Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion

Both of their last names are Black... I personally like both of them as my favourite characters.



[image error]

I love Jake, and like Sirius. I don't know why but I don't like Sirius that much. I guess because I don't really like James (Harry's dad) and Sirius is a lot like James. I loved him because he was great for Harry, but his personality bothered me a little.

Really? i liked Sirius as one of my favourites because he was so awesome. He wasn't perfect and that's why he was perfect.... make sense?

I don't like either all that much.

LAURENA!

What. In twilight I like Jasper and Emmett. In HP I like George and Ron and Luna.

Sirius just bothers me... I don't even know why!!

well you stink! I love Sirius! it was sooooooo sad in the fifth one.

No it wasn't, I knew it was coming. SOMEONE opened the book and told me like the day I got it.

FRANK!

No, ANDY!

hehe

It was really sad, and a do sorta like Sirius, but... I don't know. I really don't!!

I don't like him either. But then, I knew he was going to die in the fifth one, so I just kind of pushed him away. Why get too close to a character that is just going to die soon?

Laurena that's stupid. Scott is starring at me frekishly.

Tell him to stop. If he doesn't, tell him I told him to stop...i don't know.

It;s fine, it's just freaky!

Go here, http://www.youtube.com/user/FantasyFr... look at beccas animation.

Ha, ha. That was kind of cool. I like how it exploded at the end. Is yours going to be on youtube too?

Maybe, but i can't get the music in because it isn't a mp3 file, so right now i just play both together.

Yeah, but you don't really need the music on youtube do you?

yep, but Beccas converting it for me, but i still need to cut it up using some sort of program

Okay.

ya...

yep

sirius

Hooray!

i hate jakob.

I actually like Jacob, one of my favourites in Twilight/

I only kinda like Jake, I don't really like Sirius. The only thing--for me--that they have going for them is that they can turn into dogs. That's pretty cool.

yes. that is cool

Yep. I don't know too much about Sirius...except that he's Harry's cool godfather, and has had a pretty wicked past...and I don't mean wicked in the cool way. I kind of feel sorry for him. Being falsly accused and shoved into Azkaban prison. That's just depressing.

I feel sorry for him...but I still don't like him. I don't really know why...

except...? you're probably editing the post aren't you?

Yeah, I was.

I would be an epic dog fight--sirius has my money...

I'd go with Jacob.

really? You're just saying that cause i said siruis

Yep.

thought so.

I think if they both turn into "dogs" than it would be Jake, because he's probably bigger than Sirius, and he has super strength and speed. I know Sirius is pretty big, but you'd think Jake would be at least a little bigger than him. Jake can also heal super fast so he won't really be affected by little cuts or scrapes that he gets during the fight. Plus he could just dodge out of Sirius's way anyway.

Now if they are both human, Sirius would probaly have the advantage, but I'm not totally sure about that. And I highly doubt that Jake would stay human for very long, if at all, and if he turns into a werewolf than the fight would get very interesting. I'd say if that happened then Jake would have the advantage again.

Sirius has serious speed, and agility, so it would be quite equal in dog form but otherwise Sirius would win... yes.

Um...Jake is a shape-shifter, not a werewolf.

Just saying.

still

I know.

I've got a new point!

Jake is russet (like the potato:-)) coloured, which is really cool, and Sirius is really black...both kind of unusual for wolves.

Which one would pass for a better dog?

Personally I think Sirius.

Yeah. I can see it working like that.

Oh sorry Laurena. I was sorta wrapped up in my argument. I think Sirius would be the better dog too.

Yeah. Jake is just too huge. Right?

What class are you in?