Redwall discussion

Defend your reasons against others.

My favorite book is High Rhulain. I believe that the plot is one of the best in the series. The main island and the main characters remind me of the celtic-gaelic countries like Scotland and Ireland. Speaking, of the characters, they are well-thoughtout and not tropey or cliche.

My favs are Taggerung and Marlfox.

Redwall is probably my favorite. It was so cool reading it and the whole twist of I am that is was super cool.

You have good reason. Redwall was one of my favorites.

I just thought it was neat because of all the backstory.

But I still think Taggerung and Marlfox are the best.

Can you give any reason why?

Here’s the thing, I wish I could, but I read them so long ago, the only thing remember is how much I enjoyed them.

Sorry.

Eh, it's fine.

Mattimeo is very close to my heart because watching the animated adaptation of that book is how I discovered the Redwall book series. To this day, I love the adventure and the different plotlines going on at the same time (you've got Mattimeo with his friends, Matthias and the other questing parents, and the Redwallers defending the Abbey).

Also Martin the Warrior is an excellent story with plenty of drama, heartbreak and heroism. Definitely a highlight of the series.

High Rhulain is special to me as well because I strongly believe I was the inspiration for Tiria. Though, like I said, I never got to ask BJ if that was true, all signs point to it.

While it’s not my favorite, I was impressed by Doomwyte. Jacques didn’t ever try to add a magic system into his books, (for good reason) but it’s awesome to see how that might have played out if he had. Doomwyte might have been a good place to start. (No magic, but there is illusion.)

I thought Doomwhite was excellent as well

Patricia wrote: "Mattimeo is very close to my heart because watching the animated adaptation of that book is how I discovered the Redwall book series. To this day, I love the adventure and the different plotlines g..."

Mattimeo was one of my favorites, as it was the first book to show us parts of the world that rarely gets seen.