Keep Pitching!

Whether you're pitching your idea(s) to a magazine, a digital publication, or a traditional book publisher -- the goal is the same. Keep it simple!

Most editors have slush piles flooding their desks -- or at the very least, filling their inboxes. Three to four paragraphs usually gets the job done. Note: Book pitches often require a synopsis and a writing sample, but there's more on that below.

FIRST, share why you're the right person for this particular piece/project. Be clear about who you are professionally with just a few personal details. In other words, why should they pick you to write this essay, article, or listicle? For book pitches, let the editor know that you've researched your topic well. For example, I'm currently pitching a paranormal romance series on Japanese mythology, so I reference that I've previously studied abroad in Japan.

Perhaps your academic studies or work experience(s) contribute to the expertise behind your brilliant pitch/project. You might be a parent pitching a personal essay about your relaxed daily routine with three small kids. For an effective pitch, keep the main points focused on why your routine works. If it's an article, share the sources you plan to reference, including an expert or two that you have already reached out to. This shows the editor you've already done your homework/research ahead of time. This means you're worth betting on (especially if you're brand new to their group).

I often include a link from my author website which includes all of my recent writing clips. But when I'm pitching to a new editor (especially for a publication I haven't written for yet), I pare that list down for the specific topic I'm pitching, by including three helpful clips. This shows that I'm not wasting their time.

SECOND, tell the editor exactly what you're pitching. This might seem obvious, but if you simply share that you've got a really great idea -- without being clear about the main data points, then it's likely a quick pass. Remember, most editors are swamped, so your goal should be to grab them with a few compelling sentences right after your intro.

If it's for a personal essay, you need to explain that you've got a personal story that can be documented, as the editor will likely expect receipts, pictures (with photo credit), and screen shots of activities. For example, if you pitch a travel piece about train rides throughout Europe, your editor won't share your personal receipts/documentation with readers, but she'll need to keep them on file to back up the validity of your story for legal reasons.

For an article, make sure the pitch is direct and easy to understand. Ex: I'm pitching a piece on the dwindling honeybee population in the United States, and I already have two experts who are both available by next Friday. Include a comparison article from a similar journal/publication, so the editor can see your pitch's potential. Note: How will yours be unique from that comp?

For a listicle, you can provide an intro, four to five headers with a few sub-points for each of those, and a clear conclusion. An example could be: TK Best Lip Glosses for Teen Girls or TK Best Halloween Costumes for Small Dogs. Make sure to include a few links for recent comps from other publications too, so the editor can see that your pitch follows similar pubs' readership trends.

Note: If this topic is already archived via a quick search from their webpage(s), it might show it's no longer a relevant topic for their publication. However, if you see this, you can modify your pitch accordingly. Ex: I can see that your group covered three similar pieces over the past two years (include their internal links inside your pitch), but it might be worth revisiting -- since that topic is back and trending (quote SEO stats if possible). Note: You want to share why yours stands out for today's readers.

This simple search has saved me valuable time over the past decade! Forgetting to search has also cost me big-time. Ex: a piece with CNN on water conservation via an almost-interview with Michael Phelps initially created interest for an editor -- but then it ultimately got rejected when a second editor chimed in, noting how they had recently covered the same topic. If I'd tweaked the topic ahead of time -- sharing how my pitch offered a different perspective, it might have appeared more relevant and led to an actual contract.

For a book agent/editor, follow their specific guidelines. They're almost always listed verbatim on the agency's/publisher's submission guidelines' page (including whether or not they are currently open to submissions -- or if they are only accepting agented submissions). Sometimes there are specific calls for pitches, also known as open requests by editors. So, stick to the dates they list for these -- as your query/pitch will often be deleted if it isn't within the exact timeframe listed.

Also, following up with an editor after your pitch is generally not seen as a courtesy, and it can sometimes sabotage your efforts; remember, they are busy -- and if interested, they will contact you. This is different when it's an editor you already have a working relationship with. It's also okay to send a quick email if a particular editor shares, "Please follow up in so-many-weeks if you haven't heard back from me by then." The temptation sneaks in -- if I do more -- it will yield greater results, but that's not always the case in the writing industry.

If you don't provide exactly what an editor is asking for, your query might get passed over. Ex: If a book editor requires a two to three page synopsis, make sure to include that with your pitch (but if it's a full synopsis request, it needs to be between three to five pages). If they ONLY want the first ten pages of your manuscript as a writing sample, don't include your full manuscript just to be clever (it won't wow them!).

LASTLY, share why your pitch matters. For essays, articles, and listicles, this could be due to your professional experience, your list of writing clips from the past few years, or a specific expert you've recently crossed paths with -- who you'd plan to interview for your piece.

This includes, addressing why your pitch is relevant for their calendar (not usually the month you are currently in -- unless it's breaking news, which works differently). Note: Make sure to target the publication's typical timeline. Ex: Most digital publications are seeking pitches for the next six to eight weeks (again -- different guidelines for breaking news pieces). For magazines, it can be even longer, like three to four months out.

Perhaps, you are on various public relations' product lists (for samples or book ARCs), so you've already got five different "TK Best..." round-ups going (best coffee makers for camping trips, best sustainable sheets, best non-dairy creamers, best cozy fall rom-coms, etc.). Try to keep your list of products up to date -- ideally, from the past six to twelve months (though "coming soon" titles for book articles are usually fine)!

Note: To see if your pitch fits with their group, search for similar subjects or book titles to make sure you're a good match. Some examples include, Holiday Gift Guides, Caring for Your Aging Pet, Gardening for Small Spaces, etc. Ex: If you're pitching to an editor at Cosmopolitan, you need to keep your focus on lifestyle, cultural, and personal topics that target young-ish women; of course, there is crossover readership potential, but aiming for their target audience gives your pitch the best chance for success. For book comps (when pitching a literary agent or a book publisher), search by genre and your subject matter; if they only accept nonfiction queries, don't pitch that person/group your YA novel. Note: If you're pitching a YA manuscript, don't comp it to adult fiction titles.

Thanks for reading, and check out DianneBright.com for more tips and updates. Feel free to comment about something new that you're pitching.
 •  1 comment  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on August 07, 2026 12:14 Tags: authorlife, authortalk, bookish, books, editors, pitching, writing-tips
Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dianne (last edited Aug 18, 2026 12:38PM) (new)


back to top