Oh là là
The Lonely House: A Hercules Popeau Mystery by Marie Belloc LowndesMy rating: 5 of 5 stars
For me, this is an extraordinary book – but not necessarily for the standard reason that it is a very good book. (It is a very good book, and worthy of the sister of Hilaire Belloc.)
The Lonely House was published in 1920, and introduces the elderly French sleuth Hercules Popeau, and his younger sidekick, Captain Angus Stuart.
Also published in 1920 was The Mysterious Affair at Styles, which introduces the elderly Belgian sleuth Hercule Poirot, and his younger sidekick, Captain Arthur Hastings.
Marie Belloc Lowndes entered a complaint to the Society of Authors that her main character had been plagiarised by a fellow crime writer by the name of Agatha Christie. It seems her entreaties fell upon deaf ears.
Back to The Lonely House.
Demure, attractive, twenty-year-old English heiress Lily Fairfield is sent to recuperate with her down-at-heel aristocratic step-aunt-and-uncle in a crumbling and remote hillside mansion above Monte Carlo. It is aptly named La Solitude. The impoverished Count and Countess Polda suspiciously come into wads of cash that correspond to murders of former dinner guests and it soon becomes clear that they are lining up Lily to marry their profligate playboy son, Beppo. They will stop at nothing – no one must stand in their way – not even Hercules Popeau – and especially not Lily’s preferred suitor Captain Angus Stuart.
The plot is perfectly plausible, with agonising twists and growing jeopardy for poor naïve Lily. The characters are finely drawn, good and evil and exploitable. And the setting is sinister and evocative, expertly portraying the Old Town of Monaco and the Casino with its high life and lowlife, against the mesmerising backdrop of the beautiful riviera.
Genre-wise, there is strong thread of Romance that runs through the entire novel, and the interwoven criminal aspect is more Suspense than Mystery or Whodunit.
Remarkably, for its little-known existence (I had to find it on Project Gutenberg, where you can download it free), it outshines any of Agatha Christie’s works, and it is a crying shame that Mrs Belloc Lowndes lost the battle of the eccentric detectives. Popeau appears in just one other novel, One of Those Ways (1929). Poirot clocked up 33 novels.
Of course, it wouldn’t be a proper Golden Age Mystery if this tale of purported plagiarism didn’t have a sting in the tail. My further researches revealed that, beginning in 1909, Welsh author Frank Howell Evans wrote a series of 30 crime novels featuring retired French detective, M. Jules Poiret. And his sidekick? Captain Haven.
Poiret? Popeau? Poirot?
Oh là là!
View all my reviews
Published on October 16, 2026 10:03
•
Tags:
agatha-christie, bruce-beckham, golden-age, skelgill
No comments have been added yet.


