Woody, The Teacher said: "Those who enjoy this genre will not be disappointed. This is a fun, fast read with more interesting characters than one usually finds in historic naval fiction. Winston ranks with Forester, OBrian, and Kent."

J. said: " As the other books in this series, this book really kept my interest. It had a good pace but yet dedicated time to the indiviual characters so that they had time to "come alive". I liked some of the different actions that happened that I don't recall happening (similarly) in either the Hornblower or the Bolitho series. I was eager to read this book but yet sad when it was over because I had no more to read."

Steve Hinson said: "I read a LOT of books- Michael Winston is among the better authors out there in classic naval ficton. He does the genre proud with authentic backround information, believable and fallible characters, and plenty of edge-of-your-seat adventure. I look forward to more from Mr. Winston in the future in this vein."

William Elliot said: "Like his other books, there is considerable background but once Kinkaid gets to sea, this novel is terrific. Many surprising turns. I'm a fan of historical fiction and this is one of my favorite series. I really hope there will be more."