Manda asked Nikki Chartier:

I’m confused in the order of the American Girl On Saturn. Which book comes first? American Girl On Saturn OR American girl versus Saturn??!!

Nikki Chartier It doesn't matter. You can read either first. AGOS was written/published first. It's from Chloe's point of view about her family's lockdown experience with a boy band. AGVS is written from her sister Aralie's point of view about *her* experience. There's some crossover between both books, as they're set in the same event, but you only get one side per book. The other book fills in the gaps of what *that* sister was doing behind the scenes.

flag