The Hogwartians Group discussion

I want to know what you guys thought was the sadest part. Mine was when Harry finds out he is the seventh horcux. And when he is walking in the forest to his death. *sniff sniffle*

DOBBY! DEFINITLY DOBBY!

Dobby, Hedwig, and Fred's death are the saddest to me.

The saddest parts for me were:

Hedwig's death
Dobby's death
Mad-Eye's death

Opps! Mad eye's death would be after Hedwig's death in My list.

Well I didn't put them in order...here is the order:

Dobby's death
Mad-eye's death
Hedwig's death

Dobby's death
Mad-eye's death
Malfoy Manor
Fred's death
Ron leaving Harry and Hermione

Not in order though.

MALFOY MANNER WAS SO INTENSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I KNOW!!!!!! I WAS FINGER BITING THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE CHAPTER!!!!!

LOL SO WAS I!!!!!!!!!!!!POOR HERMINIONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I KNOW!!!!!!!!!!! I WAS LIKE AHHHHHH!!!

AND OMG IT WAS SO CREEPY WHEN WORMTAIL KILLED HIMSELF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I know!!!!!!! But that was also kind of random, I mean Harry says wormtail owes him a debt then BAM, he killed himself

Yeah. :/
When Harry says, 'You owe me, Wormtail' he probably ment 'don't turn us in, tell him we've mysteriouly dissapeared...or something'
I mean, that was a little..extreme. I wonder if they'll even show that in the film...The seventh movie had better be good

Remember that the hand that strangled himself with was the one that Voldemort gave him.
But I loved Malfoy Manor SSSSSSSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much!! And I loved the whole voldemort taboo thing! funny and clever!

Yeah they don't call him Voldemort anymore than called him 'Tabboo' and then I was like NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! When Harry said 'Volemort' and they got captered....ARRRRRRRRRRRRRRHHHHHHHH!!!!! SO INTEASE!!!
But well written.....JKR is AMAZING.

I KNOW!!!
I didnt like the final battel againts Voldermort and Harry, I thought it was to quick and easy

Erica wrote: "I KNOW!!!
I didnt like the final battel againts Voldermort and Harry, I thought it was to quick and easy"

Yeah, you would think Voldy would cheat and just kill him. But I don't know..

Erica wrote: "I know!!!!!!! But that was also kind of random, I mean Harry says wormtail owes him a debt then BAM, he killed himself"

YEAH, I totally didn't expect that!! I mean, I knew he was a coward and all but..

Erica wrote: "I KNOW!!!
I didnt like the final battel againts Voldermort and Harry, I thought it was to quick and easy"

I loved it

THose were my favorite parts. Spells flying everywhere.

No, she meant the last part between Harry and Voldemort. Not the whole Battle Scene.

Yeah, I loved the whole battle scene, just not the harry vs voldermort one

The battles scense were AWSOME!

I totally agree! That was one of the best parts! (besides the fact that so many died :'( )

I wish Dobby didn't die :(

I wish Fred and Tonks didn't die most!

Mehvish wrote: "hands down, HANDS DOWN when snape is dying and to harry he's like "look at me" because that way he can see lily's eyes before he dies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HOW SAD/ROMANTIC/ENDEARING. I <3 snape"

OMG DEFINITELEY! He's all, "look..at..me.."! And at first I was like, what was that for? And then I realized that he wasnted to see Lily! ROMANTIC!!

Whichever part when people first started dying.

Colin died right? Or was that his brother?

I think it was Colin

Savannah wrote: "I wish Fred and Tonks didn't die most!"

TONKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FRED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
WHY IN THE WORLD DID SHE KILL SO MANY CHARACTERS SHE KNEW FANS LOVED?!

♥Janeen-san♥ wrote: "Savannah wrote: "I wish Fred and Tonks didn't die most!"

TONKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FRED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
WHY IN THE WORLD DID SHE KILL SO MANY CHARACTERS SHE KNEW HER FANS LOVED?!

I DON'T KNOW!!!! WHY DID SHE DO THAT?!?!

IT WAS SOOOOOOOOO SAAAAAAAAAAAADDDD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I HAVE NO IDEA!

I cried when Lupin, Fred, Tonks died. Then Snape I was like awwwww poor Snape!

LUPIN WAS AWSOME!!!!!!!! WHY DID HE HAVE TO DIE?!?!!?!?

♥Janeen-san♥ wrote: "LUPIN WAS AWSOME!!!!!!!! WHY DID HE HAVE TO DIE?!?!!?!?"

I KNOW!! There really wasn't any point in killing Lupin, Tonks or Fred. Snape, I can understand, even though I loved him.

♥Janeen-san♥ wrote: "LUPIN WAS AWSOME!!!!!!!! WHY DID HE HAVE TO DIE?!?!!?!?"


WHY???????? WHY DID HE HAVE TO DIE?!?!?

Kendall wrote: "♥Janeen-san♥ wrote: "LUPIN WAS AWSOME!!!!!!!! WHY DID HE HAVE TO DIE?!?!!?!?"


WHY???????? WHY DID HE HAVE TO DIE?!?!? HE WAS SOOOO COOL!!!

It may not have been JKR's fault. Her editors may have changed it.

DARN U EDITOrS! DARN U TO HECK!

WHY WOULD EDITORS DO SUCH A THING? ARE YOU SURE? *sniff* MAYBE JKR PLANNED IT LIKE THAT
:(

I'm certain it wasn't the editor's idea. JKR planned her whole series and I think the deaths were necessary. They make the story realistic. There's a war against Voldemort, so good people have to die fighting. (JKR originally intented to kill Mr. Weasley and let Tonks and Lupin survive, but she changed it - I prefer saving Mr. Weasley.)

Yeah, definatly more realistic--it would be cheesy if everyone magically survived. But it was so sad. :'(

Yeah, so I guess they HAD to die :(

*sinff*

aw, it's okay.




















*sniff*

*sniiiiiiiiiiif*

Why did you put a biiiiiig space between ur words??

Felt like it....:(

ohhh...*sniff* :(