Harry Potter Fans discussion

So how this game works is I you will post a book that is also a movie. Then you have to say whatever you think the book is better or the movie and give a valid reason. More the one person can answer. 20 points for each answer. Thanks to Megharin for suggesting the game.

The first book/movie is Harry Potter and The Sorcerers Stone

Grace Wright wrote: "The first book/movie is Harry Potter and The Sorcerers Stone"

The book because it has more detail, the characters are all better written and included more, and it has more scenes/moments that weren't in the film.

Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring

Movie, I haven't read much of the book and I just love the scenery! (#ProudNewZealander)

Miss Peregrines home for peculiar children

Johanna wrote: "Movie, I haven't read much of the book and I just love the scenery! (#ProudNewZealander)

Miss Peregrines home for peculiar children"

Book-the movie was kind of strange

The Mortal Instruments: City of Bone

Book.

There were funnier scenes in the book and Jace is not at all how I imagine him.

Percy Jackson: The Lightning Thief

Books.
There were funnier scenes and Jace wasn't how I imagined him (though still awesome).
Percy Jackson: The Lightning Thief

Book. Because honestly the movies barely even followed the storyline of the books.

The Hobbit

Book. I disliked the animation on the movie.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them

Movie.
I loved Edward Redmayne's portrayal of Newt soooo much.

Twilight.

Book. (More interesting, but honestly I can still barely tolerate them)

Paper Towns

Cheating a bit

The cursed child book was great and the play more than realised the potential.

Book. so many reasons