Taken at Dusk discussion

okay, i was just wondering what you guys thought of Red. we all know that he was pretty creepy in the begaing with he was watching kylia trying on bra's blah blah. but put that aside. and what do you think his over all persaltey was like? evil like his grandfather? might actally have cared about her? seeing as we know he got killed trying to protcet her.

I think he was a good person that was raised wrong.

Daniel wrote: "I think he was a good person that was raised wrong."

Agree :)

he was a really good person his grandfather tried to make him a bad person but in roberto's heart he is a great person

I think he would have been an important person if his evil grandfather didn't corrupt his naive mind, but at least he did the right thing in the end by saving Kylie.

yeah i agree with you ailleen. i actally cryed the frist time i read it and saw that he died. i know doesnt make much snese. but yeah. i was actally kinda hoping after i found out he was trying to protcet her that he'd ditch his crazy grandfather. and maybe go to the camp and sing on or somthing

I dont think he deserved to die. Not the way he died. I liked him ok. He still was a good guy even after having a grandfather like that.

i know he was bad and all but i really liked him. it broke my heart a little when he died! ya'll said it, he was a good guy raised wrong. his intentions were good although they came off creepy and bad he really thought he was doing the right thing because he loved her. I mean he died saving her. he protected kylie and he could have given her some anwsers about who she is. R.I.P. Red we miss you

I cried too, I felt so bad for him. If he didn't grow up around so much evil he would have been a good person.

At first i didn't like him because i thought he was going to kill Kylie but then i realised that he was the good guy, god i miss that vamp...

he was an amazing bad guy, when he killed the girls for poking fun at kaylie he did it with the intents to impress her, over all he actually did care about her as a person (or as a supernatural)

He could have been in the race for Kylie's heart if he turned good and stayed alive longer.

Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' wrote: "okay, i was just wondering what you guys thought of Red. we all know that he was pretty creepy in the begaing with he was watching kylia trying on bra's blah blah. but put that aside. and what ..."

Oh my god, the story of Red made me cry (once I realized he wasn't some evil stalker trying to force her to marry him). There's this one quote that still bring me to tears "a boy raised into evil, taught evil, and never loved" *crying* but his story (along with the x men series) has taught me never judge a villain, now I always wonder what has the villain gone through and is he really a villain