The Amazon books editors got together and chose 100 Biographies & Memoirs to Read in a Lifetime. We want to know what books you would choose. Add titles below, and vote on the titles added by fellow readers.
See all of our picks at www.amazon.com/100biographies.
See all of our picks at www.amazon.com/100biographies.
Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Michelle
(new)
Mar 02, 2015 06:19PM
Too many books on this list are not biographies or memoirs. The Catcher in the Rye is a lovely book but it's fiction. Likewise The Great Gatsby. The Bible is not a memoir or a biography.
reply
|
flag
Michelle wrote: "Too many books on this list are not biographies or memoirs. The Catcher in the Rye is a lovely book but it's fiction. Likewise The Great Gatsby. The Bible is not a memoir or a biography."I agree, so I have removed all five books (three different versions of the Bible were on the list).
I'm not sure The Bell Jar (#10) qualifies either, as I always thought is was a novel (and Sylvia Platt's only one, as far as I know). Anyone?
I suppose Bill Bryson's In a Sunburned Country (#89) could be seen as a memoir, although to me it is more of a travel story than an actual memoir/biography.I've read The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini and that's not a biography but a novel (can't even be a memoir or a biography, as the author left Afghanistan as a toddler...), so I've removed the book.
Peter Carey's True History of the Kelly Gang is also fiction, so again, I've removed the book. (Don't be misled by the book's title!)
I've also removed To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, as it is a novel (it received the Pulitzer Prize for fiction !!). The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck also won the Pulitzer Prize for fiction, so that's another one I've removed.
People, please, don't just add books because you think they might be a biography or a memoir, but make absolutely sure before you add! If you have even the slightest doubt, don't add...
Booklovinglady wrote: "Michelle wrote: "Too many books on this list are not biographies or memoirs. The Catcher in the Rye is a lovely book but it's fiction. Likewise The Great Gatsby. The Bible is not a memoir or a biog..."Yes, The Bell Jar is a novel. So is The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pitman. I found so many novels on this list that I gave up.
Yes The Bell Jar is a novel. So is The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman. I came across so many novels on this list that I gave up.
The Laura Ingalls Wilder series is fiction. The Souls of Black Folk is an essay collection, not a memoir or biography.
104 Number Theory Problems. I think this list needs restart but perhaps it will end up just as irrelevant the second time around.
Parting the Waters: Martin Luther King etc is a 3-volume HISTORY of the Civil Rights Movement. Come on-- can't anyone come up with some actual biographies of darker-skinned people?
Ruth wrote: "Parting the Waters: Martin Luther King etc is a 3-volume HISTORY of the Civil Rights Movement. Come on-- can't anyone come up with some actual biographies of darker-skinned people?"Ruth, please don't be upset at others--just add it!(That is, if it is bio and not more a history of a movement. I've never read it at all). I already had 13 black bios on my own list of 38, so without scrolling the whole list it seems like you're being a bit hyperbolic. Again, please add valuable bios.
Ruth wrote: "Also, some of the biographies are known for being contrived, such as Sybil."Absolutely! That is my dilemma with some of them. I maintain that some people's autobiographies/bios are more fiction than other people's historical fiction.
I deleted the Little House set as per its Goodreads classification. I also deleted The Souls of Black Folk. There is a bio of W.E.B. Du Bois on the list. (My edition of The Souls of B F began with a powerful account of Du Bois's early adulthood)(and feel free to add other Du Bois bios).
All quibbling about a few mis-added books aside, I thoroughly enjoyed this list. Happy reading to all! I am excited to read some of these.
Removed The Bell Jar, The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman, and The Sun Also Rises for being fiction.
I did finally get through the list and found some to add that I hope will be appreciated. All in all, I think the list is good. Thanks for taking off the more obvious fictions... This is all in good fun.
Removed for being fiction: Little House in the Big Woods; Little House on the Prairie; The Long Winter. The same applies to any others in this series that anyone might contemplate adding: historical fiction, not memoir.The system found and deleted 3 duplicates also.
Booklovinglady wrote: "Michelle wrote: "Too many books on this list are not biographies or memoirs. The Catcher in the Rye is a lovely book but it's fiction. Likewise The Great Gatsby. The Bible is not a memoir or a biog..."I just looked at the list today and these books are still on the list. Maybe someone put them back on?
At least some are still there. Memoirs and biographies are NOT FICTION, i.e., not novels nor short stories nor essays.
Peg wrote: "Please remove Eragon as well, it's ficton."Which number? (There are 13 pages at the moment, which is bit much to search for a book...)
BookLovingLady wrote: "Michelle wrote: "Too many books on this list are not biographies or memoirs. The Catcher in the Rye is a lovely book but it's fiction. Likewise The Great Gatsby. The Bible is not a memoir or a biog..."Plath
Interesting. What is biography? I think of biography as being about a person, so the fact that Seabiscuit: An American Legend is in the top 20 (beating out a lot of really famous people I should add) is a bit astonishing to me. The Biography of A Grizzly also makes an appearance later in the list, a book I read and enjoyed. I supposed that particularly in these times life stories of animals (which meet the literal etymological meaning of biography) are going to be popular.
Some years back I deleted The Souls of Black Folk due to complaints that it didn't belong. I see 6 people added it back, so I re-added my vote. Some editions have great biographical intros, others perhaps not so.
I do not see how The Sunflower: On the Possibilities and Limits of Forgiveness qualifies, as it is a collection of short essays looking at forgiveness from philosophical, theological, and personal perspectives. Of the books in the top of the list this one is the one I most lean towards deleting.
I also appreciate the book Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee: An Indian History of the American West, and its power is that Dee Brown builds his narrative around biographical development. But I didn't vote for it because, while it contains biographical sketches of several dozen people, I don't see it as biography per se. It definitely has interest for those looking for biographical writing though and I can understand leaving it.
Overall though this is a great list which takes into account biographies across many centuries and cultures. Happy reading!
Related News
As you might expect, we are book people here at Goodreads World Headquarters—rather intense book people, actually. And when the holidays roll...
Anyone can add books to this list.












