven years ago and his lack of formal theologicaleducation. Most voters will not know this, and they will not know that Pope Leowas educated at the Catholic Theological Union in Chicago and studied Canon Lawat the Pontifical University of Saint Thomas Aquinas in Rome. [Vance, followingthe advice, thensaid, “I think it is very, very important for the Pope to be careful whenhe talks about theology.”]
II. Secretary of War (and Expeditions) Pete Hegsethis instructed to continue his fashioning of the Iran conflict as a holy war.His analogizing the pilot rescue on Easter to Christ rising is just the kind ofstatement that is valued as a way to cast the President, by comparison, in amore reasonable light—grounded, shall we say. Praying at the Secretary’s Pentagonpress conferences, citing God’s blessing on our troops, and declaring His lackof mercy on the enemy are off-the-wall statements endorsed by the White House. Itwould also be helpful to call the Iranian Muslims “enemy infidels who are destinedfor hell”—again, to help the President to be seen as moderate. Or to quote a fakeBible verse from a movie. [Hegseth took the advice. Hequoted a mostly made-up passage from the film Pulp Fiction as if it were fromEzekiel. And he likenedhimself, his troops, and the administration to a healing force, with “Trump-hating”reporters as Pharisees, an ancient Jewish sect, who were “only looking for thenegative” when they witnessed Jesus heal the sick. “Our press are just likethese Pharisees,” Hegseth declared.]
III. President Trump’s posting of an image of himselflike Jesus, healing the sick, will be difficult to top, but it might inspiresome of you to come up with another outrageous AI concoction. The purpose,again, is to make the President seem rational and cogent by comparison. Awarning, however: Do not portray yourselves as God. Remember, the Presidentdoes not like being relegated to inferior status, and you would undoubtedlydepart soon thereafter to the Cabinet afterlife, wherever that might be.
Good luck negotiating these treacherouswaters. Please contact the office of the Chief of Staff with any questions.
This is satire. It’s all made up (except for the quotesfrom Trump, Vance, and Hegseth), a disclosure made necessary by the absurdityof current reality, which prevents lots of people from telling the differencebetween truth and fiction.
April 12, 2026
Is Israel to Blame for the Iran War?
By David K. Shipler
Israel’sgovernment under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has given President Trump plentyof bad advice about Iran. But the rising belief that Israel is to blame for Trump’swar of choice deflects responsibility from the White House, where it obviously belongs.Trump failed to weigh Israel’s interests against those of his own country. He reportedlyignored his advisers’ doubts about Israel’s assessments and predictions.
As the wardamages the global economy and security, Israel is being teed up as a scapegoat.A most aggressive effort has come from Tucker Carlson, once a Trumpcheerleader, whose recent rant againstthe war includes a malevolent portrait of a president at the mercy of Israel.
“The Israeli government has astoried history of blackmailing US presidents,” he writes absurdly in his MorningNote. “America’s ‘special ally’ is willing to play very dirty to achieveits goals. Dark-money campaign contributions, extortion, physical threats andeven assassination. In their anti-Christian worldview, the ends always justifythe means. They have no issue destroying lives.” (Carlson doesn’t mention “Jews,”but those with an antisemitic bent will surely read it that way.)
Americans’ longstanding support forIsrael has weakened severely. Unfavorable opinions were driven up by Israel’swidespread bombing and brutal blockade of Gaza Palestinians following theOctober 7, 2023 atrocities by Hamas, and have risen further since thecoordinated Israeli and American war on Iran was launched February 28. A PewResearch Center poll taken in March 23-29 found that 60 percent of Americanadults hold a negative view of Israel, up from 53 percent last year and 33 percent in 2022. This could get worse if the conflict is not resolved beneficiallyto American interests. It’s not truly over, of course, and the eventual outcomewill render judgment.
Netanyahu lobbied hard for this war,particularly on February 11, when he gained a rare invitation to ahighly-classified meeting in the White House Situation Room. His pitch to Trumpcame in a period of terrible coincidence, a perfect storm of anxiety andextremism. Gripped by a heightened sense of vulnerability, Israel is led by themost radical, right-wing government in its history. The result is an anti-Araband anti-Muslim strategy driven by religious absolutism and ethnic bigotry.
After the October 7 attack, a waveof existential fear swept through Israel. Hamas fighters, many on motorcycles, hadmanaged to breach Israel’s high-tech defenses around Gaza, shredding confidencein the intelligence and military establishments. Iran then attacked mainly throughits proxy, Hezbollah in Lebanon, forcing Israelis to leave their homes near theborder. Others, evacuated from near Gaza in the south, added to anunprecedented population of internal refugees. Israel felt nearly encircled by Iran’sdetermination to annihilate the Jewish state.
It’s doubtful that Israel’sexistence was truly at risk; it still had the Middle East’s most formidablemilitary. But a muffled drumbeat of fear has always run through Israelisociety, a legacy of the Holocaust reinforced by the perpetual conflict withthe Palestinian Arabs. For most of its history, Israel’s counterpoint to fearhas been aggressive defiance, which the Netanyahu government has translatedinto military onslaughts.
Israel demolished most of Iran’sair defenses and decimated both Hamas and Hezbollah. Last June, the US andIsrael coordinated air attacks on Iran’s nuclear facilities. The streets filledwith huge numbers of Iranian citizens, hostile to the Islamic Revolution and sufferingeconomically; many were gunned down, but Iran’s government looked weakened. Thetime for action seemed as ripe as it had ever been.
According to remarkable reportingby Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan in TheNew York Times, Netanyahu and the head of Mossad, Israel’s version ofthe CIA, argued that regime change would be triggered by a joint US-Israeliattack. The Israelis even played a video—imagery, not words, seem the majorinput to Trump’s brain—showing individuals who could take leadership.
“Mossad’s intelligence indicatedthat street protests inside Iran would begin again and — with the impetus ofthe Israeli spy agency helping to foment riots and rebellion — an intensebombing campaign could foster the conditions for the Iranian opposition tooverthrow the regime,” wrote Swan and Haberman. “The Israelis also raised theprospect of Iranian Kurdish fighters crossing the border from Iraq to open aground front in the northwest, further stretching the regime’s forces andaccelerating its collapse.”
To anyone who knew anything aboutIsrael’s record in predicting or manipulating the politics of its enemies, thisconfidence should have raised a red flag. It did among several participants,according to the reporters. In all the efforts to remake the politics of thePalestinians and Lebanese over the years, not a single example of success comesto mind. Israel’s intelligence agencies are good at locating targets forassassination and disrupting technology, but terrible at understanding thepolitical and social dynamics of their adversaries.
The Israelis were also wrong aboutthe military results, at least in the short term, according to the Timesreporters: “Mr. Netanyahu and his team outlined conditions they portrayed aspointing to near-certain victory: Iran’s ballistic missile program could bedestroyed in a few weeks. The regime would be so weakened that it could notchoke off the Strait of Hormuz, and the likelihood that Iran would land blowsagainst U.S. interests in neighboring countries was assessed as minimal.”
Trump seemed nearly persuaded byIsrael’s optimistic predictions. Having cushioned himself with sycophants and purgedIran experts from the State Department, Pentagon, and National Security Council,he had forfeited the opportunity for informed debate. Nevertheless, a fewvoices of skepticism were raised in subsequent meetings.
The CIA director, John Ratcliffe,called Netanyahu’s regime-change scenarios “farcical,” the reporters wrote. “Atthat point, Mr. [Marco] Rubio [Secretary of State] cut in. ‘In other words,it’s bullshit,’” he said.
When Trump asked General Dan Cainefor his views, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff answered: “Sir, thisis, in my experience, standard operating procedure for the Israelis. Theyoversell, and their plans are not always well-developed. They know they needus, and that’s why they’re hard-selling.”
Since those meetings were attendedby only a small circle of high-level officials, somebody inside clearly wantedthe discussions documented publicly. The writers did the reporting for their forthcomingbook, Regime Change: Inside the Imperial Presidency of Donald Trump.
Their account suggests that indeciding to go to war, Trump filtered out cautionary information that did notharmonize with his gut desires. Like millions of his fellow Americans who choosenews sources the confirm their biases, he absorbs only what he agrees with. Andlike authoritarian personalities throughout history, he cows his subordinates.Swan and Haberman note that in the end, despite some reservations, his deferentaides did not argue vigorously against the mission.
Years before, Netanyahu had opposedthe multinational agreement with Iran, negotiated under President Obama tocurtail its nuclear weapons program. It left Iran’s ballistic missile developmentuntouched and placed no limits on its proxies, which threatened Israel. Yet evenwith its flaws, the agreement froze Iran’s nuclear development for a period and—whatshould be most telling for a president—bolstered US national security interests.Trump, who hates everything Obama did, took Netanyahu’s advice and committed theblunder of scuttling the accord, releasing Iran to renew its advance towardnuclearization.
Bad advice doesn’t have to betaken.
Today, while Israel can be blamedfor misreading Iran militarily and politically, it need not be blamed for thewar. The fault is Trump’s. The fault is the collaborators’ he has installedaround him. The fault is the millions of Americans’ who put him back in theWhite House even after seeing his anti-constitutional moves to overturndemocracy.
Even if he were not asemi-dictator, Trump would put the country in danger from his startling lack ofanalytical skills and obvious cognitive impairment. His decline intoimpulsiveness is rapidly advancing, perhaps a symptom common to aging narcissists.Barely any checks on his power are imposed by any branch of government. He rulesby feelings, not facts, limited only by his “own morality,” as he told TheTimes in a January interview.
What a comfort. His own morality.
March 19, 2026
Trump Meets the Unconquerable World
By David K. Shipler
One of themost enlightening summations of Donald Trump came from his longtime associateand now chief of staff, Susie Wiles. He has an “alcoholic’s personality,” shesaid in aninterview with Vanity Fair, which means he “operates [with] a view thatthere’s nothing he can’t do. Nothing, zero, nothing.” She should know. AlthoughTrump claims not to drink alcohol, Wiles grew up with an alcoholic father, thefootball player and sportscaster Pat Summerall.
Trump’sfantasy of omnipotence helps explain why he swaggers across parts of the globeand tramples his own country’s democratic norms. But his illusion of boundlesspower is now running into the reality of Iran. So is Israel’s imagined abilityto manipulate the politics of its enemies, a practice it has pursued fordecades with absolutely zero success.
Trump has been riding anintoxicating high of adventurism since he found little resistance from earliertargets, bombing Iran’s nuclear facilities last June, blowing up speedboats inthe Caribbean, capturing President Nicolas Maduro from Venezuela in January,and now cutting off Cuba’s oil supplies. He said of Cuba, “I can do anything Iwant with it.” On Iran’s retaliation across the Gulf states, Trump declared, “Nobodyexpected that. We were shocked.”
An educable president who took advice fromexperts would have anticipated the ruthless resilience of Iran’s odious regime.That is not the president Americans elected. Instead, he has rid government of specialistswho know Iran. He has made the White House into an echo chamber of zealots andsycophants. He has let his incompetent “Secretary of War,” Pete Hegseth, purge thesenior officer corps of many seasoned professionals essential to complex combat.
Furthermore, Trump carries the flawof every dictator. He thinks policy is personified in a single figure, as inhis own administration: hence his misplaced belief that decapitating agovernment will bring it down, as in the seizure of Maduro and theassassination of Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei.
Taking a still picture of a war inprogress can be misleading, for the final judgment usually rests on itsoutcome. So far, the Israel-American onslaught from the air has killed much ofthe leadership, including potentially moderate figures, and obliterated much ofIran’s military.
The regime remains, however, fightingfor its life using asymmetrical warfare against massive Israeli and Americanair power: mostly drones and rockets aimed at the pressure points of the globaloil economy. The US is burning through its arsenal of expensive defensivemissiles, which it’s using to down the relative cheap Iranian drones. Thatlimits Ukraine’s ability to get them to hold off Russia, which poses a much graverthreat than Iran.
Nor is there any sign yet of thepower vacuum that both Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahuanticipated could somehow be filled by an unarmed and unorganized opposition. “Thehour of your freedom is at hand,” Trump toldIranians on February 28, the day he began the war. “Stay sheltered, don’t leaveyour home….When we are finished, take over your government, it will be yours totake.”
Perhaps Trump had been persuaded byNetanyahu, the latest in a long line of Israeli leaders who have tried andfailed to realign Arab and Muslim politics.
In theearly 1980s, to dilute the Palestine Liberation Organization’s influence in theoccupied West Bank, Israel appointed Menachem Milson, a professor of Arabicliterature at Hebrew University, as architect of a set of rural “villageleagues” composed of moderate, compliant Palestinians. They were seen by thePLO as Israeli collaborators, Jordan threatened to prosecute them for treason, moderatePalestinian mayors denounced their complicity, one member was shot and wounded whenhis son was killed, and others resigned. Milson impressedArabs as arrogant and ignorant of their culture, I was told at the time, breakingpromises and wielding crude political patronage to no avail.
Similarlyin that period, Israel’s army in occupied Gaza was giving money to the MuslimBrotherhood, a precursor of Hamas. That startling miscalculation was confirmedto me in 1981 by Brig. Gen. Yitzhak Segev, Israel’s military governor for Gaza,who explained that he was instructed to build the Brotherhood as a counterpointto the PLO and the Communists, whose goal of Palestinian statehood was seen asmore threatening than Muslim fundamentalism.
TheBrotherhood was doctrinaire religiously but also deep into social welfareservices for the impoverished Gaza population. I suppose the movement seemedbenign to Israeli officials whose hubris led them to think they understood theByzantium of Gaza’s politics.
A year later, Israelis made thesame mistake in Lebanon, where they went to war to succeed in expelling the PLObut fail dramatically at realigning Lebanese politics in a pro-Israel direction.Their favored leader, Bashir Gemayel, a Maronite Christian who had led fighterson Israel’s behalf, was assassinated by a pro-Syrian operative shortly afterbeing elected president.
More recently, Netanyahugovernments bolstered Hamas to divide Palestinians and cripple their movementfor statehood. Years after Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, Israel allowedQatar to send suitcasesfull of cash for Hamas through checkpoints into Gaza.
Devoted to Israel’s ultimatedestruction, Hamas seemed useful to Netanyahu, because it undermined thePalestinian Authority, which descended from the PLO, favored a two-statesolution, and governed parts of the West Bank under the Oslo Accords. The self-destructiveresult of this bumbling attempt at manipulation came on October 7, 2023, whenHamas fighters caught Israeli intelligence and armed forces off-guard, breachedthe defenses around Gaza, slaughtered some 1,200 people, took 251 hostages, andtriggered Israel’s massive bombing of the territory. In its brutal vengeanceduring that war, Israel forfeited its moral authority.
Under Trump, the United States isalso forfeiting its moral authority. That is an unmeasurable commodity. Itcannot be quantified in numbers of missiles, dollars per barrel, or the balanceof trade. But its depletion, with allies and adversaries alike, leaves Americahandicapped in the real world, which even Trump’s megalomania cannot tame.
David K. Shipler's Blog
- David K. Shipler's profile
- 90 followers

