Listopia > Michaela's votes on the list The Book Was Better Than the Movie (6 Books)
| 1 |
|
Ella Enchanted (Ella Enchanted, #1)
by
"Because that Movie was STUPID!! and Ella Enchanted is a WONDERFUL book!!"
Michaela
rated it 5 stars
See Review |
|
| 2 |
|
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (Harry Potter, #4)
by
"They ruined the challenges (the dragon scene went on WAY too long), the Ball, which they made a Prom, and Dumbledor! You can't make Albus YELL!! What's WRONG with these people!?!?"
|
|
| 3 |
|
Pride and Prejudice
by
"The Five-hour-version was about as close as you could get, but the 2 hour? How could they possibly have Kira Knightly play Lizzy? And Mr Darcey was Ugly! He had a big nose. plus everything was too fast: nothing made sense unless you had seen the five-hour. Plus, Mr. Collins wasn't creepy and greasy enough."
|
|
| 4 |
|
Howl’s Moving Castle (Howl’s Moving Castle, #1)
by
"I will say that I liked the movie on its own. But Miazaki, of whom I am a tremendous fan, completely changed the plot, (for goodness' SAKES, he changed the villian). For those who haven't yet read the book, Howl is NOT a Demon. However, they got Calcipher pretty spot-on. But Micheal is supposed 16-17, not a little kid! This movie just was weird, though it was one of Miazaki's more normal ones. Because Howl was Howl, but he wasn't. There were something Howl would DEFINITELY do, and others he wouldn't have. And he wasn't a big enough jerk. And he wasn't funny enough! they mixed up the thing with the dog and the scarecrow. And where Howl came from... it just was not the same story. But I still liked the movie because it was a Miazaki film."
Michaela
rated it 5 stars
See Review |
|
| 5 |
|
Prince Caspian (Chronicles of Narnia, #2)
by
"See, the movie was pretty good. And Reepicheep was very good (even though he's supposed tp be dark grey, not cream). IDK, but the movies both had a different feel than the books. They weren't as straight forward as the books but yet I still felt like ti was Narnia, in of itself, and the director is getting Aslan almost perfect: only once or twice I disagreed with what Aslan would or wouldn't do, but hey, it's the director's interpretation, not mine. Caspian, I didn't feel, had the personality that Caspian did in the books. He wasn't cheery enough. And some things pertaining to the plot and the order of how things happened was a little screwy, but It wasn't too bad. I still think they did better with The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe."
|
|
| 6 |
|
The Princess Bride
by
"I will just say that they came out with the movie first."
|
|
