The Agatha Christie Reading Group discussion

Second Poirot novel, published in 1923.

Looking forward to reading this one. Another of my favourites

I have read till 50% and have a question. What do you people think of Detective Giraud? Is he parody of Sherlock Holmes?

Tushar wrote: "I have read till 50% and have a question. What do you people think of Detective Giraud? Is he parody of Sherlock Holmes?"

Hmm. I don't know. I never read any of Sherlock Holmes to compare the two characters. Interesting observation.

I certainly think so, especially at the time it wasn't written.

I have finaly located my copy, I did lend it to somebody and she will return it as soon as she comes down soutn, which is next week.

I will let you know as soon as I have finished it.

Lauren, I too have watched this on Netflix, and I thought they mentioned a sister but there was none. While reading this I hear Poirot and Hastings voices. I enjoy it.

Tushar wrote: "I have read till 50% and have a question. What do you people think of Detective Giraud? Is he parody of Sherlock Holmes?"

Yes I was reminded of Sherlock Holmes too. Giraud has some Sherlock-like qualities and this made me consider how unlike Sherlock Poirot is.

On the subject of parodies has anyone seen the movie Murder by death with the Marple and Poirot parodies? Watched it last week. I highely recommend it.

I love Murder by Death! I rewatch it at regular intervals.

I want to see that movie so bad! I'm sure I will enjoy it.

I just finished this one. It was certainly twisty! I have a hard time seeing how Poirot and Hastings are such friends, especially the way Hastings acted in this book. Overall, 4 stars!