date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Celeste
(new)
Sep 17, 2018 10:55AM
Jaima, you know I am one of your greatest fans. I've read all of your books and think they are perfection, including The Dark Before Dawn. You have created a wide range of characters, all of whom have faults because, after all, they are human. They also act foolishly at times, because... well, see the previous sentence. And they also have their own reasons for doing the things they do. None of us are surrounded solely by those who have never sinned, never made a mistake, never acted impulsively, because those people don't exist. Characters in books should reflect the human condition, not exclusively be paragons of propriety 24/7. Klara never imagined being in love or being loved. She basically lead a solitary life, and never imagined anyone like Josef being a part of it. I think your story would not have been as believable, given the atmosphere of the city, Klara's loneliness, Josef's larger than life persona, their passion, and the life and death situations they faced, if the couple had not succumbed to their passion. Considering Klara's unconventional upbringing, and the fact that she was living a lie every day of her life that could bring dire consequences if revealed, I don't think she considered loving Josef as wrong, but only as dangerous as every other thing she did in her life. Perfectly human, perfectly Klara, perfectly perfect. It's thoughtful of you to apologize to one of your dear readers, but in my humble opinion it wasn't necessary. You brought complex characters to life for all of us to enjoy, and the fact that you let them lead lives that you yourself would never live isn't something you should apologize for. It's called creativity! And let's remember that even the Holy Bible is full of treachery, theft, adultery, fornication, murder, etc... so should we skip the Good Book, as well? I think not.
reply
|
flag

First, may I say that I'm thrilled and flattered that you care about Klara and Josef enough to be bothered by their choices? If they are real enough to root for, I feel like I'm succeeding as a writer. 

