No Judgement Book Club discussion

Ok, who felt cheated about Blue. The ending was ehhhh and what about Noah?! What are your thoughts?

I didn't really love the series so the ending, even though it was meh, did wrap up the plot for me in a lot of ways. Liked this the best of the other books for sure, but again, probably because it marked the end of the series.

I loved this series, until the ending. It just all felt kind of... ehhhh is a good way to describe it actually. I believe I rated it 4 stars right after I finished reading, but I think that was still because I was on a lack of sleep buzz. But after thinking about it I feel like it was the most lacking of the series. It answered most of the questions, but at the same time I didn't feel like Blue really got the ending that she deserved. Same goes for Noah ;; Poor pale prince

Kayy wrote: "I loved this series, until the ending. It just all felt kind of... ehhhh is a good way to describe it actually. I believe I rated it 4 stars right after I finished reading, but I think that was sti..."

I felt the same! Did anyone else feel this way?

I actually felt like this book was a great way to end the series. I thought the ending with Gansey was sort of predictable, but if it had been any other way I would've been so upset. haha

Noah's ending.. I mean, what ending did he deserve, really? There was only one way for that to go pretty much, and I felt it was fitting. And neat, the way it tied everything together. He ended up being the reason they all found each other, which is super sweet.

Blue got what she wanted; her true love was alive, and she was about to have the chance of traveling the world with him like she wanted. Plus, she got the greenest car ever. haha

So yeah, I was pretty happy with it, and still feel like it deserved the 5-star rating it got from me. :)