Michelle
745 books
1 friend
1 friend
Greyweather
2660 books
65 friends
65 friends
Susanna - Censored by GoodReads
3386 books
851 friends
851 friends
Bettie
15674 books
19 friends
19 friends
Rhonda
84 books
0 friends
0 friends
Lynne
511 books
0 friends
0 friends
Kelly
555 books
57 friends
57 friends
Melissa
5834 books
136 friends
136 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-42 of 42 (42 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Janice
(new)
Aug 19, 2011 08:25AM
The edition of The Stone Angel shown in this list is a dramatization of the book by James W. Nichol. Is there a Goodreads Librarian who can change the edition to one that is written by Margaret Laurence so that it accurately reflects the correct author?
reply
|
flag
As far as I can see, both books are actually on this list -- and since Nichol is a Canadian playwright, isn't his dramatization properly included on that basis alone?That said, is this for authors LIVING in Canada or who are Canadian CITIZENS? Emma Donoghue lives in Ontario now, but she's actually Irish ...
Themis-Athena wrote: "As far as I can see, both books are actually on this list -- and since Nichol is a Canadian playwright, isn't his dramatization properly included on that basis alone?That said, is this for author..."
According to Wikipedia, she became a Canadian citizen in 2004.
David Guterson is not Canadian, but American. Therefore, I removed Snow Falling on Cedars from the list.
Tracy Chevalier is not Canadian and has been removed.Once I'd started, I decided to delete all authors I recognized as 'non-Canadian' (and it was quite a lot of work, because I checked before I deleted). I most probably haven't deleted all non-Canadian authors, just the ones I recognised, so I'm sure there are several others who do not belong on this list (the number of USA authors I had to delete was amazing...)
So please, when adding titles, do make sure the author is CANADIAN and not American (and still living in the States!!!), or whatever. Thanks! :-)
Booklovinglady wrote: "Tracy Chevalier is not Canadian and has been removed.Once I'd started, I decided to delete all authors I recognized as 'non-Canadian' (and it was quite a lot of work, because I checked before I d..."
Thank you!!
Please tell me how to delete them & I will take all the John Grisham, Agatha Christie, Lois Lowry, Michael Crichton etc out. There are so many incredible Canadian Authors it is hard to imagine so many people can be so sloppy or else unaware of them!
While trying to figure out how to delete entries I was surprised to find that most of them were added by someone called yesucan - could it be that someone is spamming this list??
Mariellen wrote: "While trying to figure out how to delete entries I was surprised to find that most of them were added by someone called yesucan - could it be that someone is spamming this list??"I don't know if you deleted these, but the 'yesucan' person certainly has added Agatha Christie, Michael Crichton, Patricia Cornwell, James Patterson... I have deleted those I was sure of.
Please. The Canadian (and correct) title of Lawrence Hill's novel is 'The Book of Negroes' and not 'Someone Knows My Name'. (#16) Kindly amend.
Thanks, Bernadine! I double checked that she was indeed Australian and removed the book from the list. I also noticed that Philip Pullman's The Golden Compass was on there and removed it as well as he is British.
Seems like user vote https://www.goodreads.com/list/user_v... may be more suspicious than most. I spotted Lois Lowry again and Geraldine Brooks and S. J. Watson - none of which seem to have been born or live in Canada.
Removing Before I Go To Sleep by S. J. Watson (from the UK)RemovingNumber the Stars by Lois Lowry (from Hawaii, Mass, Maine)
Removing Double Standards and A Kingdom of Dreams by Judith McNaught (from California, Missouri and Texas)
Mauberley wrote: "Please. The Canadian (and correct) title of Lawrence Hill's novel is 'The Book of Negroes' and not 'Someone Knows My Name'. (#16) Kindly amend."I guess it depends on whether the person adding it to the list read it in Canada or the States ( Don't know which version is available in other countries)
It does mess up the stats a lot but I can understand that people who have read the book under the "sanitized(?)" name would use that when voting.
Should The Boy in the Striped Pajamas (#99) really be in this list? It looks like John Boyne was born in Ireland and still lives there.
Booklovinglady wrote: "Tracy Chevalier is not Canadian and has been removed.Once I'd started, I decided to delete all authors I recognized as 'non-Canadian' (and it was quite a lot of work, because I checked before I d..."
I nominated several books which got deleted. I honestly wish someone had notified me before having them deleted, tbh, since despite the fact that they now don't fulfill the above description re: the authors, as I did put some thought into the nominations/suggestions I made.
I definitely have deleted books from this list and would do so again. It is too bad that people can't follow clearly stated list directions but in a great great great number of goodreads lists they can't. Does that mean all books deleted are deleted correctly? no. I'm sorry that Coucher de soleil feels badly about this - badly enough to repeat a fairly obnoxious comment in https://www.goodreads.com/list/user_v... "All right, several of my votes got deleted, which is annoying (especially since I tried to reflect the breadth of Canadian experience in my choices). It would have been nice to have been notified of this. More Goodreads censorship?"
The message a librarian sees before deleting books is as follows:
"Note: Only delete books from the list that are totally miscategorized. Deleting books that aren't will result in a loss of librarian privileges, and possible deletion of account. We're super serious!"
I've yet to see a librarian being capricious around deleting books from lists.
Mitchell wrote: "I definitely have deleted books from this list and would do so again. It is too bad that people can't follow clearly stated list directions but in a great great great number of goodreads lists they..."*sigh*
I sincerely apologize for the tone of my response (I will admit to being a bit miffed once I noticed the deletion). But surely you can sympathize with the notion of putting some serious thought into something only to have your efforts deleted?
PS: Was such a reply really necessary?
Stephen wrote: "Today I added the three volumes of The King Trilogy..."Do you really need a Listopia to promote your own books? You do realize this says something about you as the author...
I had a look at your profile where it clearly says, and I quote, "It would be appreciated if all of my Goodreads friends voted for the above books in the following lists".
I personally would consider such a thing spamming.
Booklovinglady wrote: "Stephen wrote: "Today I added the three volumes of The King Trilogy..."Do you really need a Listopia to promote your own books? You do realize this says something about you as the author...
I had..."
The answer to your question is "no." I posted that a long time ago, when I did not understand Listopia. I will attempt to remove what we both agree should not have been posted.
Stephen wrote: "Booklovinglady wrote: "Stephen wrote: "Today I added the three volumes of The King Trilogy..."Do you really need a Listopia to promote your own books? You do realize this says something about you..."
Apology accepted :-) It is easy by the way to remove your own comment (and I can remove the books for you, if you like).
Deleted (for not being Canadian authors):William Gibson - "The Miracle Worker" (The author of "Neuromancer" William Gibson is Canadian-American, this playwright is not).
Lisa Genova - "Still Alice"
Garth Nix - "Lirael"
Kathy Reichs is on this list, but she is not Canadian even though much of the action in her books takes place in Montreal.
Colleen wrote: "Kathy Reichs is on this list, but she is not Canadian even though much of the action in her books takes place in Montreal.""Kathy Reichs is a forensic anthropologist for the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, State of North Carolina, and for the Laboratoire des Sciences Judiciaires et de Médecine Légale for the province of Quebec. She is one of only fifty forensic anthropologists certified by the American Board of Forensic Anthropology and is on the Board of Directors of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. A professor of anthropology at The University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Dr. Reichs is a native of Chicago, where she received her Ph.D. at Northwestern. She now divides her time between Charlotte and Montreal and is a frequent expert witness in criminal trials."
Colleen wrote: "So this list is broad. Thanks for explanation."Actually this list is unclear. The list description isn't explicit. By custom the list creator would set this kind of criteria.
At times a librarian will make a list more explicit, especially if there is an active message board and clear consensus.
Sue wrote: "Kathy Reichs is not Canadian"someone added her again - could you please delete all her books?
Linwood Barclay and Julia Quinn are not Canadian as well.
Fiona wrote: "Peter Carey's Oscar and Lucinda should be removed. Both author and book are Australian."Done. And I fully agree, as he is indeed Australian and not Canadian :-)
Carolyn wrote: "Noticed Annie Proulx listed who is an American not a Canadian author!"Schiffsmeldungen by Annie Proulx has been deleted, as you are absolutely right.
Next time, do mention the number where you found the book/author, as it is much easier for a librarian to remove it we know approximately where it is 😉
Wasn't sure about adding the Witches of New York by Ami McKay. She was born in the US, but married a Canadian and now lives in Canada. The CBC sometimes lists her as a Canadian writer.
How does one remove a book from this list? Raymond Khoury (The Last Templar) is not a Canadian author.
@AmyLibrarians can remove books from a Listopia (otherwise only the votes one has added can be removed). If you want a book removed, do mention not only the title/author but also the current number you found the book on, as it makes it (a lot) easier for a librarian to remove a book 😉
(The Last Templar has been removed.)
Related News
Now here’s an interesting stack of books…
To honor the conclusion of the first quarter of the new century, we’ve ventured deep into the...
Anyone can add books to this list.














