An Alcott Event discussion
Miscellaneous Alcotts
>
Jack and Jill
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Christine PNW
(new)
Oct 12, 2013 04:28PM
Mod
reply
|
flag
Zahara wrote: "I'm going to be listening to this one on Librivox. It sounds good."
It's delightful. You will love it!
It's delightful. You will love it!
I finished Jack and Jill. I really loved most of it. I found it got kind of preachy/moralizing about the last fourth and lost the lovely interaction between Jack and Jill. But overall, it was a great story.
Zahara wrote: "I finished Jack and Jill. I really loved most of it. I found it got kind of preachy/moralizing about the last fourth and lost the lovely interaction between Jack and Jill. But overall, it was a gre..."
It is interesting - this is the first time that I've ever really taken note of Alcott's heavy-handed moralizing. Maybe because I'm reading a number of them in a row?
I love her characters and her stories, but her insistence on shoving the moral down the readers throat detracts from the enjoyment, and, worse, it is unnecessary. We can all get her point without the explicit passages. I think that a more subtle approach would be more effective, actually.
It is interesting - this is the first time that I've ever really taken note of Alcott's heavy-handed moralizing. Maybe because I'm reading a number of them in a row?
I love her characters and her stories, but her insistence on shoving the moral down the readers throat detracts from the enjoyment, and, worse, it is unnecessary. We can all get her point without the explicit passages. I think that a more subtle approach would be more effective, actually.

