The Glass Bead Game
question
Famous Books/Author That Work Better If You Are Young
Robert
Jul 21, 2014 05:48AM
Every go back and read a book you read in your teens or twenties only to find it just doesn't play so well now that you are perhaps decades older?
I like to go back and read, and here's a few of the books that I loved when I was younger, but now, not so much.
Herman Hesse: Glass Bead Game
Salinger: Catcher In The Rye
Ayn Rand Books (Lord the writing is bad)
So what are your authors/books that you loved in your 20's, but not so much now that you are older?
I like to go back and read, and here's a few of the books that I loved when I was younger, but now, not so much.
Herman Hesse: Glass Bead Game
Salinger: Catcher In The Rye
Ayn Rand Books (Lord the writing is bad)
So what are your authors/books that you loved in your 20's, but not so much now that you are older?
reply
flag
Tom Robbins, Jitterbug Perfume and Another Roadside Attraction
Henry Miller....everything but especially Tropic of Capricorn and Tropic of Cancer
Douglas Adams, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
Hermann Hesse, Demian
Henry Miller....everything but especially Tropic of Capricorn and Tropic of Cancer
Douglas Adams, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
Hermann Hesse, Demian
i find the bulk of Hesse's work, i cannot read as an adult - other than the Steppenwolf & Narcissus and Goldmund. he appealed to the conflicts i was encountering when i was a teenager. Hesse was that first author i discovered that made me see how foolish and adolescent the beatniks were. and we all wasted our time with Kerouac.
Referencing Hesse, the only book of his that works as a teenager and not an adult is Demian.
Some novels and poetry endure thousands of births and lives and deaths
The same stream twice is Heraclitus...though it could be from China too.
Here's the link http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/11752...
Here's the link http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/11752...
I read Glass Bead Game as and adult and don't think I would have understood it as a kid, despite being above average in reading level.
Catcher in the Rye I didn't even like that much when I read it as a teen, I'd probably like it less now. Same with Ayn Rand's Anthem, which I was not thrilled with then.
For me, the early books in Diane Duane's Young Wizards series are a little immature for me in some ways now - I don't care about a character debating fashion choices. But the fantasy aspects and writing style are still excellent. Granted, this is YA anyway.
In terms of non-YA - I haven't reread them but I think I'd like Anne Rice's Vampire Chronicles less now than I did as a teen. I've gotten more picky about writing styles over the years, that's part of the reason.
Catcher in the Rye I didn't even like that much when I read it as a teen, I'd probably like it less now. Same with Ayn Rand's Anthem, which I was not thrilled with then.
For me, the early books in Diane Duane's Young Wizards series are a little immature for me in some ways now - I don't care about a character debating fashion choices. But the fantasy aspects and writing style are still excellent. Granted, this is YA anyway.
In terms of non-YA - I haven't reread them but I think I'd like Anne Rice's Vampire Chronicles less now than I did as a teen. I've gotten more picky about writing styles over the years, that's part of the reason.
I find this problem more with hack and slash fantasy. Granted there is only one Robert E. Howard.
deleted member
Aug 31, 2014 12:42AM
-1 votes
So interesting. Glass Bead Game is on my re-read list, and I've just ordered it, but wonder how I'll see it 40 years later. I remember the interplay of all disciplines made into a symphony. I worry about the splintering of all of us into factions, and hope to see this as a uniting, fortifying book. Ayn Rand appealed to me when young. Now? Hmm. She's been co-opted by so many groups, it's hard to say. I have not reread, say, "Stranger in a Strange Land," knowing I would find it facile. Have attempted reread of "Nausea" and found it a giant, ego-driven "selfie." Just read in an intro to The Oxford Book of Japanese Short Stories that Hans Christian Anderson is one of the great short story writers, remember being enthralled by him, feeling even as a child that I was catching only glimpses of things I wasn't ready for. Now I wonder if I need to reread him not only to study his short story forms, but the levels at which it can be read. What accessible to a child, what's there for me in my 60's? My instince is that I will find stories which attempt to explain pain and longing, which have been relegated to the world of children's literature, but which speak to adults, as well. Updike's "Couples" did not hold up for me, but his short stories from the same period have. Interesting question.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic





