The Lost Prince (The Iron Fey: Call of the Forgotten, #1) The Lost Prince discussion


177 views
Team Ethan OR Team Keirran???

Comments Showing 1-45 of 45 (45 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sarah (last edited Nov 22, 2012 05:10PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sarah It's SO hard to pick between these 2 AMAZING characters, who do you pick?


Leilani Team Ethan, duh. not that hard :P


message 3: by Bre (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bre I like Keirrans' personality, he acts like Ash and Puck combined,I love that:)What Keirran did was kinda idiotic, i'm not gonna lie


Leilani agreed.


Caralin I love both of them. Agree with you Bre, Keirran's actions were kinda dumb. I think he is gonna end up the traitor prince in the next book. I love ETHAN! He is just like Ash. Think about it. Ash's background was: fell inlove with a girl a long time ago and something bad happened to her. Because of that he sealed all of his emotions making him someone you avoid, and sealing off his heart. (Ice Prince Personalitly) then a girl comes around that breaks all of the walls he enclosed his heart with and loves her.
Ring a bell??? thats what happened with Ethan.


Cali I found Keirran kind of... flat... He wasn't what I was expecting. Ethan on the other hand was full of life. Eh that's just my opinion. So I guess I'd say Team Ethan (isn't he so cute with Kenzie?) :)


Isabella (All Da Ladies Luv Leo) Thomas Caralin wrote: "I love both of them. Agree with you Bre, Keirran's actions were kinda dumb. I think he is gonna end up the traitor prince in the next book. I love ETHAN! He is just like Ash. Think about it. Ash's ..."

Actually that I didn't like becouse it's like trying to make another book but you;re out of ideas and insted post the same story as the book before.


Isabella (All Da Ladies Luv Leo) Thomas Keirran flat out annoys me. I never really liked his personality.... since the Iron Knight.


Leilani ikr????!!!!!! thought who would've been amazing. don't get me wrong, he is a great guy with a big heart trying to help the Forgotten but it was kind of idiotic.
miss puck though, he only showed up twice in the lost prince :(


message 11: by Amy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Amy Lopez Well I guess cuz it was from Ethan's perspective that I prefer him much more but maybe Julie Kagawa should write one from Kierran's perspective? Actually I hope she writes another book from Puck's point of view!


message 12: by Amy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Amy Lopez Caralin wrote: "I love both of them. Agree with you Bre, Keirran's actions were kinda dumb. I think he is gonna end up the traitor prince in the next book. I love ETHAN! He is just like Ash. Think about it. Ash's ..."

Seriously! I think Kierran's going to end up ruining everything! :/ He seems childish enough to end up working alongside you know who. Haha wow I couldn't have said it better on Puck's and Ethan's similarities ;)


message 13: by Nila (new) - rated it 3 stars

Nila They were both kinda... boring. I loved that Kierran had the power of all three courts and that he acted just like ash in protecting annwyl and everything but both of them kind of didn't have that strong a personality. but i liked kierran better cause i felt like i knew him better he wasn't always either hating the fey or hating himself for putting everything in danger.


Leilani Amy wrote: "Well I guess cuz it was from Ethan's perspective that I prefer him much more but maybe Julie Kagawa should write one from Kierran's perspective? Actually I hope she writes another book from Puck's ..."

YEEEESSSSSS!!!!! that would be amazing!


message 15: by Caitlin (new) - added it

Caitlin Douglas I never knew thee were sides you know it will be a happy ending. I couldn;t pick a side honestly because I haven't seen the characters developed yet this book didn't show any chracter progression like her Iron Fey series the two main charcters were very one minded and sided in this one. Hope it gets better.
Peace to the Maker


message 16: by Caitlin (new) - added it

Caitlin Douglas Ponnila3398 wrote: "They were both kinda... boring. I loved that Kierran had the power of all three courts and that he acted just like ash in protecting annwyl and everything but both of them kind of didn't have that ..."

I completely agree with you.
nice opinion.

Peace to the Maker


Reyhaneh I'm Team Ethan because I think Kierran is a little stupid but I still loved the book. Julia Kagawa can do no wrong in my eyes and I know the book series will end up amaizing.


message 18: by Home (new) - rated it 5 stars

Home Ice-bloxx First I didn't like Ethan (got better, but.. hum.) ... but I loved Keirran at first sight!! Could be because I love his dad so much, but he's awesome <3 But they're both irresistible <3


Ariel Team Ethan, what Kierran did was kinda stupid. But, I love Kierran's name. But, really what I am most disappointed was the book. I was expecting something really amazing, a new adventure. I read all the Iron Fey books, but after I was done reading the book, I was like. Ok, ghost fey. Just like the Iron Fey. Boop! Ethan is probably become the King of the ghost fey thingies. Or whatever they're called. The book just didn't hit the soft spot for me.


chillygarlic Team Ethan because I like(not love) him and Kierran is flat out dumb.


Jordi Bre wrote: "I like Keirrans' personality, he acts like Ash and Puck combined,I love that:)What Keirran did was kinda idiotic, i'm not gonna lie"

hahaha, Yes... I noticed that aswell, I fell in love with him the instant read it


Jordi ^^I meant the way he acted and i agree what he did was completely idiotic


Jordi But I dont know who i would choose out of Ethan and Kerrian... I love them both <3


Ariel Ethan. <3


Nansea Ethan, he is so sweet! (But underneath that badboy exterior that makes him so intriguing, like ash)


message 26: by Luna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Luna Well I really don't know, I like Ethan( besides How annoying how he gets hurt all the time, I swear I wanted to scream "STOP BLEEDING" , Kierran I don't know I haven't read Iron Legends so..


Lindsay Team Ethan. I like Kenzie and enjoy seeing her and Ethan. Kerrian is just a repeat of Ash except that a lot more hangs on his shoulders than Ash. While I liked him because he helped Ethan he is only ok.


onceuponadreamer (nav) team ethan, foever and always!


Julia Griffis - The Romance Bibliophile This is a tough one because both characters possess striking qualities, however, I am Team Ethan.


message 30: by Azhu (new) - rated it 4 stars

Azhu Herondale I love them both... Its hard to pick between Ethan and Keirran..
can I pick sh instead? :)


message 31: by Angela ♥ Mrs. Hollywood ♥ (last edited May 28, 2013 06:09PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Angela  ♥ Mrs. Hollywood ♥ Home wrote: "First I didn't like Ethan (got better, but.. hum.) ... but I loved Keirran at first sight!! Could be because I love his dad so much, but he's awesome <3 But they're both irresistible <3"

Keirran, for the same reasons!


Melanie Although i dont like picking sides for characters i have to say i love Ethan. He is so strong and super awesome and after all the obstacles he over came them. He is such a strong character.


Chisom Ugh neither! Ethan seemed confused while Kierran is about to do something very stupid in the next book. I'm still very much Team Ash even though this has nothing to do with him.


Ishika If I had to choose. Team Ethan. Maybe cuz the book is centered around him. I dunno but there is just something that is really sweet and magnetic about him.
GUYS THE IRON TRAITOR COMES OUT IN 5 DAYS... WHO ELSE IS EXCITED?


message 35: by Addee (last edited Oct 24, 2013 01:47PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Addee Are you serious?

KIERRAN! Any offspring of Ash is going to be my favourite everyday. I was surprised there were so many votes for Ethan, he was ok but I had almost forgotten who he was. I must admit sadly that I am undeniably and hopelessly infatuated with Ash, so I usually only remember what happens around him.

Yes can't wait for THE IRON TRAITOR.....I LOVE THE COVER...


Angela  ♥ Mrs. Hollywood ♥ Smeghead wrote: "Are you serious?

KIERRAN! Any offspring of Ash is going to be my favourite everyday. I was surprised there were so many votes for Ethan, he was ok but I had almost forgotten who he was. I must adm..."


I agree with you Smeghead!!!


FaeryMeganChase Ethan, Keirran doesn't know when to give up in the second book. :P


Malanala Team Ethan!


message 39: by Quizzes (new)

Quizzes Team Ethan!


Alondra Team Ethan, for sure!


Muse-ic ♬ Ethan. Kierran was completely selfish. I get he really wanted to save his girlfriend which is an important motivator, but to destroy the entire Nevernever for her is really pushing it.


Josie Team Ethan! People who say team Kierran just wait till you read the ending of iron traitor.


Jordan I'm Team Ethan but, I do like Kierran because he reminds me of Ash and Puck.


Anoeska Nossol Team Kierran just because I like him more even when he is a little selfish and not that great towards his girlfriend or whatever she is to him. Guess they were in some sort of forbidden love.


Daring I am so far down the rabbit hole of Team Ash that I can't see the light of day anymore. So... I'm probably going to say neither. If I have to choose one, it'd be Ethan. Though I find him broody and irritating, Kierran is way too immature for me. I understand he's hopelessly in love, but his mother was willing to give up love for the good of a kingdom, so I think he should have learned a thing or two about sacrifice.


back to top