The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
TASK HELP: Winter 2025-26
>
15.1 - Polar to Peak
date
newest »
newest »
Would Trail of Tears Princess of the Desert - M.N. Thomas be ok for part 1 of this challenge?Many thanks
Fiona (Titch) wrote: "Would Trail of Tears Princess of the Desert - M.N. Thomas be ok for part 1 of this challenge?
Many thanks"
yes
Many thanks"
yes
JennRenee wrote: "Fiona (Titch) wrote: "Would Trail of Tears Princess of the Desert - M.N. Thomas be ok for part 1 of this challenge?Many thanks"
yes"
Change of book as I've found out my copy isn't around. So I wondered if this would be ideal for book 1: Falling Apart and Other Gifts from the Universe - Catherine Ryan Hyde
Many thanks
Does this work for part 2Spring Girls - set in Appalachian foothills -- not sure if this meets the intent of the task
Fiona (Titch) wrote: "JennRenee wrote: "Fiona (Titch) wrote: "Would Trail of Tears Princess of the Desert - M.N. Thomas be ok for part 1 of this challenge?Many thanks"
yes"
Change of..."
As long as you can account for the letters in Polar Desert, a book would work.
Approved
No, the foothills are not part of the mountainsfoothills are not mountains; they are lower hills or rolling terrain that are found at the base of a mountain range, acting as a transition zone between flat land and higher elevations
The task specifically asks for the setting to be in the mountains.
for the Alps...Bearer of Bad News - from the description - a mysterious job that takes her though the Italian Dolomites
from my googling, the dolomites are part of the Alps range in Italy - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolomites
does that work?
Dee wrote: "for the Alps...
Bearer of Bad News - from the description - a mysterious job that takes her though the Italian Dolomites
from my googling, the dolomites are part of the Alps rang..."
Yes that would work. If you add the info to your claim post, it would help the reviewing mod greatly. :)
Bearer of Bad News - from the description - a mysterious job that takes her though the Italian Dolomites
from my googling, the dolomites are part of the Alps rang..."
Yes that would work. If you add the info to your claim post, it would help the reviewing mod greatly. :)
The Couples Trip"From the austere mountaintops of northern Sweden"
Does this work for Scandinavian Mountains?
MorningI just wanted to get these two confirmed that you're happy they're both set in the Himalayas.
Into Thin Air: A Personal Account of the Everest Disaster, Jon Krakauer
POLAR: PeRsOnAL
DESERT: EveREST Disaster
Thin Air, Michelle Paver
Setting stated in the GR description as The Himalayas, 1935
Thanks.
Susan A wrote: "Is that approval for both post 10 and 11?"
Yes, I would say both yours and Trish' s are approved.
Yes, I would say both yours and Trish' s are approved.
Les flammes de pierre - "Flames of Stone" apparently hasn't been translated into English. The first line of the GR description says "Rémy et Laure partageaient le sommet de Croisse-Baulet : - Remy and Laure (the hero and heroine) shared the summit of Croisse-Baulet. I looked up that name and found it is in the Alps. Most of the book takes place in the area. I just wanted to get it approved here - thanks!
Books mentioned in this topic
Les flammes de pierre (other topics)Thin Air (other topics)
Into Thin Air: A Personal Account of the Everest Disaster (other topics)
The Couples Trip (other topics)
Bearer of Bad News (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
M.N. Thomas (other topics)M.N. Thomas (other topics)
Catherine Ryan Hyde (other topics)
M.N. Thomas (other topics)
M.N. Thomas (other topics)




The main types of tundra are arctic tundra and Alpine Tundra. The Arctic Tundra is a desert with permafrost and is often referred to as the polar desert.
The Alpine Tundra is found at high elevations in mountains with harsh cold conditions.
This is a two book task,
Book 1: Read a book where all the letters of Polar Desert can be found in the title/subtitle/author name.
and
Book 2: Read a book that is set at least 50% in one of these mountain ranges that have alpine tundra or set in "snowy mountain location"
North American Cordillera mountains, Appalachian mountains, the Alps, Pyrenees mountains, the Himalaya Mountains, Karakoram mountain range, the Andes, the Eastern Rift mountains, the Snowy Mountains, and the Scandinavian Mountains.
Required: If the setting is not evident from the Goodreads main page, provide a reference.