Another mass murder has occurred in America, and, once again, outraged Americans have taken to social media to make their perspectives known. This is an online dialogue far too many people have grown tired of — and by “tired” I don’t mean “bored of” but rather tired from the depths of our souls.

Collectively, we are all outraged — even if we don’t agree on what we are outraged about. And so, we attempt to exorcise our pain by pointing fingers and placing blame. Some people blame Muslims; some...