Rated YA-MA discussion

First Impressions- Roll Call
This is a spoiler free thread!

Roll Call: Will you be joining in the group read? What format: print, ebook, audio? How excited (or not) are you to read this great stand-alone fantasy? Have you read it already?

First Impressions: Share your initial impressions of this book without any book spoilers.

Discuss the full book with spoilers here: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

Melanie wrote: "First Impressions- Roll Call
This is a spoiler free thread!

Roll Call: Will you be joining in the group read? What format: print, ebook, audio? How excited (or not) are you to read this great stan..."
I am reading this now and plan to post on the spoiler thread later. So far this is not bad. I like the emphasis on books, reading and libraries.

I just started today, so I’m still comprehending the world-building.
I listening to it on audio.

Melanie wrote: "I just started today, so I’m still comprehending the world-building.
I listening to it on audio."

The world building is pretty good. Idk if this is a one off, or part of a series that will be based in this world.

It is dry specifically a stand alone as that was the nominating category. Soo you wot ave to find or wait for a new book 8n this series. The author has other books and the art work for t(em is kind of similar.

Melanie wrote: "It is dry specifically a stand alone as that was the nominating category. Soo you wot ave to find or wait for a new book 8n this series. The author has other books and the art work for t(em is kind..."

I really like the magic system and the whole idea of the books. It’s a fun read and I wish it was a series. Have you gotten very far into it?

Not yet...

I'm listening to the audio book and really enjoying it so far. I like the magic system too, the beginning had a bit of a harry potter vibe to it for me. Less so now, I'm more than half way through. I like Elizabeth and I find Nathaniel's dry humor funny. It's been a fun read so far.

Amy wrote: "I'm listening to the audio book and really enjoying it so far. I like the magic system too, the beginning had a bit of a harry potter vibe to it for me. Less so now, I'm more than half way through...."

There really is a Harry Potter vibe. Especially with the school and the books.

@Cyn
the conversation in this thread should be spoiler free first impressions. Can you move this post over to the spoiler thread: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/... ?

Moved to fantasy folder.