There is a moment, in a certain kind of story, that I have spent most of my life chasing.

It is not the moment the monster appears. It is not the door bursting open, or the hand on the shoulder, or the face at the window. Those are fine. They do their work. They make the heart go quickly for a second or two, and then the heart, which is sensible, settles.

Thanks for reading The Hum! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

The moment I mean is quieter than that, and it does not settle.

It is the moment when something ordinary declines to behave.

A staircase with one step too many. A relative who says your name slightly wrong and does not notice. A house glimpsed through trees that does not look built all at once, but assembled across different decades, in sections that were never fully persuaded to agree with one another. Nothing has attacked you. Nothing has even threatened you. And yet some part of you, older than your reasoning, has stopped and gone very still.

That is the hum. It is not a sound. It is the sensation of a world that has begun, very slightly, to run at the wrong frequency, and the awful private knowledge that you are the only one who can hear it.

Robert Aickman, who was the great master of this, did not call his pieces horror stories. He called them strange stories, and he was right to, because horror implies a thing that can be identified and therefore, eventually, escaped. Aickman’s stories offer no such courtesy. You finish them and you cannot say precisely what happened. You can only say that something did, and that it is not finished with you.

Shirley Jackson knew the same secret, and put it in the first paragraph of The Haunting of Hill House: a house that is not sane, standing by itself against its hills, holding darkness within. Not a haunted house. A house that is simply, quietly, wrong. Whatever walked there, walked alone.

The modern instinct runs the other way. Explain the monster. Give it an origin. Show it in the third act, clearly and at length, so that the audience can see what they have paid for. And the moment you do, the terror politely leaves the room. A thing with an origin is a thing with a rule. A thing with a rule is a thing that can be beaten. The audience relaxes, because you have handed them the exit.

The stories that stay do not hand you the exit.

They leave the questions open, and this is not a failure of nerve, or a trick, or an author who could not think of an ending. It is the point. Because the open question does not stay on the page. It follows you out of the book and into the kitchen at two in the morning, where it is waiting, patiently, with no intention of ever being answered.

I have come to think this is the honest form. We do not, after all, get explanations. Not for the things that actually frighten us. Not for the shape at the edge of the dream we cannot recall on waking, or the way a childhood house feels when you return to it as an adult, or the sensation, standing in a crowded and cheerful room, that everyone present knows something you do not.

There is no third act for that. There is only the hum.

So: this is what I write, and this is where I will be writing about it. Essays on the quiet end of the genre. Notes from inside the trilogy I am building. Fragments that did not survive the manuscript, and stray pieces that arrive here first.

There is also a novel, which is called The Night Fair, and which is about a private exhibition held once a year on a private estate, and about two people who went looking for a story and were given one. If any of the above sounded like your particular frequency, you will probably know already whether you want it.

I will not be asking twice.

— A.J. Vane

For those who hear the hum.

Subscribe now

Thanks for reading The Hum! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.