Controlling, psychotic men: The new hot?

The worst thing a writer can do is not say anything.

I have that quotation on a post it note stuck above my desk. Yet I wonder whether it’s actually accurate. It seems to me that one of the worst things a writer can do is to say something that acts in disservice of their gender.

Recently I’ve become more and more aware of the number of books being published, particularly in the YA realm, and by women too, which to my mind are damaging to girls. Books which do more to push back gender equality than any offensive statements by Kanye West, ever could.

I’m talking about books that portray controlling, obsessive, even psychotic boys as hot and desirable because they have a six-pack, cheekbones you could slice salami on, and they kiss really well. Books that portray a healthy relationship as one in which the boy beats the crap out of any guy who so much as looks sideways at ‘their’ girl. Books in which men stalk girls, act out violently, manipulate and otherwise emotionally abuse the girl because ‘they love her’. Yeah, I’m not sure in what world that qualifies as love. And always the girl forgives said boy because she needs him, he’s her soul mate, she can’t live without him…and don’t forget…he’s hot!

Please. Is this what we want to teach teenage girls? Is this what we want for the next generation of women? For them to grow up looking for this in their ideal partner? Is this what we want young men to think is what girls actually want?

Isn't it bad enough that Chris Brown's career sky rockets in the wake of him smashing his fists into Rihanna's face and that she responds by calling him the love of her life? We have awful enough 'role models' in real life - do we have to create them in fiction too?

The thing that gets me most though is that these books are written by women.

(Referring back to the Kanye West comment he made on Twitter, what riled me most was not the comment itself, but the fact that his girlfriend Kim Kardashian backed him up, telling her millions of Twitter followers that it was OK to call a woman a bitch. Again…in what world is that OK?).

Let’s stop betraying our gender girls. We can’t ever expect men to grant us respect and equal rights if we can’t even respect ourselves (Rihanna, Kim Kardashian, and all you readers and writers take note!)

As an author and as a woman (and a mother) I believe that I have a responsibility and a duty to my readers (and my daughter) to portray both healthy male and female role models and healthy relationships. Girls who are in control of their own stories, who are smart, resilient and know when a guy is being a total jerk and aren't afraid to tell him. Girls who’d never let a guy control them or tell them what to do. Girls who kick ass and can look after themselves (admittedly, having that hot, intelligent and loving boy as a sidekick). My girls are heroines in the true sense of the word.

I don’t want to paint completely idealised romances either. My characters have flaws – they’re people after all. But mainly I want girls to read my books and feel stronger, feel prouder to be a girl, to come away feeling that it’s OK to not have a boyfriend, it’s OK to feel desire and want sex, but it’s also OK to wait – in fact it’s often a good idea to wait.

I want girls to know that the right guy (and there will be one) is not the guy who likes to beat the crap out of people or tell you what to wear, what to eat and how to dress. But the guy who supports you, is kind, is loving and puts you not on a pedestal, but on an equal footing.

To writers:
Teenage readers are influenced by our words, by our stories. Make them count.

To readers:
Think carefully about what you feed your subconscious. Question the books you read and the messages they are sending. Become a critical reader and shout from the rooftops when you find something offensive or sexist. Let publishers know. But most especially, if you're female, fight back against anything that denigrates women. It's your duty.

To publishers:
STOP publishing these books. Stop running with the trends. Start bucking them. Empower the next generation through the books you choose, don't disempower them at such a critical age. Yours is a position of power, don't abuse it.
25 likes ·   •  5 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on September 14, 2012 18:27 Tags: feminism, fiction, hunting-lila, publishing, reading, sexism, tips, writing, writing-for-teens, young-adult
Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

I agree 100% with you on this! You said it perfectly! It's one thing to have a misunderstood bad boy that is actually the nice guy but to glorify the psycho guy just because he's "hot" is wrong. Young girls already have a lot of imagery to deal with on looks, we don't need them to feel like it's okay to be with a guy that treats women bad.


message 2: by Nakeesha (new)

Nakeesha Thank you so much for speaking out Sarah. I say that as a mother of a daughter and as a grown woman. I watch little girls walk around with Twilight under their arms and I cringe. I see grown women giggling over 50 Shades and my fists ball up. As a teenage girl I thought that perfect Prince Charming was a damaging ideal. I never thought I wish for the return of those days!


message 3: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Wolfe I too have noticed this trend and have become disturbed by it.

I think it's great to have damaged characters, in fact I want flaws in all the main character; that's what makes them interesting and able to be related to. But how can I respect or even like a character that does not respect or care for themselves?

In these novels where the male lead is made excuses for - he had a bad childhood, he was abused himself, he was cheated on and abandoned by a previous girlfriend, whatever the case may be - he never seeks help and he never really apologizes for his behavior even when he is aware of how irrational and mentally unbalanced he is. He just attaches himself onto the lead female like a barnacle. The lead female doesn't seem to mind, doesn't encourage him to seek out some kind of psychotherapy for his issues, and decides that with only her undying love and devotion he will change and be the most perfect boyfriend. It is very damaging to women, in adolescence and adulthood, to read novels like this and think that this is acceptable or the norm for any relationship.

It also sends the wrong message to males as well. They might start to believe a girl will have no interest in them unless they are domineering and obsessive.


message 4: by Tzadikim (new)

Tzadikim Thank you so much for writing this.

Now days I have such a hard time finding a good YA book because of these controlling, abusive male leads. I mean, what's wrong with a goofy, adorable boy instead? More Augustus Walter and less Edward Cullen.

I think that's why I like the Hunger Games more than I should—Peeta is sweet. Anyway, I can only count a handful of YA Paranornal books that don't have that.

Now that's just pathetic, and what is the appeal with male leads like Cullen?

//Sighs.

I hope your male leads, Ms Alderson, get the recognition that they deserve.


message 5: by Sarah (saz101) (new)

Sarah (saz101) Here, here!
Sarah, I don't know what to say -- you've said it all. It's like the bad 80's rapey-romance resurgence... but it's worse, because these books are for girls only just finding their place, and developing an idea of what romance is, or what is a normal, healthy relationship.

I think this: "Think carefully about what you feed your subconscious." is SO important. We choose to allow in what shapes us. It's like feeding your body healthy food, or junk. Our minds are just the same.

I LOVE this. Thank you for sharing ♥


back to top

Writing and all the bits in between

Sarah Alderson
I have a blog at www.canwelivehere.com which documents my life living in Bali, writing, drinking coconuts, dancing ecstatically and meeting crazy people.

I have a website at www.sarahalderson.com where
...more
Follow Sarah Alderson's blog with rss.