Robert Dixon-Kolar asked Keith Taylor:

Hi, Keith - I'm curious about your thoughts on book reviewing (a genre I've begun to take pleasure in writing.) You write many thoughtful, extended reviews--just as Sven Birkerts, your bookstore associate from years back--so often does. What does the activity of reviewing a book offer you personally? What do you hope it offers to readers of your reviews? Thanks!

Keith Taylor Robert - Just the other day I realized that I published my first book review over 40 years ago. That kind of amazed me. Books have always been the center of my life, and stopping to think about them forces me to become more articulate about my responses to them. And, of course, I also try to write books, and knowing what has moved me in someone else's work can help with my own. I also continue to believe that books are important, so if I can interest a person or two in the discussion, then it is worth it. Also, I'm getting older now, and forcing myself to read new books by younger people keeps me fresh, forces me to keep thinking in new ways.

You will have noticed that I seldom give bad reviews. Maybe sometimes they are mixed, but very seldom pans. If I don't like a book, I won't finish it, let alone review it. The only time I'll do that is when someone well known writes a book that I think is bad (often sloppy) and that I have been asked and paid to review. Then I'll say something negative.

But I'm not quite sure what this might mean for someone who reads the review. Probably I'm hoping that if you read my review you will realize that someone took this author's process seriously and that maybe reading that book might help you do it too. That seems worth it!

Thanks for asking. Here's a link to a short essay I wrote about reviewing a few years back for "Fiction Writers Review"

https://fictionwritersreview.com/essa...

flag