4.39 avg rating — 590,399 ratings

"I haven't finished this book (I know, shame on me), but from what I read and the effect of this book earns it 1st place "

4.26 avg rating — 197,103 ratings

"This was an amazing book! Its dark, gritty, solid and somewhat weird. What more do you want in a batman comic?! This book is also in a high place because of the legacy it left behind. It got batman out of a dark ( ahem, 60's) place."

4.36 avg rating — 234,341 ratings

"This was one of the best batman stories of all time. One of the most disturbing and emotional of all. It's short, which is a good and bad thing. Still really amazing."

4.25 avg rating — 273,067 ratings

4.25 avg rating — 271,337 ratings

"Noir and timeless quality, I only wish it gave batman MORE of a spotlight. Solid and accessible, definitely a classic. "

4.15 avg rating — 78,979 ratings

"GO HELLBOY!"

4.26 avg rating — 67,327 ratings

"A jaw-dropping amazing rendering of an argument of the moral existence of superheroes and the genre. "

4.17 avg rating — 61,219 ratings

"Good what if story."

4.11 avg rating — 45,645 ratings

"Two words: Emotional Maturity"

4.34 avg rating — 109,981 ratings