The Iron Knight (The Iron Fey, #4) The Iron Knight discussion


213 views
Should there be a book for Puck?

Comments Showing 1-50 of 63 (63 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Kassyreadsalot (new)

Kassyreadsalot I think there should be I mean she made one for Ash. I think Puck deserves a happy ending.If only Julie Kagawa would write one.Doesn't anyone else agree?


message 2: by [deleted user] (last edited Jan 22, 2013 12:50AM) (new)

I KNOW RIGHT OMGGG!!!!! SHE SHOULD DEFINITELY WRITE A BOOK ON PUCKS ADVENTURES!!! I actually emailed her about it but she never answered my email. ;(


Hilary Garza Isn't Puck in The Lost Prince? I haven't read that yet but I thought I heard Puck was supposed to be in that.


message 4: by Kassyreadsalot (new)

Kassyreadsalot The lost prince is mainly about Megan younger brother b puck is in it but not the main character


message 5: by Bre (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bre YESSS puck needs his own book; I enjoyed summers crossing which was from his point of view


Karah Sommer Hilary wrote: "Isn't Puck in The Lost Prince? I haven't read that yet but I thought I heard Puck was supposed to be in that."

I read that book, Puck is only in like 2 scenes. That's probably why the book wasn't that amazing. ;P lol


Karah Sommer I think that Julie Kagawa should make a book about Puck and have him fall in love with some other half human half summer fairy. That would be awesome right? :D Or.... heck just have him fall in love with someone! Lol It could be interesting if he fell in love with a winter fairy. :D


Lizbeth I would love a prequel book on Puck before Megan was sucked into the Nevernever. And it would have to be from Puck's POV so it could be even better.


❀ Crystal ✿ -  PEACE ☮ LOVE ♥ BOOKS Puck definitely deserves his own book, especially after he lets Meghan go. Where's his Happily Ever After...


message 10: by Home (new) - rated it 5 stars

Home Ice-bloxx Hilary wrote: "Isn't Puck in The Lost Prince? I haven't read that yet but I thought I heard Puck was supposed to be in that."

I think it's Ethan in The Lost Prince :)


Nurlely Home wrote: "Hilary wrote: "Isn't Puck in The Lost Prince? I haven't read that yet but I thought I heard Puck was supposed to be in that."

I think it's Ethan in The Lost Prince :)"


Ethan is the main character in The Lost Prince, but Puck is in the book too, although just a bit...


Marina Who do you like better, Ash or Puck? I honestly can't decide!


Nurlely I love Ash and like Puck :)


Reyhaneh There is a novelle from Puck's perspective but I do want a book were Puck gets a happy ending. I liked Puck's character better than Ash. Don't get me wrong Ash and Megan yaaa... but Puck's personality and character was great and I felt sorry for Puck way more than I felt sorry for Ash.


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

Hilary wrote: "Isn't Puck in The Lost Prince? I haven't read that yet but I thought I heard Puck was supposed to be in that."

I read that two months ago and he was like barely even in the book


message 16: by VG/Allie (new) - added it

VG/Allie Yes, there should be a Book just about Puck, knowing some of what he dose there could be a whole serise....


Reyhaneh Veggy wrote: "Yes, there should be a Book just about Puck, knowing some of what he dose there could be a whole serise...."

LOL... you just kind of make my day with that.


message 18: by Nila (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nila YES! There should definitely be a book for puck! He was my favorite character! I want to see him fall in love with a girl that will actually accept him and love him! HE'S AMAZING!!!


Isabella (All Da Ladies Luv Leo) Thomas well there's an ebook for puck


message 20: by Bre (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bre Isabella (Professional RPer) wrote: "well there's an ebook for puck"

yes but we're an actual book, series maybe


Snowblue~ Rachel is AWESOME!!! :p Yes there needs to be a book for Puck! I want Puck to have a happy ending, but yet, I want him aaaaalllll to myself ;)

Anyone with me? ;)


puppitypup Yes! Puck is the best character! Without him and Grimaldi, the books would be dull...ergo the lost prince. It broke my heart that Megan chose Ash instead of Puck.


Snowblue~ Rachel is AWESOME!!! :p puppitypup wrote: "Yes! Puck is the best character! Without him and Grimaldi, the books would be dull...ergo the lost prince. It broke my heart that Megan chose Ash instead of Puck."

OH SO TOTALLY TRUE! Puck loved her longer than Ash had. He had to wait for her, but she chose the selfish, boring- sorry I am going on again. And it is Grimalkin. The cat/cait sith's name is Grimalkin. And Puck is the best character ever. Grimalkin is really funny too. I love it when Puck argues with people! Oh, so much funny... sorry I am doing it again.

So yea.


message 24: by Luna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Luna There is but its a ebook. I agree it would be cool if they had a series for Puck, but Julie Kagawa has 2 series,plus one coming in 2015


Snowblue~ Rachel is AWESOME!!! :p really? well, I don't have anything for ebooks but... eh


Lizbeth Amber wrote: "There is but its a ebook. I agree it would be cool if they had a series for Puck, but Julie Kagawa has 2 series,plus one coming in 2015"

What is this about another series??? When was this announced?


Nurlely Lizbeth wrote: "What is this about another series??? When was this announced? "

You can look for them here ---> http://www.goodreads.com/series/list?...


Abbie I agree about Puck having a book but not about him having a new girl to fall in love in with. I was originally team Puck, wishing he'd be the one to end up with Meghan but then I can't quiet picture him as a family man as Ash. Or maybe I just want him available and not committed, selfish me. :D


Snowblue~ Rachel is AWESOME!!! :p YOU STAY AWAY FROM HIM! HE IS MINE!
you know, I was going to be super creepy and scare you but that is just mean... and kind of gross if you knew what I was going to say... people wouldn't be very happy...


Reyhaneh I think Puck really deserves a happy ending. I mean in the end the poor guy doesn't get anything and megan and ash are all happy. Don't get me wrong I'm happy that they are happy but puck deserves to be happy too.


Snowblue~ Rachel is AWESOME!!! :p I know how Puck feels...


message 32: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna 335 NOPE


Olivia (Bookcomet) That is such a good idea! Need to know what happens to Puck!


Trinity Oh my gosh YES!! I actually prefer Puck over Ash and it would be so cool to hear his story!!!!!


Trinity Hilary wrote: "Isn't Puck in The Lost Prince? I haven't read that yet but I thought I heard Puck was supposed to be in that."

The lost prince is Ethan's book, I'm pretty sure


Lauren There should definitely be a book just on puck, some of the things he says are hilarious, only he can make a joke in bad times :)


Lindsay Ome of the novella's is from Puck's point of view. It might be summer's crossing but you can check.


Sarah There should be a whole book on Puck. Ash just can't live up to Puck's amazingness. ;)


Roberta Reynolds I think Puck should have his own book. Maybe one's coming after The Lost Prince (Ethan's book) & the next book for the series which is supposed to be from Meghan & Ash's son.


Xavier I wish Meghan had chosen Puck. He is hilarious! Drives me crazy though. Why can't Ash just back off?!?


Miranda There shouldnt be a book for Puck. Im sorry but he is way too predictable .... There's no surprises in his character for me.


Caralin Hey im writing a fan-fic about puck's future daughter anyone interested? seeing a lot of puck fans like me. OMG I LOVE PUCK!! I wanted Ash and Meghan together more just saying but I LOVED PUCK!! I wanted him as my best friend so much through the whole story. and hes how I get people to read the book. by bragging about pucks awesomeness lol sorry I was ranting


Caralin http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...

If you guys want a story for Puck make one. This is an idea for a never-ending story about Puck after he left Ash in the Iron Knight


message 44: by J (new) - rated it 5 stars

J Yes, mega YESSS! Puck deserved one! I kinda feel sad about his immortality without someone in his life. :(


Ashley reads Joyce wrote: "Yes, mega YESSS! Puck deserved one! I kinda feel sad about his immortality without someone in his life. :("

I totally agree, he deserves a better ending! Even though Julie Kagawa doesn't want to write a sequel I think a new book (or even better a series) about Puck's past would also be interesting since he seems to have lived a lot of adventures full of pranks ^^


message 46: by Tor (last edited May 20, 2013 07:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tor Cassie I would totally love that :)
I <3 puck


Eveline I would love that! We do not really get to know him in the books and he always was my favourite character!


Addee Puck deserves his own book.....


Nikita oooh yeah, I would so love that. Maybe a prequel of when he first met Meghan leading up to the Iron King.


Julia Wang Yes! There should definitely be a book about Puck!


« previous 1
back to top