date
newest »
newest »
Thanks, Triss. And let me know how you like KASHMIRI, will you? ( And tell your friends, and write a review, and share on FB--if you feel so moved. Because KASHMIRI isn't a mystery, I don't have the promotional apparatus of Poisoned Pen Press behind me this time. Social media is my primary PR.)
As another "established author" (5 novels with major presses) gone to self-publishing (I've now self-pubbed 3 books) because my latest novel The Executioner's Heir: A Novel of Eighteenth-Century France was apparently "unpublishable"--or possibly because I, the author, was not enough of a mega-seller to be considered publishable any more--I am with you, feel your frustration, couldn't agree more with your sentiments, and thank you for a great post. Best of luck, Joanne.
I have The Kashmiri Shawl on my kindle, Joanne, although I haven't read it yet. As soon as I read the description I wanted it! Hoping it does well for you.
Sarah wrote: "I have The Kashmiri Shawl on my kindle, Joanne, although I haven't read it yet. As soon as I read the description I wanted it! Hoping it does well for you." Sarah, I do hope you enjoy it! And I'm looking forward to your latest, as well!
I've often felt the established Publishing World has an extremely limited idea of what it decides to publish and you've just verified that for me. "Love your book, but the big thing now is serial killers. Throw one in and we'll talk."I truly believe that the authors who put in the time and effort to create interesting, well written stories that don't fit the latest Big Thing will succeed in self publishing.
And good luck now that you've gone over to the Dark Side, at least according to James Patterson.
Susanne wrote: "As another "established author" (5 novels with major presses) gone to self-publishing (I've now self-pubbed 3 books) because my latest novel [book:The Executioner's Heir: A Novel of Eighteenth-Cent..." Susanne, yes, I didn't address that, but you're so right. "The Market" no longer seems to have the patience to foster mid-list authors. Publishers seem to have discarded even the notion of a back-list.
Judy wrote: "I've often felt the established Publishing World has an extremely limited idea of what it decides to publish and you've just verified that for me. "Love your book, but the big thing now is serial k..." Judy, you're right, of course. It seems to be a very different situation than prevailed even 20 years ago when I signed my first contract for a whimsical and satiric academic mystery with Doubleday. But that was before Bertelsmann gobbled DD up. Poisoned Pen Press, of course, would publish another of my mysteries, if I were to write one, but they're Independent and still maintain integrity.
Interesting post. I would have thought India would interest some in the Publishing World--that setting seems to be HOT at the present time. Ah well, there's just no rhyme or reason these days. Good luck with the book. I enjoyed it immensely.
Beverle wrote: "Interesting post. I would have thought India would interest some in the Publishing World--that setting seems to be HOT at the present time. Ah well, there's just no rhyme or reason these days. Good..." Thanks for the kind words, Bev, and for the good wishes. They're much more cheering than "rhyme and reason"!
Joanne, loved the whole piece. The last paragraph says it all, for a lot of us. I'm buying the book as soon as I get off Goodreads and FB. Wishing you huge sales and happy writing.
Nora wrote: "Joanne, loved the whole piece. The last paragraph says it all, for a lot of us. I'm buying the book as soon as I get off Goodreads and FB. Wishing you huge sales and happy writing." Nora, thank you SO much. I do hope you enjoy it!
Very interesting. Thank you.It's sad that you weren't able to find the right publisher. While I certainly wish for your book to be successful, the other problem (is it one?) is that readers have also got accustomed to thinking in certain set ways - mystery, romance, serial killers etc. Do they perhaps search for books in the way publishers would like them to? If so, would books that don't exactly fit in find it difficult to find their reader? Just wondering.
Thank you for sharing your experience. Vasudev raises an interesting question about readers and genre conventions; however, I wonder whether the problem is that publishers are afraid of taking any kind of risk, especially nowadays. In any case, I wish you the very best with your book and intend to read it. I too am tired of serial killers and decadent dukes!
Vasudev and S.K. Good insights! I do think there's a major difference between genre and formula. Genres are, and have always been, wonderfully variable forms of story telling, flexible and capable of developing with teller and across time. Formulas seem to be more rigid, imposed on storytelling rather than providing a wellspring for them. When our publishers are ruled by international media-investment conglomerates rather than by people who truly know literature and have the best interests of books in mind rather than the best interests of M.B.A.s and their clients, readers and writers suffer.
But is it really possible for publishers to publish a book without taking into its account its financial viability? They can probably take a risk about 10% of the time, but otherwise, would they not have to look at supply and demand like any other enterprise? Pondering....
Vasudev wrote: "But is it really possible for publishers to publish a book without taking into its account its financial viability?" It's a matter of scale, isn't it? An independent press makes its own decisions and answers to itself and its own needs. A press owned by a multinational media investment firm answers to its investors and makes decisions based on their needs.
You could have written fan fiction, an alternate universe version of Jane Eyre. That also probably could have gotten published easier. I've heard fan fiction is quite the thing. But I liked it the way it came out, in New York, with an American heroine. So brava.
Joanne, I agree with Beverle. India, with it's rich complex culture and history of conflict, not to mention its current ascendancy in education and technical topics, offers a setting of great interest to readers. It has also become a top travel destination. I think you are just ahead of the curve for stories set there. You lead and others will follow.




This is really interesting and thoughtful, more thoughtful than many of the rants on this hot topic. Much appreciated. And the book goes right on my TBR list.
Triss Stein