Go Harry Potter And Twilight! discussion

So do you think Bella should have ended up with Jake? What do you think of Jacob?

Definitely not, they are much better as friends. I like Jacob but i prefer Bella with Edward. He's kind of funny and would make for a great heater during the winter, but as i said i think Bella made the right choice.

The guy (Taylor Lautner) they chose to play him in the movies is all wrong, definitely not what i was expecting.

Ugh, I hate Taylor!! He's eww, I canNOT believe girls think he's HOT! EW

But I really don't like Jake, I thought he was too pushy, especially in the 3rd book.

Swati wrote: "Ugh, I hate Taylor!! He's eww, I canNOT believe girls think he's HOT! EW

But I really don't like Jake, I thought he was too pushy, especially in the 3rd book."

i agree about jacob being waaay too pushy...that's exactly how i described him (luv ya swati, my twin sis)
but i thought taylor was pretty OK looking (the only thing u will never agree with me about)

Samiha wrote: "Swati wrote: "Ugh, I hate Taylor!! He's eww, I canNOT believe girls think he's HOT! EW

But I really don't like Jake, I thought he was too pushy, especially in the 3rd book."

i agree about jacob ..."


Luv ya too, Samiha!

Hm, yeah, that and the Draco thing!!

I pictured him to be better looking in the book though.

Draco thing? What Draco thing??

Uhhh..lol, I forget!!

emm... i didn't like robert n Kristen playing as Edward n Bella-- dunno i fell like they are so not like the characters in the books... yuck :S
Am i the only one who hates those 2 ppl?? okay not really hate..lol

I don't think they could have found anyone as good as the Edward we all pictured in our heads, though i go through fazes thinking Robert was a good choice, depends on how he looks at the time, but i do think he played the part well. Kristen on the other hand i think fitted the image pretty well, but acting wise she wasn't what i was expecting, she might do well though in New Moon during her depressed period.

I liked Jacob. However, whenever I see him I feel a million years old and he's just a cute little kid.

Strange, I know...

Edward was horrible, I didn't like him at all, and Bella..well, she was okay..

thankyou swati-- at least somebody in this huge world agrees with me- i so don't like robert pattinson :(

Neither no I!! He really scares me..I loved him as Cedric though..as Edward..*shudders*

I think that Kristin Stewart LOOKS a lot like Bella, but her acting...ugh! And then Robert Pattinson is a good actor, but as Edward, definitely does not fit.

Do yuo have any actors you think would've been a better Edward? I love re-casting movies! lol

I have no idea - I don't really know much about the whole acting industry.

Meh neither do I...I just pick who looks the part.I wanted Steven Strait for Jacob...and I'd want someone else as Rosalie...just not sure who

yeah- the guy's ok as cedric swati.. :) well i don't think anyone can do justice to the characters of twilight-i mean- aww... dunno...

yeah Rosalie looked too old I think...

everyone looks too old- except for esme n carlisle-- obella n others r supposed to be 17,18 right???

Swati wrote: "So do you think Bella should have ended up with Jake? What do you think of Jacob?"

omg no are you crazy wait yes so i can be with edward and she can have jacob thats better

Vanessa wrote: "Swati wrote: "So do you think Bella should have ended up with Jake? What do you think of Jacob?"

omg no are you crazy wait yes so i can be with edward and she can have jacob thats better"

=D Vanessa, why would you want a stalker for a boyfriend!?

I don't like Jacob in the book and I don't think he's cute in real life (ew), but in real life I like him better than Robert Pattinson because (even though he's rreeaalllyyy hot) he's like a crack head in real life. He smokes, stalks Kristin Stewart, and hates kids!

yeah but he is soo hot and not jacob but who cares i like crackheads

ya he is still hot...but i like edward better than robert

But still...Jacob is a little woman stealer! Can't he see that Bella is in love with Edward?! AANNNDDD he's giving her a hard time about it and making her feel horrible! And he's a little pedifile liking Bella's daughter!

-_- he can go jump off a bridge

...and onto a giant floating trampeline!!

i don't like JAcob really...i don't understand the character...still haven't read breaking dawn...maybe if i read it i'll understand his personality..