Introduction: The Myth of Originality

Let’s start with a harsh truth that no one really wants to admit: originality is overrated. There it is. No take-backs. Somewhere right now, a literary purist just fainted into a pile of their self-published novellas, whispering, “but… but… the sacred spark of creation!”

Listen, here’s the deal-every story you’re reading today, writing today, or even thinking about writing today has roots in something older. Much older. We’re talking myths, folklore, bedtime stories, religious texts, and probably a campfire tale someone once told to scare a cousin who still sleeps with a nightlight.

It’s not laziness to recycle old bones into new flesh. It’s survival. These myths are sticky because they work. They’re primal. They’ve survived wars, plagues, countless translations, terrible stage adaptations, and (God help us all) fanfiction so bad it should’ve been quarantined.

Now pair myths with nostalgia, and you’ve got yourself a tag team that can knock out even the most jaded reader. Nostalgia whispers in our ear: remember how magical it all felt the first time? You can feel that again. And so we return, not because we’re uncreative, but because these stories still own us.

This post is both a love letter and a roast to nostalgia and reimagined myths. And maybe, by the end, you’ll stop pretending that every idea you have was born out of some untapped well of genius, and instead admit the obvious: you’ve been borrowing from the greats all along. Congratulations. You’re human.

1. Why We Crave the Familiar

There’s a reason you rewatch the same TV show when life gets hard. (Yes, you with your eighth rewatch of The Office, and you, clinging to Friends like it’s a life raft in a storm.) You already know the jokes, you already know who dies, and yet it feels safe. Comforting. A warm blanket made of canned laughter and predictable arcs.

That’s nostalgia in action. And in storytelling, it’s basically a cheat code. The familiar works because it taps into the brain’s love for patterns. It’s why your heart beats a little faster when you hear the opening notes of a song you loved at thirteen, or why reading a retelling of an old fairy tale can pull you back into the emotional gravity of childhood.

For writers, nostalgia is gold because:

It makes readers care instantly. You don’t need to build the foundation from scratch, the emotional scaffolding is already there.

It creates shared shorthand. You can hint at something, and your readers will fill in the gaps because they already know the framework.

It lets you tap into memory. Nostalgia isn’t about plot, it’s about the feeling of being pulled back into a moment that never fully left you.

Readers don’t always want new, they want new enough. They want familiar stories twisted, cracked open, and reimagined so they can feel both safe and surprised.

2. Reimagining Myths Without Ruining Them

Here’s where the real artistry comes in: reimagining myths without butchering them into lifeless, soulless husks. There’s a thin line between creative brilliance and creative plagiarism-with-extra-steps.

Reimagining a myth works best when:

You add new context. What if Hades isn’t a villain, but an overworked bureaucrat trying to manage underfunded departments of souls? (This man did not sign up for HR complaints from Cerberus, thank you very much.)

You change the perspective. What if we stop telling the hero’s story and tell the monster’s? Or the side character’s? (Wicked, Circe, and countless indie works have thrived on this alone.)

You update the stakes. What if Little Red Riding Hood wasn’t innocent, but complicit in the game of predator and prey?

Butchering myths looks like:

Copy-pasting a story into a “modern” setting with zero depth. (Slapping Zeus into a leather jacket does not count as innovation.)

Stripping the story of its soul just to cash in on a trend.

Forgetting to ask the crucial question: why does this myth still matter?

Respect the bones, but don’t be afraid to put new flesh on them. Mythology doesn’t need your protection, it needs your evolution.

3. Nostalgia as a Writer’s Crutch (and Secret Weapon)

Let’s be brutally honest: nostalgia is dangerous. It’s soft, it’s comforting, and it’ll gladly lull you into writing mediocrity if you’re not careful. (Insert groan at the fifteenth gritty reboot no one asked for.)

But, if you wield it carefully, nostalgia can be a secret weapon.

Here’s how to use it well:

Anchor your readers emotionally. Nostalgia gets their guard down. Once you’ve got their trust, you can twist the knife (metaphorically… unless you’re writing horror).

Bridge your story into the real world. Nostalgia makes the fictional feel real by tethering it to something the reader already knows.

Create timelessness. A well-done nostalgic echo can make a book feel like it belongs to yesterday, today, and tomorrow all at once.

The trick is balance. Nostalgia is seasoning, not the main course. Too much, and your story feels derivative. Too little, and you miss the emotional weight nostalgia can bring.

4. How Rambling (Yes, Rambling) Ties Into Myths and Nostalgia

People don’t talk in clean, plot-driven dialogue. They ramble. They trail off. They go on tangents about their childhood, their grandmother’s soup recipe, or some half-remembered myth they’re not even sure they’re telling right.

That’s where nostalgia and reimagined myths thrive. A character rambling about the bedtime story their mother told them or the urban legend that haunted their neighborhood, doesn’t stall the plot. It breathes life into it. It makes the world feel lived in, chaotic, human.

Rambling ties into myths because myths are, at their core, rambling stories polished by centuries of retelling. They were never neat. They were messy, contradictory, full of digressions and embellishments. And that’s why they lasted.

So let your characters ramble. Let them tie your world to their past. Let them wander into nostalgia, because that’s how real people talk and how stories become bigger than themselves.

5. Why Readers Want the Same Stories Told Differently

Readers are impossible creatures. They scream for originality, but riot when you change too much. (See: every fandom meltdown ever.)

The truth? Readers don’t want brand-new, they want familiar with a twist. They want to recognize the skeleton, but be surprised by the skin.

Examples?

Vampires. Hundreds of vampire stories, yet people keep buying. Because every author tweaks the formula, sometimes terrifying, sometimes romantic, sometimes sparkling (don’t pretend you don’t know).

Greek mythology. How many times has it been retold? And yet, every version thrives because it speaks to something universal in us: power, tragedy, betrayal, love.

You’re not betraying your readers by giving them something familiar, you’re feeding them exactly what they came for. The trick is the wrapping.

6. My Personal Experience: Why I Started With Myths and Nostalgia

I’ll confess something: I started writing myths and nostalgia not because I was brave, but because I was buying myself time. I wasn’t ready to give the world my deepest, most personal stories yet. So I borrowed.

Borrowing gave me practice. It gave me structure. It let me experiment with voice, pacing, and style without the crushing weight of “this must be the masterpiece that defines me.” Nostalgia and myths became training wheels. And in the process, I discovered that my own voice was loud enough to stand on its own.

If you’re just starting, don’t feel guilty about leaning on what’s already out there. These stories are scaffolding. They’re safe enough to give you room to grow, but flexible enough to let you bend them into something new.

And when you’re ready to write from the heart, you’ll find your own originality sharpened by everything you learned while borrowing.

7. Practical Tips: Using Nostalgia & Myths in Your Writing

Alright, let’s get tactical. Here’s how to actually use nostalgia and myths without falling into cliché:

Pick a myth or memory that haunts you. Don’t chase trends. Write the stories that won’t let go of your brain.

Ask what’s missing. Every myth has blind spots. Every nostalgic memory has shadows. That’s where the gold is.

Add your era. Nostalgia thrives when it’s tied to a specific time and place, whether it’s 90s suburbia, 18th-century countryside, or your own chaotic childhood.

Make it personal. The deeper your emotional tie, the deeper your readers’ investment.

Break it on purpose. Nostalgia is comfort. Sometimes the boldest, most powerful move you can make is to destroy it.

8. The Inevitable Sarcastic Section: Bad Uses of Nostalgia

“What if Romeo and Juliet had TikTok?” (I beg you, stop.)

Rebooting a beloved story just to sell merch (no names, but you know exactly which franchise I mean).

Entire plots that rely on: “remember this thing from the 80s? Good, because that’s literally the whole story.”

Nostalgia without heart is empty calories. It gives readers a quick rush, but leaves them hollow.

9. Conclusion: Nostalgia Isn’t the Enemy - It’s the Map

Here’s the truth: nostalgia and myths aren’t enemies of creativity. They’re the foundation. They’re the stories that kept people alive during hard winters, the ones that made children believe in magic, the ones that connected generations long before Instagram tried.

As writers, it’s not our job to escape nostalgia. It’s our job to have a conversation with it. To ask: what does this story mean now?

So don’t run from it. Borrow from it. Twist it. Break it. Reshape it. Nostalgia isn’t a weakness, it’s a compass. And if you follow it far enough, it just might lead you back to the kind of originality you’ve been chasing all along.

- Makitia Thompson

#Makitia #TheMidUniverse #MindsInDesign #MakitiaThompson #WhereTimeCantExist #UntilTimeRemembers #Midstories #Midcontent