Romance is often complicated in fiction. What are the best books with love triangles? (Please no young adult books. Check out these other lists filled with great YA recommendations.)
Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jane
(new)
Oct 14, 2012 08:12AM
Ravens Deep Ravens Deep is the first book in a dark romantic trilogy. The love triangle unfolds in the second book - Blood & Ashes.
reply
|
flag
Just goes to show--love triangles were around for a long time before Twilight. @Jessica: there are a YA title and a biography on here; do you want me to remove them?
To me a love triangle is more than an affair outside of a mariage or committed relationship, though it often includes that. It is a case of someone who is truly torn between two loves over a long period of time and for good reasons. That's why I added Love Medicine by Louise Erdrich. I don't remember the names of the characters any more since it was so long ago that I read it, but it was a true traingle.
Wanda wrote: "Please check #161. I do not believe it belongs on this list."Plenty of books have recently been added to this list that don't belong here, alas. Nonfiction (essays, philosophy, religion), fiction that doesn't even contain a love story, LET ALONE a love triangle ... Jessica, would you like a librarian to do a bit of clean-up work?
Also, what about biographies of real persons involved in love triangles? (E.g., I see Massie's bio of Catherine the Great has been added and is steadily gaining votes. Stay or go?)
Yes, thank you. Librarians, feel free to remove books that legitimately don't have a love triangle.But nonfiction involving love triangles feels relevant. It's interesting to see the real-life antecedents.
Removed, for the time being:The Art of Happiness
Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking
How to Win Friends and Influence People
Book of Honey Tattoo Flash Designs (twice)
A Book of Flowers Flash Sketchbook
8 Minutes in the Morning: A Simple Way to Shed Up to 2 Pounds a Week Guaranteed
Shakespeare's Language
Macbeth
The Old Man and the Sea
I Love You Through and Through
The Meaning of Me
The Last Best Hope: A Civil War Era Alternate History
Wild: From Lost to Found on the Pacific Crest Trail
The House of Silk: A Sherlock Holmes Novel
Paradise Lost
Art Through the Ages
Immediate Family
The Shock of the New
There are plenty of others that I doubt have a legitimate place on this list (especially among the books currently on p. 2 and 3), but that will require a bit more investigation.
Well, there are 10 people who have voted for Ella, Enchanted and 9 who have voted for The Outsiders. Before a librarian decides whether or not to step in, maybe some of these folks want to speak up and explain why they think these two books fit the criteria for this list?As for the two Brontë books, I at any rate won't remove those unless Jessica specifically says she doesn't want them here. They may not be the epitome of what we consider a love triangle today, but they very much expressed that situation in Victorian terms. For a woman to leave her husband (abusive or not) was unheard of in Victorian society in the first place, and to even contemplate turning to another man (as happens in The Tenant of Wildfell Hall) was as unthinkable as for a woman to reject a "respectable" offer of marriage (like that from St. John Rivers in Jane Eyre: note that "respectability" required only financial security and social standing, NOT love), "just" because the woman in question is in love with another man ... especially if, ostensibly, the "competitor" was unattainable to her anyway. Also, there is another triangle in Jane Eyre -- the one between herself, Rochester and his first wife -- which likewise touches on a taboo, namely, bigamy. And, finally, the marriage being abandoned in The Tenant of Wildfell Hall to Helen herself actually WAS a love match initially (or at least, infatuation) ... it only turned sour later on, albeit fairly quickly.
In other words: in Victorian society, the mere notion of a "love" triangle as such was a nonentity, because love simply wasn't a consideration at all when it came to choosing a partner in marriage; and once married, a woman just had to stand by her husband ("for ill or for good, until death do us part") -- for her to do anything else was not just to break social convention but even to break the law. It was precisely this disregard of love as a material factor in marriage -- as well as the notion that it was only "she" who needed to prove that she was worthy of "him", rather than also vice versa -- that the Brontë sisters sought to highlight and criticize in their books (Charlotte incidentally did so again, in as forceful terms, in Emma).
Alright, upon review, the following strike me as Young Adult:The Outsiders
Ella Enchanted
After Forever Ends
Thoughtless
Effortless
I Capture the Castle
Son of the Shadows
A Witch in Love
Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children
A Spy in the House
The Hunger Games
The Last Letter
Girl in Translation
Genesis
Nick of Time
Taking Chances
Bitter Blood
Island Beneath the Sea
Impossible
Before I delete them, is there somebody (maybe some of the folks who voted for these books) who can give a reason why they are within the parameters of a list entitled "Literary Love Triangles (Non-YA)" -- and which contains the added expres caveat "Please no young adult books" -- and why they should NOT be deleted?
I can understand wanting to vote for a book you have fallen in love with, but... If this is really just about love triangles, in my opinion, there are many books that should be removed.. Books, that I too love, but don't fit the criteria of the vote.. Just my opinion.. :-)
Themis-Athena wrote: "Alright, upon review, the following strike me as Young Adult:The Outsiders
Ella Enchanted
After Forever Ends
Thoughtless
Effortless
I Capture the Castle
Son of the Shadows
A Witch in Love
Miss Pe..."
Since in almost 2 weeks nobody has come forward to explain why the books in my above post should not be characterized as "Young Adult," I have now deleted them, as well as the following more recent additions:
The Magicians
Daughter of Smoke & Bone
Wonderstruck
The Maude Reed Tale
Forget Me Not,
which are also Young Adult.
Moreover, on investigation, I fail to see love triangles figuring in the following books (not all of which are even fiction or (auto)biographies), and which I have therefore also deleted:
Automaton
How to Flirt with a Naked Werewolf
Love in a time of outsourcing
Maligned
The Merchant of Venice
Clotho's Loom: A Novel of Literary Romance and Realism
Much Ado About Nothing
Catch-22
Merminia
In Defense of Food: An Eater's Manifesto
Oz: The Wonderful Wizard Of Oz
Chicken on the Hudson
A Life Worth Living
Fool
الثورة 2.0
The Chronicles of a Crazy Chick
The Winemaker's Dinner: Appetizers
Blue Straggler
Tempted
V for Vendetta
The Mutter Museum: Of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia
The Nightlife: New York
Wicked Ties
Imbroglio
Gideon's Sword
Elephant House: Photographs of Edward Gorey's House
A Deconstructed Heart
Hinduism
The Grand Design
The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable
Drift: The Unmooring of American Military Power
The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair that Changed America
Hark! a Vagrant
Me Talk Pretty One Day
Into the Wilderness
The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks
Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community, and War
Below Stairs: The Classic Kitchen Maid's Memoir That Inspired "Upstairs, Downstairs" and "Downton Abbey"
Can someone please take Lord of the Flies off the list? (And maybe even Fellowship?) I really doubt there's any kind of love triangle going on in those books....or at least not canon ones....
Triv wrote: "Harry Potter is young adult and I don't recall a prominent love triangle in the first"Removed Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (clearly YA).
As for Lord of the Flies and The Fellowship of the Ring; again, maybe those who voted for these books can explain where they see them containing a love triangle?
"The Bridges Of Madison County" is a great love triangle story and some of the best writing ever. Robert Waller can pack an immense amount of feeling in but a few words. I thought the rating was too low on this story. I gave it 5-stars: great story and great writing. A short book, but 45 minutes of pleasure.
Why Jane Eyre? Saint John wasn't in love with her, she wasn't in love with him. Some marriage talk doesn't mean there's love involved.
Related News
Need another excuse to treat yourself to a new book this week? We've got you covered with the buzziest new releases of the day, according to early...
Anyone can add books to this list.


















