Is the pen mightier than the sword?
“People under a dictatorship, it has been well said, are condemned to a lifetime of enthusiasm.” This quote is from an article written in 1937 by author Eugene Lyons, and begs the question, who keeps the enthusiasm going? Writers do. Throughout history, rulers have never been able to silence the social advocates, orators, or court jesters. In fact, jesters throughout history from countries like France, England, China and India have had the unique freedom to speak honestly, without fear of reprisal. Unfortunately, other scribes throughout history haven’t fared as well.


 


In 1937, Russia and Germany put restrictions in place to control the flow of ideas and tagged anything they didn’t want exposed as fake news. The similarities between now and then are astounding, and those who do not know history are doomed to repeat it. 


 


In Mr. Lyons article, he writes,“Censorship of the word is more rigid in Russia than anywhere in the world, with only Germany as a runner-up within hailing distance. Every book, before it is even considered by one of the government publishing organizations, must be read and passed by Glavlit, the literary censorship office. Ditto every play. Magazines and newspapers, besides being subject to a series of political checks and counter-checks to eek out possible heresy, have special persons on their staffs charged with the responsibility of detecting and casting out anything faintly off-color politically.”


 


While this external censorship from the state was bad enough for a writer, the psychological toll was even more sinister. These controls lead to self-censorship, and as every writer knows, they are their own worst critics.
What happened to writers that believed the propaganda?


The article explains, “Censorship of course does not affect the writers whose views are identical with those of the censors. Certain Russian writers of my acquaintance have insisted that the pressure is so light they scarcely feel it. But these were, in every case, hundred-percenters for whom compliance with the official catechism was second nature. The relative freedom of press and conscience in any nation must be judged by those out of step rather than by the ardent goosesteppers.”


 


Authors in Russia that towed the party line were well compensated. Their works were published by state sponsors of propaganda. Royalties for these authors ranged in the neighborhood of 10-15 thousand rubles a month, compared to the average Russian citizen who earned a mere 200 rubles monthly. But alas, not all writers sold out. Many kindred scribes found writing the truth much easier than keeping track of all of the lies. In 1937 Russia, authors who disagreed with the state were dissidents, many of whom were brutalized and imprisoned for speaking the truth, a truth that would be labeled as fake by the state. It is hard to wrap your head around the irony.


In the Today’s News
The history of how writers were brutalized under this regime is eerily similar to what is happening around the world today. The following quote from Mr. Lyon’s article was so close to today’s reality, that the year it was written, had to be double checked.


 


Read for yourself and see if you agree, remember, the following excerpt was written in 1937:



“For reasons of international diplomacy Russia, which is eager to be accepted into the company of democratic nations like France and England, is seeking to create the impression that it has accepted democracy. How any one-party system in which political thinking that deviates from the prescribed “Party line” is punished as treachery can be made democratic is a mystery.”


 


It appears Russia has expanded their sphere of influence by attempting to control the thought process of writers on social media. History allows us to put our present into focus while offering 20/20 hindsight. If today’s scribes see history repeating itself, it is their duty to shed light on reality not propaganda.


In the novel, The Fablecastle Chronicles, the main character is an investigative journalist who truly believes words matter and that the pen is mightier than the sword. This conviction is challenged when Maggie traveles to a place called Earth to conduct an interview with someone claiming to be Lucifer. Find out why.

The post Words Matter appeared first on Trina Spillman Author.