Which titles have you watched the movie because it either came out first, or you had no time to do both?
Are you intending to read the book?
Are you intending to read the book?
1406 likes · Like
Lists are re-scored approximately every 5 minutes.
Comments Showing 1-50 of 155 (155 new)
message 1:
by
Diana
(new)
Mar 08, 2010 07:13PM
I think I'd only be interested in reading Stardust and A Walk To Remember, I don't really like reading books just because the movie made it popular.
reply
|
flag
I've read a few books because the movie left me with questions. But mostly if I loved the movie I'll read the book. If I HATED the movie? I am so not reading the book.But once in a while, The movie makes me go "huh? that makes no sense? How'd they get there?" so I go read the book. And I sometimes like the book BETTER.
But mostly, If I LOVE the book, I avoid the movie at all costs (Percy Jackson for instance. LOVE the books. Heard the movie changed EVERTYHING and left huge, gaping holes in the storyline. WON'T be seeing that thing. EVER!!! Leave me my innocence!!!!!)
Susanna... you haven't read GWTW? The book is much better than the movie, really it is!
No, I've never read Gone with the Wind. It's on Mt. TBR, though.Have they actually made movies of all those Laurell K. Hamilton books? I wasn't aware of it.
Susanna wrote: "Have they actually made movies of all those Laurell K. Hamilton books? I wasn't aware of it."At one time they were planning to make a tv movie based on "Guilty Pleasures", but the plans fell through. I'm going to remove those from the list.
Unless the book is popular, a classic, or part of the canon...we don't know whether a film was a novel before. =D Sometimes a film spurs me on to read the novel which is usually children or young adult books like Harry Potter.
If I see the movie first, that's usually a death knell for the book, because if I really care about the book I'll make sure to read it first.
It is very rare that I'll read the book after I see the movie. There are a couple here and there that are in my TBR pile but it's very few. Most of these I had no idea were books first.
LOL I love this list !Honestly, I didn't know some of those movies were taken from books either :)
And I've got to admit, sometimes I just watched the movie because I was too lazy to read the book...but that happened _very_ long ago...
Well, now I guess I've got to mark some of them as 'to-read'
I usually have a "No watching the movie until I read the book first" policy, but I guess I broke the rule on a few of these...I didn't even realize some like Slumdog Millionaire and Chitty Chitty Bang Bang were books. And some books I didn't realize had movies too like The Invisible Man.
I prefer to read the book at first than see the movie. if i see the movie I will never read the book!
other than The Lord of The Rings, i don't think any movie has given justice to a good book.Am surprised A Beautiful Mind is taken from a book, that would be an interesting read to see how the writer would cover up for the plot, as the movie director did it in a very clever way, i tend to think it is difficult to do the same when writing. Am inticed to read the book now
I still cannot make the NEW AND IMPROVED listopia work. Before it was improved I had no problem but now I can only vote. I was just trying to add Because of Winn Dixie but no luck. Why is it new and improved never works for me.
Half Asleep
Half Asleep
Allegra wrote: "I usually have a "No watching the movie until I read the book first" policy, but I guess I broke the rule on a few of these...I didn't even realize some like Slumdog Millionaire and Chitty Chitty B..."
Same for me. So many movies I had no idea they were books first. Very rarely is the movie as good as the book but just lately I have found a few where the movie was better and was shocked.
Same for me. So many movies I had no idea they were books first. Very rarely is the movie as good as the book but just lately I have found a few where the movie was better and was shocked.
I loved a lot of the movies on this list. Half of them I had no idea had a book to it, namely Apollo 13, Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, and Angels & Demons. Angels & Demons is one of my favorite movies of all time. Its amazing. I especially did not expect Shutter Island to be a book. It was also very amazing, yet confusing. A lot of these books I've only read the book, not the movie, or the other way around, or both.
The thing is, I can't stop voting, hahaha. There are so many of these that I didn't know where books it's not even funny.
I only voted for the ones I have seen but hadn't read. That was alot. Most of which I have no intention what so ever of reading. Sad but true. :)
really good list. who would've thought that Catch me if you can, or the pursuit of happiness were books?! i think most movies that have a great or deep story behind them were originally books, other movies depend on other things rather than the story (well not all of them!) for instance i should have guessed that pay it forward was a book no other way could they have thought of that idea and just brought it to the screens.
I voted for Shrek because NOBODY seems to know that it was based off a picture book by William Steig.
I voted for the books that I have no intention of reading, but have seen the movies to go with them. They were all good movies too..
Diana wrote: "I think I'd only be interested in reading Stardust and A Walk To Remember, I don't really like reading books just because the movie made it popular."Stardust is a great read. :)
If it looks good i usually always read the book first, in very rare cases (nick & norah's infinite playlist and because of winn dixie) i have loved the movie so much that i read the book afterwards and both were great but its certainly a different reading experience... there were only 10 books on here whose movie i saw without ever reading the book, most of which i didnt even know were based on books, of course there are also on lot on this list where i havent read the book or seen the movie... and a few where ive only read the book
Red Riding Hood
I don't know if I will read the new book but I will sure buy the DVD when it comes out.
I don't know if I will read the new book but I will sure buy the DVD when it comes out.
If I get even a hint that the book is going to be made in to a movie I read the book immediately so that I can criticize the movie. Now seeing the list I realize I have watched a lot of movies without having even the slightest idea that they were books first. Sure I will read some of the books mentioned but that will be because the movie was too confusing.
i think the book is always better than the movie.It doesn't matter,if i watch the movie first or read it. But if i don't like the movie i won't bother reading it.
Lila wrote: "Diana wrote: "I think I'd only be interested in reading Stardust and A Walk To Remember, I don't really like reading books just because the movie made it popular."Stardust is a great read. :)"
I'm reading Stardust and then watching the movie to compare the two. It's really good so far. And good far me because I love fairy tale retellings.
For me, there's no point in reading the book after I watch the movie...Didn't realize that some of the movies I've watched were based on books!
Hollywood has always made movies out of books.I prefer it to their making movies of old TV series most of the time!
Wow! A Cool List! I just added The Last of the Mohicans (The best movie ever!) I'm surprised it's not in the list and The Scarlet Letter which I loved but have no desire to read.
Most times, if I really love a book, I won't go see the movie. I don't want to ruin my experiences with the book by having someone's interpretation of characters and plots running around in my head.
I'm glad to find this vote. And so far, I've voted 69 movies. I know that Some movies were originally from books, like Fantastic Mr. Fox, Harry Potter series, Time Traveler's Wife, etc, but I was shocked to know that Green Mile, December Boys, The Blind Side, empire of The Sun and some others are from books.U have some e-books for those movies, but it seems that I don't intend to read the books since I enjoyed the movies, like The Phantom of The Opera, Time Traveller's Wife, The Kite Runner, etc.
In God We Trust: All Others Pay Cash
What do you do when the movie has a totally different name? The movie is: A Christmas Story and it is super funny. I need to read the book.
What do you do when the movie has a totally different name? The movie is: A Christmas Story and it is super funny. I need to read the book.
I feel so ashamed. I've only read a few of these, yet I've seen 49 of these film adaptations. I didn't even realize that some of them were based on books.
Same for me Kitty. There are so many movies I have seen and I get the book later when I find out there is one. In a few cases I much preferred the movie! Like The English Patient and Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe.
Kitty wrote: "I feel so ashamed. I've only read a few of these, yet I've seen 49 of these film adaptations. I didn't even realize that some of them were based on books."
Kitty wrote: "I feel so ashamed. I've only read a few of these, yet I've seen 49 of these film adaptations. I didn't even realize that some of them were based on books."
Anita wrote: "I've read a few books because the movie left me with questions. But mostly if I loved the movie I'll read the book. If I HATED the movie? I am so not reading the book.But once in a while, The m..."
The movie wasn't that bad, they changed Annabeth a bit and left some of the minor exploring out
dontouchmychocolate wrote: "No point in reading the book after I watched the movie...Didn't realize that some of the movies I've watched were based on books! Hollywood running out of ideas?"I disagree. There are a lot of movie adaptations (I, Robot, War of the Worlds, Ella Enchanted, Stuart Little, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, The Three Musketeers, Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs, Breakfast at Tiffany's, Dracula, etc.) that actually have very little in common with the books on which they are supposedly based. In my opinion, it's usually worth reading the book even if you saw the movie first. I like to compare the two and analyze the changes made in film adaptations.
I agree with you Kayleigh! Books are usually far more interesting and have great details that you never get in a movie. Some of them bear little resemblance to each other.



















