I am a pantser --- but then !

A couple months ago I read a blog written by Goodreads author Thomas Drinkard at his Pinnacle Writing site. He was illustrating two very different writing styles and I was quick to connect with one and was delighted to realize I was not alone in my writing process.

Planner or Pantser is the name of the post where he compares the work method of two successful authors.

Jeffery Deaver is a planner that uses detailed outlines to write. At a conference in 2010, Deaver reported that his book The Bone Collector was published at not quite twice the size of the 184 page outline. That amount of organized preparation amazes me.

Thomas' friend, the late Anne Carroll George spoke to him of being a seat-of-the pants author - a pantser. Among her achievements, she had been nominated for a Pulitzer Prize for Some of it is True, a collection of poetry and was honored with the Agatha Award for her Southern Sisters mystery series. Her process was minimal outlining and letting her characters drive the story not knowing where they would lead her. One man she thought was the murderer, suddenly ended up shot one night.

I laughed out loud and clapped my hands in joy when I read this. I have been trying to explain to people that I knew how my story in The Spruce Gum Box began and I knew how the story would end but the characters led me through the twists and turns between. Some characters became much more important than I thought. Others less. I would call my daughter and say, "You won't believe what Jed did last night." As historical fiction, I did use a list of events and dates like the dots in a connect-the-dots puzzle. The puzzle became what the characters would do (or not do) as the story moved forward. They held the clues.

Thank you Thomas for the reinforcement of the method I use as I write the sequel Granite Hearts . It is going through final pains before publishing but the characters guided the story. I can't imagine trying to force them down a path not of their choosing.

I am a pantser .... but then again I confess when it comes to everything else I am a planner . I live by the list - sometimes having lists of my lists. In upcoming events I massage every detail until they scream. I can't remember not having the need to overachieve in every task (except losing weight). It is a curse. After 70+++ years, you would think I could find a cure.

I want to toss away my need to over plan. It would be so nice to know what I would like to do and set a date for the doing. Then go with the flow between point A to point B. Ah yes, I want to live as I write ... as a PANTSER!

Thomas Drinkard is a fellow member of The Independent Author Network. His work includes thrillers Piety and Murder and Where There Were No Innocents and in a new change in genre - a vampire novella V Trooper. He also enjoys spending time in my Maine. We share a love for the coast and all it holds.

Visit his author page at The Independent Author Network http://www.independentauthornetwork.c...
2 likes ·   •  5 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on April 25, 2012 08:25
Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ray (new)

Ray Pace Ah yes, that question of should all of this be planned out, or do I wing it? Has anything of value ever gone entirely to plan? Aren't there always improvs along the way? And what about how those characters talk to the writer offering advice and insisting they would never say that or do such and such? Creativity brings all this excitement to the forefront.


message 2: by Jeannie (new)

Jeannie Walker Elizabeth- you are such a wonderful friend and writer. Loved the post.


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Funny - I was thinking about you this week when I was posting a review for Larry Enright. I gave "Fighting the Devil" 5*s at Goodreads and saw I had not done the same at Amazon. Will take care of that.


message 4: by Jacqueline (new)

Jacqueline Patricks I am very much a pantster! I used to make outline, but all they ever did for me is create writer's block. Once I just dived in and started writing... well things got a whole lot more interesting. My best scenes are ad libs, shocking twists that I hadn't thought of until I got there. I know it's the main reason why I write plot twists so well. But then, I also plot the major points out in my head. That's right, all in my head. Only a few bare notes to get things straight.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Jacqueline wrote: "I am very much a pantster! I used to make outline, but all they ever did for me is create writer's block. Once I just dived in and started writing... well things got a whole lot more interesting. M..."
Jacqueline - I am well into the last book of the Maine historical fiction trilogy. Did not get past chapter 1 before the characters began to surprise me. I do have a page of dates of births, deaths of characters from Spruce Gum Box and Granite Hearts and a page of historical dates - I use them as points to let my characters string their stories. Th for your comment.


back to top

Elizabeth Egerton Wilder's Blog

Elizabeth Egerton Wilder
Elizabeth Egerton Wilder isn't a Goodreads Author (yet), but they do have a blog, so here are some recent posts imported from their feed.
Follow Elizabeth Egerton Wilder's blog with rss.