YA Book Club! discussion

Here you can discuss the Fault in Our Stars or any other of John Green's books.

So this is a discussion... Well I loved/hated the ending! Since I'm a romantic at heart I wanted no one to die but death was what really made the book popular so I'm torn

I loved that book

I'll have to say that I'm not a huge fan of the FioS. I totally HATE the ending, but at the same time I love it! Overall, it was a good book though! :D

Aryan wrote: "I want to read The Fault in Our Stars and Looking For Alaska SOOOOOOO badly!!!!!!!"

Also, Looking for Alaska is better in my opinion

Julie wrote: "Also, Looking for Alaska is better in my opinion"

I disagree, I think the Fault in Our Stars was better then Looking for Alaska. It wasn't one of my favorites.

Well, I guess I'm also kind of biased, since I dislike the FioS A LOT...
Well, (view spoiler)[ he died, and I hate that.... (hide spoiler)]

Ya it kind of sucked but I still liked it

Other than that, the book was really good though.

Yes!! We're reading Anne Frank at my school (view spoiler)[and it reminds me of when Gus and Hazel kissed at the Anne Frank house. (hide spoiler)]

That's one of my fav parts!

Ya I absolutely loved it

I loooved this book sooo much! It's one of my favourite ever! and yeah the part where (view spoiler)[they kissed in the Anne frank house (hide spoiler)] was one of my fav parts too. But omg this book is so sad, im gonna cry so much when I see the movie.

That was my favorite part too. And I cried so hard the book I will be bawling when I see the movie.

I'm guessing I'll be crying as well

Has anyone seen the movie yet??? I'm seeing it on Wednesday, or Sunday! I'm soooo excited! :D

I'm hoping to go sometime this week!!!

Why not?

I live in the Netherlands and here the movie doesn't come out until July 10th!! :'(

Julie wrote: "Has anyone seen the movie yet??? I'm seeing it on Wednesday, or Sunday! I'm soooo excited! :D"

I haven't even read the book! I'm 191 in the hold list thingy!

Littlebooklover wrote: "I live in the Netherlands and here the movie doesn't come out until July 10th!! :'("

Really? That sucks

James wrote: "Julie wrote: "Has anyone seen the movie yet??? I'm seeing it on Wednesday, or Sunday! I'm soooo excited! :D"

I haven't even read the book! I'm 191 in the hold list thingy!"

191?!?!?! Wow. My teacher at school loves books, and she lets me borrow hers, so that's how I got to read it

I'm so excited to see the movie

Yes, so am I! I haven't seen it yet but I'm seeing it in a few days!

The movie was good...but the book is always better <3

Adrianna♥ wrote: "The movie was good...but the book is always better <3"

Yes, books are always better in my opinion! :D
[image error]

I know right.

Aryan wrote: "Julie wrote: "Why not?"

Because the movies PG-13 and I'm only 10" It's not like you're going to go by yourself....Isn't a parent or guardian going to take you?

Aryan wrote: "Adrianna♥ wrote: "Aryan wrote: "Julie wrote: "Why not?"

Because the movies PG-13 and I'm only 10" It's not like you're going to go by yourself....Isn't a parent or guardian going to take you?"

Ya..."


oh...have you read the book yet?

-gasp- ...why?..

ohhh....okay.

You should read it! It's really good!

Julie wrote: "James wrote: "Julie wrote: "Has anyone seen the movie yet??? I'm seeing it on Wednesday, or Sunday! I'm soooo excited! :D"

I haven't even read the book! I'm 191 in the hold list thingy!"

191?!?!?..."

Lucky! Now I'm 163. I'll keep you updated!

Cool! Well, you'll read it eventually!

Yep! 157

;)

I never thought I would like a book like this .. But seriously, it blew my mind. Finished it in a day and a half, (just after finishing Allegiant trying to heal my wounds .. mind you, it did not work) and went straight on to Looking for Alaska which was also an epic book. John Green's style of writing is just .. drool.

Vilde wrote: "I never thought I would like a book like this .. But seriously, it blew my mind. Finished it in a day and a half, (just after finishing Allegiant trying to heal my wounds .. mind you, it did not wo..."

Agreed. It worked maybe some when I was trying to get my mind off of finishing Harry Potter, by some I mean VERY WELL. I love this book. ;)

Vilde wrote: "I never thought I would like a book like this .. But seriously, it blew my mind. Finished it in a day and a half, (just after finishing Allegiant trying to heal my wounds .. mind you, it did not wo..."

I liked the book, but the ending… it was just sad. I normally hate those types of books with sad endings, but for this book, I have conflicted feelings- I love and hate it at the same time!

Vilde wrote: "I never thought I would like a book like this .. But seriously, it blew my mind. Finished it in a day and a half, (just after finishing Allegiant trying to heal my wounds .. mind you, it did not wo..."

I liked the book, but the ending… it was just sad. I normally hate those types of books with sad endings, but for this book, I have conflicted feelings- I love and hate it at the same time!

Julie wrote: "Vilde wrote: "I never thought I would like a book like this .. But seriously, it blew my mind. Finished it in a day and a half, (just after finishing Allegiant trying to heal my wounds .. mind you,..."

I second that

Yeah. ;)

Somebody spoiled it for me. I don't know if they were telling the truth, but I'm going to read it anyway.

Ok. It's a good book

Julie wrote: "Vilde wrote: "I never thought I would like a book like this .. But seriously, it blew my mind. Finished it in a day and a half, (just after finishing Allegiant trying to heal my wounds .. mind you,..."

I couldn't agree more. I've been going over this in my head a gazillion times, but I think I've come to the conclusion that the ending was as ingenious as the rest of the book. Sure it was sad, but it was like a "oh my word so sweet and unexpected and epic" sort of sad (if that's even a thing.)

I feel the same way. It was a really sad ending but it fit with the rest of the book and completed it.

Yeah. ;)

43! 43!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm 3! 3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Aryan wrote: "But I did not cry in the book."

Neither did I