As I wrote in 2021, taking steps to remove the human voice and replace it with a synthesized one destroys the art form.

I certainly do not want or intend to participate in any attempt to create artificial voices meant to replace human narrators.

However, I unknowingly may have done that very thing by choosing to distribute audiobooks through FindawayVoices.com. Today, I took action to revoke Findaway’s license to Apple to use my audiobooks for machine learning.

In recent days, people on Facebook have shared this clause in Schedule D of the rights holder’s Distribution Agreement from FindawayVoices.com:

Machine Learning
Rights Holder grants Apple a limited, non-exclusive, non-transferable, non-sublicensable right and license to use Digital Audio Products files for machine learning training and models, provided that in no event shall any Rights Holder Digital Audio Products or portion thereof be provided to any third party or end-user in contravention of this Digital Distribution Agreement (e.g. making Rights Holder content available for free to end-users without express written consent). Rights Holder may revoke this right and license by sending Notice to Findaway as outlined in Section 11.

Section 11 states:

11. NOTICES
All notices required under this Agreement shall be sent by email to support@findawayvoices.com.

I’m a rights holder on Findaway. I sent the email below to FindawayVoices as my Notice. Feel free to use it as a template, though in retrospect, I’d change the subject to be Revoke license for Apple machine learning. I also should have added that my revocation applies to any future similar license with another company. Not surprisingly, the auto-reply message stated they are “experiencing higher than average email volume.”

Subject: Revoke use of Apple machine learning

Hello. I am disgusted to learn that Findaway at some point added language to Schedule D of the Distribution Agreement which allows Apple to use my audio for machine learning.

Per Item 11 of the Agreement, I revoke that right and license forever for all of my audiobooks.

Please send confirmation of this request, as well as confirmation from Apple that my files will not be used in this manner.

Looking at my copies of past Distribution Agreements, I see that this clause has been in place since at least March 2020.

It’s unfortunate that Findaway’s lawyers banked on the fact that most people would not see or understand this treacherous clause in the Agreement.

For a company that proudly proclaims “We Love Narrators” on the home page of FindawayVoices.com, this clause makes it seem that the company loves big money more.

In addition to the royalty break-down listed in the Agreement, Findaway should be transparent about the amount of money that Apple is paying for the right to use your clients’ audio to create synthetic voices that could take the jobs of the narrators Findaway “loves”.

Thank you for your attention and immediate action.

Update: After receiving numerous questions and comments from other narrators, I’ve changed this post to clarify that the “Machine Learning” language only appears in the rights holder’s Distribution Agreement.

I’ve narrated and self-produced a number of books that I distributed through Findaway as the rights holder. I couldn’t find a link to the current Distribution Agreement on the web. It’s contained in my Rights Holder Dashboard.

Narrators sign away our interest in the recording at the point we contracted with a rights holder. You can send the email to Findaway. However, I imagine they would tell you to contact the rights holder(s) of books you’ve narrated to revoke their sub-license to Apple.

The post Revoked Findaway’s License to Apple for Machine Learning appeared first on Karen Commins.