Add or vote for novels or short story collections that you would like to see make the Tournament of Books for 2016. Books you add or vote for should ideally be books that you've read and loved yourself, rather than your predictions for what will actually make the long list in January 2016, or books you've heard good things about but haven't yet read. Eligible books are fiction published in English (translations ok) from November 2014 to December 2015.
283 books ·
1,364 voters ·
list created July 24th, 2015
by ♑︎♑︎♑︎ ♑︎♑︎♑︎.
Comments Showing 1-50 of 72 (72 new)
message 1:
by
Michele
(new)
Jul 24, 2015 06:00PM
Thanks for making this list Poingu!
reply
|
flag
it's a little early for such a thing but otoh it felt good to get the first-half-the-year reads up there, before the second-half juggernauts hit. I love hearing other people's best-of-2015 thoughts. I never would have found a lot of these books on my own.
This is great. I'm adding some of the "literary pop star" books. Sorry Poingu :). I'm also adding "Where Did you Sleep Last Night for some balance.
Sherri wrote: "This is great. I'm adding some of the "literary pop star" books. Sorry Poingu :). "Ha! There are actually two books on this list now that were painful 1-star reads for me, but there is something very cool about the way we can get one another to appreciate aspects of a given novel that we didn't appreciate on our own.
Some of us will always love it and some of us will always hate it. I hated Station Eleven, for instance. Yikes, don't throw tomatoes. But I just couldn't take it. And I know I am in a severe minority.
Poingu wrote: "it's a little early for such a thing but otoh it felt good to get the first-half-the-year reads up there ..."i don't think it's too early either. maybe helps keep it a bit more manageable as get further into the second half of the year. :)
Michele wrote: "Some of us will always love it and some of us will always hate it. I hated Station Eleven, for instance. Yikes, don't throw tomatoes. But I just couldn't take it. And I know I am in a severe minority."michele -- while i didn't hate Station Eleven, i didn't love it the way so many others have. so you aren't totally alone! :)
Adding 'Go Set a Watchman' -- which I was pleasantly surprised with (caveat: liked, not loved 'Mockingbird' even with a recent re-read). Definitely think 'Watchman' would make an interesting discussion + all of its baggage + it will make folks' heads explode that it's on the list (a la Elizabeth Gilbert) -- so like its chances to make ToB.
Intriguing list! All the Light We Cannot See should be taken off the list, though--it came in second in the tournament last year. (Station 11 was #1, I think?)
Liz wrote: "Intriguing list! All the Light We Cannot See should be taken off the list, though--it came in second in the tournament last year. (Station 11 was #1, I think?)"ah, interesting someone would add that one to this list. i have removed the book as it is not a contender for the 2016 ToB. thanks for catching that, liz. :)
So I'm having trouble finding the need to pick up A Little Life though so many people say it is great. What would you say is mostly contained in that giant book (ie: the five main things)? And does it only take place in NYC?
I am adding The Tusk That Did the Damage, Us Conductors, and The Animals. So far, they are my favorite reads of the year, and they each would make for great discussions.
I love how long this "best" list has become! We can't read or know about everything and it's great to have all these recommendations now.
Jennifer wrote: "Liz wrote: "Intriguing list! All the Light We Cannot See should be taken off the list, though--it came in second in the tournament last year. (Station 11 was #1, I think?)"ah, interesting someone..."
Jennifer, can you edit the "Goodreads 2016" list to remove "All the Light We Cannot See" again? (I don't have that editing power). Interesting to see its staying power, even though it isn't eligible for 2016...maybe it should have won 2015 instead of being the mere runner-up.
Poingu wrote: "Jennifer wrote: "Liz wrote: "Intriguing list! All the Light We Cannot See should be taken off the list, though--it came in second in the tournament last year. (Station 11 was #1, I think?)"ah, in..."
I did it.
heh -- thanks, michele! :)isn't it funny how someone (someones?) really want it to be on the 2016 list.
i think a lot of books get put onto all possible lists without the adder even knowing what the list is about.and then there are voting campaigns. looks like we have one here at #2. I don't think our Rooster groups have discussed that book.
i recognize none of the 17 voters for that #2 book. (not that that means anything since, somehow, i didn't even notice the book until you mentioned it. i have no idea how i managed that awesome attention. ha!) :/
just noticed 'orphan train' on the list, #13... it came out a couple of years ago..
yeah... i'm going to remove 'orphan train'. took a moment to double-check publishing dates, and it's definitely 2013.
Thank you Jennifer and Michele! Wow. Voting campaigns. I hadn't thought of that. It makes sense that people would try but otoh on Goodreads you do risk raising the wrath of the community for the smallest turn in the direction of self-promotion.
I run a listopia list of books by women sci-fi authors and I regularly deal with voting campaigns putting completely unknown books up at the top of the list with ursula le guin. Mostly what I've seen happen is that self-published authors form organizations and then go run voting campaigns for each other on lists and on the book's homepage.I wish they would spend their energy on becoming better writers instead of gaming the system.
Michele wrote: "I run a listopia list of books by women sci-fi authors and I regularly deal with voting campaigns putting completely unknown books up at the top of the list with ursula le guin. Mostly what I've se..."I wish goodreads would add the capability of editing - like letting others invite friends to a party. Sometimes a list is just that... a specific list. Make a button that gives the creator of the list the option of selecting - open voting or not.
Poingu wrote: "Thank you Jennifer and Michele! Wow. Voting campaigns. I hadn't thought of that. It makes sense that people would try but otoh on Goodreads you do risk raising the wrath of the community ..."
no problem at all, poingu!! it hadn't occurred to me that that weird behaviour would go on on this list, but i have seen it elsewhere. or instances where a book is just put on ALL lists, whether it fits or not. it does annoy a lot of people, but luckily librarians can clean these sorts of things up. (shame to create 'make work' situations though. heh!)
yeah -- there are definitely improvements that would be nice to see in the listopia department. not sure how high on the priority list listopia is for the GR powers that be, however.
So how do you librarians decide whether something like the novel A Small Indiscretion is a campaign or a legitimate outpouring of love for that book?I think I would abuse my power and think, man, this book I gave 1 star to, how did that ever get 22 votes...that looks suspicious! (just kidding) (mostly)
Poingu wrote: "So how do you librarians decide whether something like the novel A Small Indiscretion is a campaign or a legitimate outpouring of love for that book?..."ha! i only tend to removed very obvious misfits -- like if the list is about nonfiction something or other, and someone's slipped in their/a novel, it's in the wrong place.
i've left 'small indiscretion' alone, because (after attention was drawn to it) i really didn't know if it had come up in any ToB chatting. (i have a dodgy memory at times!) i did notice amber, i think, has it on one of her shelves... so i thought it was possible it had come up in the group.
but if you feel it shouldn't be here... i am sure we could help it along on its way. :)
I don't know anything about this novel, good or bad, but I think I would not mind you removing it because I see that more than a few of the votes for this novel are from people with 0 to 1 books in Goodreads, and/or have 0 to 1 friends, and also because when I search for it it seems that no one in the Goodreads TOB group has mentioned it.
At some point I guess i'll try to go through the long tail and do some housekeeping too. For instance Blackout: Remembering the Things I Drank to Forget doesn't appear to be fiction. But I am fascinated with that long tail, and fascinated by how this list has 65 different books chosen by 100 readers, so far. That's a lot of different opinions.
Poingu wrote: "I don't know anything about this novel, good or bad, but I think I would not mind you removing it because I see that more than a few of the votes for this novel are from people with 0 to 1 books in..."yes, that is a telling sign, the # of books. i'll remove it!
i'll remove 'blackout' too - since nonfiction doesn't work for ToB.when you have a chance to get to the housekeeping, just post any others you think don't belong here, and we can get them deleted. i can take a closer look too and ask about any books i am not sure about her in the comments. :)
one i am curious about, that did stand out to me: #61, Broken Promise. barclay's a canadian writer, popular, but not ToB-type stuff at all.
# 62 - The Lie Tree is shelved a bit as a middle grade book. when YA gets in, it's usually older stuff, yes?
#50 - Mr Mac and Me came out in (sept) 2014. unless it was different in the US (i feel like it wasn't though.)#31 - The Weight of Blood - also 2014 (march)?
Jennifer wrote: "#50 - Mr Mac and Me came out in (sept) 2014. unless it was different in the US (i feel like it wasn't though.)#31 - The Weight of Blood - also 2014 (march)?"
Jennifer all of your suggestions sound like good books to edit out. Sorry to be making you housekeeper though.
Hi. I'm a silent follower of ToB and hope no one minds that I added Our Souls at Night, Black River, and The Secret Wisdom of the Earth to the list. They are among my favorite books of the year so far, along with A Little Life.
Thank you so much for adding these, Ryan! I've been meaning to read Our Souls at Night and the others look great too.
Can I put in a request for The Lie Tree to be added back, on the grounds that it's shelved twice as much in Young Adult than in Middle Grade (and that since it's a super low sample data anyway?), and I would classify it as definitely Young Adult. (Also, I think I was the only one who voted for it, so this is less of a request and more of a "If I add this back, would it be so bad?") I did add it because I think it's a complex and literary read (and far more literary if far less popular than other previous TOB YA picks). (And I have no illusions about it actually making the TOB longlist, but I think it'd be a good book for the tournament.)
Megan wrote: "Can I put in a request for The Lie Tree to be added back, on the grounds that it's shelved twice as much in Young Adult than in Middle Grade (and that since it's a super low sample ..."The best reason I can think of to keep a book on this list is that someone genuinely loves it. Librarians?
Also: One of my favorite books of the year, Fifteen Dogs, probably has a reading score of around 8th grade. Books don't need to be long or complicated or NSFW to be profound.
Poingu wrote: "The best reason I can think of to keep a book on this list is that someone genuinely loves it. Librarians? "totally valid!
Thanks! I totally didn't mean to sound ungrateful for active pruning and oversight--just wanted to defend a book I loved and felt was TOB-y.And I probably should have said in my earlier comment, but thanks to everyone who's been curating this list. I've enjoyed watching its evolution, and I'm looking forward to see how it differs from the official lists in (oh gosh) a couple months.











