2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #1 discussion

Who topped your initial suspect list after Vivian’s death? Did it change when Amy died?

Yes I thought it was Amy so I had to think again once Amy died. I thought it might be Tamar

For most of the story I thought it was Tamar, especially when Amy moved into the house and was then abducted and killed. It wasn’t until close to the reveal that I moved away from her as the suspect.

I thought it was Tamar. When it was mentioned that she always rides home with Vivian but didn't on the afternoon that Vivian died, I suspected that Tamar was the person who poisoned her. I also thought that she had hired someone to get rid of Amy while they were out shopping.

Yep! We followed that red herring all the way.

Very similar thinking on this point, Robin. I just wonder how Tamar could influence Gregory so quickly, whether he had a thing going with her and Amy (not at the same time, ick), or that Tamar was threatened with Amy's presence and production of a son.

I never thought it was Amy because it'd have been too easy. Tamar was always among my top suspects, and even when Mrs Spratt-Williams being the culprit became a very real possibility, I still couldn't completely stop suspecting Tamar until the very end.

I suspected Tamar until Lisa Biofare (sp?) said something about Vivian and Spratt-Williams' argument. After that I knew it was her.

We all went down the same path.