My Name Is Red My Name Is Red question


122 views
***spoiler alert***
Michal Michal May 09, 2013 07:47AM
Why didn't Elegant Effendi just reveal the identity of his murderer, since he wanted him to be caught? He knew who he was with, after all... I know that would defy the purpose of the book, but from a logical point of view I'm not sure how much sense it makes to keep the identity to himself.



This is a book that seems to have many narrators... until the end, when we find there is only one: Orhan, who is writing well after the events depicted. Shekure even apologizes that the narrative might be altered for the sake of a better story (I don't have the book handy for the quote but it is essentially that she might be portrayed as more beautiful then she really is, Shevket as more unpleasant, Black as more forgetful etc. because Orhan is looking to write the best story possible)

So the corpse doesn't reveal himself because it isn't truly him talking; it's Orhan narrator who wants the identity to remain secret.

19632699
Michal Bingo! :) I have just read the last chapter and indeed, in the last paragraph Shekure mentions giving it all to her son, Orhan, to write up. So that's ...more
May 22, 2014 06:16AM · flag
19632699
Michal Thanks, Edward. Nice one.
May 22, 2014 06:16AM · flag

Because it was a murder mystery


because the creation was more important than the artist. He was more concerned about finishing the book than saving his life. In fact that is the common theme throughout the book.


back to top