Horror Aficionados discussion

Maggie's Grave
This topic is about Maggie's Grave
430 views
Group Reads > May 2025 Group Read #1-Maggie's Grave

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Latasha (new) - added it

Latasha (latasha513) | 11983 comments The winner of our May Poll is Maggie's Grave. Reading begins on May 1st and last all month. Read at your own pace. Please use spoiler tags if discussing anything that could ruin the story for others. Happy reading!


Netanella | 599 comments Yeah! Excited for this one!


message 3: by Lazar. (new) - added it

Lazar. Melala | 11 comments I am waiting for what’s coming.


message 4: by FranWeird (last edited Apr 27, 2025 12:39PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

FranWeird | 19 comments Perfect excuse to order another book! 😁 I'm stoked!


message 5: by whatYetiread (new)

whatYetiread | 3 comments so excited! both this months books have been on my list. now if i can get through "You like it darker" before the 1st


destiny ♡ howling libraries (howlinglibraries) | 322 comments Ooooh I read this not too long ago and LOVED it! David has become an auto-read author for me. I can't wait to discuss it!


Diane  | 178 comments Enjoy...This is Awesome!!


Nicole | 1 comments I loved this book, can’t wait to talk about it!!!


Ginger | 3973 comments Excited this got picked! I’ve had it on my TBR for a while and I’ll be joining for the group read. 🙌


message 10: by Kasia (new)

Kasia (kasia_s) | 4623 comments Mod
I already have a copy, never heard of it before and it sounds really great :)


message 11: by WendyB , Christmas Mouse (new) - rated it 4 stars

WendyB  | 5182 comments Mod
I'll be starting this tomorrow. :)


message 12: by Joel (new) - rated it 4 stars

Joel | 1 comments Just finished it. It was great! What a fun ride


message 13: by WendyB , Christmas Mouse (new) - rated it 4 stars

WendyB  | 5182 comments Mod
20% read... and other than the first couple of pages, nothing much has really happened. I'm guessing it'll pick up soon?


AWellReadKimberly | 4 comments Excited to read this one with ya'll!


Jennifer | 452 comments Ooh, I have a copy of this one already and I've just finished my last read so I'm starting this one today.


Aline | 21 comments I'll start it in a few days. Right now I'm finishing Bird Box.


message 17: by Ginger (last edited May 05, 2025 08:09AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ginger | 3973 comments WendyB wrote: "20% read... and other than the first couple of pages, nothing much has really happened. I'm guessing it'll pick up soon?"

I'm about 20% in as well and I'm thinking it's going to start pretty quick.
I just finished up Chapter 7. (view spoiler) hahaha


Heather (libbylilwing) | 24 comments just got my copy. excited to start reading and this will be my first group read of the year! yay!


message 19: by WendyB , Christmas Mouse (new) - rated it 4 stars

WendyB  | 5182 comments Mod
About halfway through and lets just say all Hell has broken loose.
I'd like to finish today but not sure if I'll have the time.


Ginger | 3973 comments WendyB wrote: "About halfway through and lets just say all Hell has broken loose.
I'd like to finish today but not sure if I'll have the time."


Woohoo!! Great to hear. :D


message 21: by Cujo (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cujo (deadtimestories) | 44 comments I just finished this today and the question still lingers, did the townsfolk wash those yoga Mets after they were done with them back in 85?


Russel (rft183) | 16 comments Ginger wrote: "WendyB wrote: "20% read... and other than the first couple of pages, nothing much has really happened. I'm guessing it'll pick up soon?"

I'm about 20% in as well and I'm thinking it's going to sta..."


I was thinking the same thing around the 20% mark. Not much happening. Though Sodergren has been doing a good job at giving the town and it's citizens a sense of despair... Now I'm around the 40%, and it's starting to pick up quite a bit. I have a feeling that the sense of despair is going to stick around though.


message 23: by WendyB , Christmas Mouse (new) - rated it 4 stars

WendyB  | 5182 comments Mod
Almost done.
What a twisted little town. Don't know what else to say.


message 24: by WendyB , Christmas Mouse (new) - rated it 4 stars

WendyB  | 5182 comments Mod
Finished. Thought the story ended stronger than it started and def didn't see that ending coming and I probably should have. lol

I do have a question or two but it involves spoilers so: (view spoiler)


Diane  | 178 comments WendyB wrote: "Finished. Thought the story ended stronger than it started and def didn't see that ending coming and I probably should have. lol

I do have a question or two but it involves spoilers so: [spoilers ..."

Hi Wendy...The orgy in front of Alice was a ritual done in an attempt to expel the demon witch believed to be inhabiting the town. Hope that helps? 😊


message 26: by WendyB , Christmas Mouse (new) - rated it 4 stars

WendyB  | 5182 comments Mod
Diane wrote: "WendyB wrote: "Finished. Thought the story ended stronger than it started and def didn't see that ending coming and I probably should have. lol

I do have a question or two but it involves spoilers..."


weeeellll.... why would an orgy do that? To me, it just seems thrown in the story for shock value and not because it had any good reasoning behind it.


Diane  | 178 comments WendyB wrote: "Diane wrote: "WendyB wrote: "Finished. Thought the story ended stronger than it started and def didn't see that ending coming and I probably should have. lol

I do have a question or two but it inv..."

🤣🤣🤣 Well...perhaps it would scare her off as she may think she had to join in!!! 🤣🤣🤣


Ginger | 3973 comments Diane wrote: "🤣🤣🤣 Well...perhaps it would scare her off as..."

I completely agree!! hahaha


message 29: by Ginger (last edited May 12, 2025 02:11PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ginger | 3973 comments I finished last night. I loved the fact that there is a real Maggie Wall cairn in Dunning in Perthshire, Scotland. It made this even more fun to read.

I really liked how this one ended. I had an idea that (view spoiler)
The action and gore were off the charts. I had a blast reading it!


Russel (rft183) | 16 comments WendyB wrote: "Finished. Thought the story ended stronger than it started and def didn't see that ending coming and I probably should have. lol

I do have a question or two but it involves spoilers so: [spoilers ..."

I wondered that myself. Like, who decided that that had to be part of the ritual?


Patrick Ellard | 30 comments I enjoyed Maggie's Grave, it played out very much like a creature feature. Plenty of gore and a nice ending. There were a few plot points left unexplained and the plot is far from original but it was enjoyable and didn't overstay its welcome.


message 32: by Kasia (new)

Kasia (kasia_s) | 4623 comments Mod
Late to the party but I finally finished my other group read and really enjoying this one, I re-read the opening line three times, I mean wow.


Jennifer | 452 comments I'm not sure if the tone was supposed to be horror comedy but that was fun! I tore through that book. Hope you're all enjoying it.

The lead up to the ending was a little bit too long for my liking but it really paid off.

I enjoyed the writing, it made the town seem so empty and sad and the main characters were fleshed out enough, and Maggie too. I felt that we could understand why she was doing what she did.


Aline | 21 comments The book is fun, a little ridiculous at times and too much. But that didn't stop me from having fun reading it.

Maggie is scary!
We understand how she feels, her background and why she acts the way she does.
The subject of motherhood could have been dealt with in much greater depth. It remains a bit superficial, which is a shame...

I'm disappointed to have found out about Beth from the start.


Jennn | 52 comments I enjoyed this! It was as expected having read David Sodergren before. Fun and gory! Wondering if he has a unique, comical, over-the-top sexual death scene in each of his books. This wasn’t quite as crazy as The Forgotten Island but I love a good witch story and thoroughly enjoyed it. I also liked the ending. I probably should’ve seen it coming but didn’t.


Chris N | 3 comments This is my first David Sodergren read and I'm excited! I feel like I've walked into a cheesy cult horror film - my favourite kind.


Chandler | 271 comments This is my first Sodergren book - it was so wild! I liked it :) Action packed with gory and creepy imagery.

(view spoiler)


Chris N | 3 comments Finally finished and I absolutely loved this! It's brutal but not without moments of dark humour that eases the tension and makes it fun.

Some plot points are left unexplained which I can see have already been mentioned here, but that didn't bother me too much and I will just interpret the lore using my own imagination.

I will definitely be reading The Haar and some others after this :)


back to top