Tags:
britain, england, europe, great-britain, historical-fiction, ireland, scotland, setting, uk, united-kingdom, wales
Jan
3109 books
265 friends
265 friends
Susanna - Censored by GoodReads
3386 books
852 friends
852 friends
Thom
6022 books
294 friends
294 friends
Lobstergirl
5768 books
157 friends
157 friends
Liane
930 books
13 friends
13 friends
Bettie
15674 books
19 friends
19 friends
Misfit
5492 books
531 friends
531 friends
Mary
637 books
69 friends
69 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-50 of 63 (63 new)
message 1:
by
Bettie
(new)
Oct 20, 2009 12:20PM
If you want to include the whole of Ireland then the term UK doesn't cover it.
reply
|
flag
Bettie wrote: "If you want to include the whole of Ireland then the term UK doesn't cover it."Thanks for pointing that out, I guess I should have said the UK and the whole of Ireland.
How fab to see so many great books added to this little list I started.
Beadyjan wrote: "Bettie wrote: "If you want to include the whole of Ireland then the term UK doesn't cover it."Thanks for pointing that out, I guess I should have said the UK and the whole of Ireland.
How f..."
Hello there Beadyjan - the term British Isles covers all and everything. And, you are right - it's an all encompassing subject for a list. I had to stop myself at 75 to leave room for the 'musts' later on.
:O)
Yay! I have just found out that I have a passion for this genre & can't wait to start reading.
Thanks for the list! :)
What is Snow Flower and the Secret Fan doing on this list? It all took place in China. And Jurassic Park???
Isn't historical fiction something that was in the past for the author? While books such as Pride and Prejudice may be very much in the past now, they weren't for the author, so should they be on this list?
This list needs a good clean up. There are quite a few that aren't historical fiction (not by anyone's definition) and a couple that aren't set in UK and Ireland or aren't fiction. Will post a list of problem books I spotted if anybody wants one.
That would be great, Jemidar; particularly if you could list whereabouts on the list you saw it (makes tracking down the suckers easier when removing).
Susanna wrote: "That would be great, Jemidar; particularly if you could list whereabouts on the list you saw it (makes tracking down the suckers easier when removing)."Seconded ...
#152 is a book which I do not believe to be historical fiction. Flavia is a fun-to-read modern (1950/1960) mystery series. I enjoy the series very much but do not believe it qualifies as h-f. If I am wrong, I apologize.
I'm still working on it. Between finding more than than I originally thought there were and the page taking ages to load it's pretty slow and tedious going. Coming soon though. Promise!
Jemidar wrote: "I'm still working on it. Between finding more than than I originally thought there were and the page taking ages to load it's pretty slow and tedious going. Coming soon though. Promise!"Yeah, the new green warts really speed things up.
Not.
Susanna wrote: "Yeah, the new green warts really speed things up.Not."
Amen!! (Again.) Big annoyance, that.
Susanna wrote: "It's set sixty years ago - isn't that historical fiction?"Not for me. The term historical fiction is a subjective one. I would consider Flavia as more modern fiction/literature. H-F to me means more along the lines of Sharon Kay Penman and Dorothy Dunnett. So, the term will remain subjective. I won't argue or debate. I will just go.
Deleted The Secret Garden and Pride and Prejudice, which are not historical fiction properly defined.
Wives and Daughters #100 wouldn't be historical fiction. When it was published it was quite contemporary. Neither would be North and South #232 for the same reasons. Wuthering Heights #246 should also be removed.
Deleted -- along with a minor boatload of other novels likewise not belonging into the historical fiction category because they were contemporary from their authors' POV (essentially, everybody's 19th century darlings ... Austen, the Brontes, Gaskell, Hardy and Trollope. Fortunately at least Dickens and George Eliot haven't made an appearance yet -- or if they have, I've missed them!)
Susanna wrote: "Well, Tale of Two Cities would probably be OK (historical fiction even in Dickens' day)"True. A Tale of Two Cities I'd have left ... but that's about the only one by Dickens I can think of that would qualify.
Susanna wrote: "Barnaby Rudge is, I think, his only other historical novel."Ah yes, of course, true again ... :)
I have not read the novel (yet - I'm keeping some Dickens novels for my next insomnia bout), but the dog was sweet, stupid, and had a guilty conscience (he clicked his jaw when he wanted to confess, and would then lead us to the spot he wished to be chastised about).
That sounds very sweet (and naively innocent) indeed! Also very much like what my sister's dog Timmy would have done (who in turn was named for the dog in Enid Blyton's Famous Five series). And NOT at all what either of my cats would ever even have remotely considered doing (yours not either, I bet) ...
Sounds like a Turgenev dog. I'm reading Turgenev right now and his stories are filled with dogs who are smiling, or angry, or "smiling uneasily," etc.
No. There is actually one sketch where a poodle's owner is trying to teach it the ABC's, but the dog refuses to learn.
413 - contemporary 'vampires' fighting crime in upstate New York . . .how on earth has it made the list?
Donald wrote: "413 - contemporary 'vampires' fighting crime in upstate New York . . .how on earth has it made the list?"Which book are you referring to -- or did you delete the entry in question yourself already? As I'm looking at the list, none of the (several) books currently ranked #413 seem to match your description. What am I missing?
I just deleted. It was Dark Lover. Also got one set in Texas.Please do identify titles, though, along with a ranking - many books often share one ranking on a list.
424 - The Witches of Chiswick is really scifi/alternate history, not historical fiction413 was JR Ward Dark Lover - somebody else must have removed it
403 Dark Prince - contemporary US vampires again449 The Fate of Empire, 1776-2000 (A History of Britain, #3) - Pure History, not fiction
Also is the 1970s historical fiction? 424 Naked
418 The Punk Ethic - contemporary no idea if it's even set in UK
212 I Claudius is set in Ancient Rome surely?291 Dark Fever seems to be Urban Fantasy
245 Oliver Twist contemporary Dickens?
Related News
For devoted bookworms, the new year is an exciting time. Specifics on the year’s upcoming books start making the rounds, along with release...
Anyone can add books to this list.












