Reader's Ink discussion

2. What does Luncheon of the Boating Party suggest about finding oneself in life and in love? Is there something unique about the way an artist finds his or her way? With the two women that were in his life and proved to be his love interests (Alphonsine & Aline), what was your take on them?

I don't know that I'd call it unique, but Renoir's quest for love seemed--to me--indulgent and childish. He covered for his immaturity by claiming to need his precious muses for his art. I dunno. I just didn't buy it. The idea that you can't create true art without being a Parisian cliche who uses women while they're interesting and beautiful to you seemed hum-drum and predictable to me.

Ashley, I think I mostly agree with you on the immaturity of Renoir in his love interests and pursuits. I found myself engaged with the two women, whom I really grew to like, one for her wisdom and experience, and the other for her naievity and passion.