Hannah’s review of Never Let Me Go > Likes and Comments
913 likes · Like
You should watch the movie! Its one of few adaptations that did the book justice. The soundtrack and performances are perfect.
this was one that i actually really liked the movie better than the book, i was crushed by the movie but when i read the book i felt similar to how you said that it's just objectively sad.
I was weeeeeping for the last twenty pages of this book 😭 my favorite book of all time. I love how it teeters in this tentative place of breadcrumbing a disturbing alternate universe, but by the time you put the pieces together, you realize the actual story is about these close friends in this horrific experience trying to process what their lives are and their relationships to each other. And I love Ishiguro’s use of simplistic, subtle, and heartbreaking slow reveals of information through dialogue. But I totally understand your perspective!
This was the bleakest take on humanity I’ve read in a long time LOL
I watched the film first and then read the book to its soundtrack. Absolutely devastating.
I read this, I wanna say when I was 14? I was young. Anyway.. I WAS NOT READY. but even years later I am still thinking of this story, it’s one of the first books that I really ‘took with me’ so to speak. As you say, the writing is phenomenal. I wonder if I would think different re-reading it now as an adult. I won’t ever forget these characters, they are so engrained in my mind. I would 100% recommend the film if you haven’t watched it already.
I just finished it last night. I'm still in a bleak, sad mood today. Very powerful.
I completely agree! I wanted to love it but the plot was not super devastating to me and I didn’t feel any real connection to the characters. Honestly this book just left me in a reading slump.
What was most disturbing to me was how easily these very likable (if flawed) characters capitulated to their fate.
Capitulated as opposed to? What else would they have done? The most sympathetic to their plight regarded them as revolting walking spiders. What society would they have fled to? What life would they have fled toward? The clones didn’t even fully understand their plight. By the time they got a semblance of understanding it was too late. Like Tommy says they always learned information at the optimal point where they could do nothing with it.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Erica
(new)
Jan 26, 2024 12:47AM
You should watch the movie! Its one of few adaptations that did the book justice. The soundtrack and performances are perfect.
reply
|
flag
this was one that i actually really liked the movie better than the book, i was crushed by the movie but when i read the book i felt similar to how you said that it's just objectively sad.
I was weeeeeping for the last twenty pages of this book 😭 my favorite book of all time. I love how it teeters in this tentative place of breadcrumbing a disturbing alternate universe, but by the time you put the pieces together, you realize the actual story is about these close friends in this horrific experience trying to process what their lives are and their relationships to each other. And I love Ishiguro’s use of simplistic, subtle, and heartbreaking slow reveals of information through dialogue. But I totally understand your perspective!
This was the bleakest take on humanity I’ve read in a long time LOL
I watched the film first and then read the book to its soundtrack. Absolutely devastating.
I read this, I wanna say when I was 14? I was young. Anyway.. I WAS NOT READY. but even years later I am still thinking of this story, it’s one of the first books that I really ‘took with me’ so to speak. As you say, the writing is phenomenal. I wonder if I would think different re-reading it now as an adult. I won’t ever forget these characters, they are so engrained in my mind. I would 100% recommend the film if you haven’t watched it already.
I just finished it last night. I'm still in a bleak, sad mood today. Very powerful.
I completely agree! I wanted to love it but the plot was not super devastating to me and I didn’t feel any real connection to the characters. Honestly this book just left me in a reading slump.
What was most disturbing to me was how easily these very likable (if flawed) characters capitulated to their fate.
Capitulated as opposed to? What else would they have done? The most sympathetic to their plight regarded them as revolting walking spiders. What society would they have fled to? What life would they have fled toward? The clones didn’t even fully understand their plight. By the time they got a semblance of understanding it was too late. Like Tommy says they always learned information at the optimal point where they could do nothing with it.
