In a Relationship with a Fictional Character discussion

This guy is such a cutie! I just finished the two books and for the sake of non spoilers, that's all I'm gonna say. Thoughts on Peter? Who did you ship?
I shipped Josh first :P

I always shipped Peter. The childhood friends thing was cute. Right from the start I felt off about Josh.

the thing that felt the most off about Josh was how he immediately wanted to give Lara Jean a chance when it's like, "you just got out of a relationship and with her sister of all people!"

Exactly!!! I just had such a huge problem with that.

Just finished first book :( my heart hurts how can she just end the book like that?!! And i shipped Josh first lol but then i got annoyed cause he kept being rude and claimed he was just being protective but it pissed me off the way he was doing it and he seemed to like Lara Jean once she was with Peter who i loveddd :( my heart oh Peter le sigh im so conflicted idk if i wanna read sequel i dont want another new guy! :( ugh

I feel you Crystal!

Mehhh lol thxss i need a day to think it over lol

We're all in the same boat!

Just finished the second book!! Didnt anyone think the ending could have been better?? Maybe they resolved their issues before the last chapter /:

I agree! It was too simple and lame. I found it rather "meh". Could have been wayyyy better!

Yesss im like but wth they went through mad crap and thats all the reunion we get :(

I know right?? And the whole John thing (was that his name?) was totally irrelevant! We didn't even need a second book to be honest! I think the second one just showcased Lara Jean's stupidity :P

We really didnt lol i felt bad for John Ambrose MCcarlen(thats the full name lol) poor guy just wanted to be loved

I agree. to be honest, he deserves someone for whom he is the first choice, not the "my boyfriend and I are having issues I caused but I chose to blame him instead of paying attention so I'm gonna turn to you because you're available" option :P

Lol i woulda picked him xD

John? I liked John, I just don't like him for Lara Jean. I don't know who I'd pick for myself ^^

Lol yeah i agreee

I also really wish we saw more of her dad and her neighbor. I thought they made a cute couple ^^

Yasss lol i loved them her dad was so adorable

Yasss lol i loved them her dad was so adorable

And the lame ending excluded them :(

Yass ikk