Pick-a-Shelf discussion
YOU CHOOSE - ended Dec. 31, 2010
>
Natasha's YOU CHOOSE Super Awesome Challenge
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Luann
(new)
Jul 22, 2010 06:27PM
Wow, nine books!! Great start, Natasha!
reply
|
flag
Natasha wrote: "I finished Flatland A Romance of Many Dimensions by Edwin Abbott Abbott. I gave it two stars. The first half of the book was dedicated to describing Flatland and its culture. That got..."
Natasha,
I assign it to my advanced Geometry students every year, and they have a hard time with it. I think it's one of those books that was revolutionary for its time, but is hard to appreciate when reading it now. I still find the argument by analogy (for the existence of more dimensions) rather persuasive. And if you think of the description of the culture of Flatland as in part a satire of the Victorian culture Abbott lived in, you might find more in it than you saw at first.
But in many ways, I can see two stars as fair. I only give it 3 stars now, even though I remember finding it amazing when I read it in high school.
Natasha,
I assign it to my advanced Geometry students every year, and they have a hard time with it. I think it's one of those books that was revolutionary for its time, but is hard to appreciate when reading it now. I still find the argument by analogy (for the existence of more dimensions) rather persuasive. And if you think of the description of the culture of Flatland as in part a satire of the Victorian culture Abbott lived in, you might find more in it than you saw at first.
But in many ways, I can see two stars as fair. I only give it 3 stars now, even though I remember finding it amazing when I read it in high school.
How DO you strikeout the books that you have read? I keep seeing people do that and I really love to cross things off of my list of things to do. Thanks.
Crystal wrote: "How DO you strikeout the books that you have read? I keep seeing people do that and I really love to cross things off of my list of things to do. Thanks."
Add "<" followed by "s>" in front of it (If I type it all together now, it'll just do it and not show you>) At the end, type "<" followed by "/s>". Anytime you're typing a comment, click on the "(some html is ok)" link to see other things you can do -- bold, underlining, etc.
Add "<" followed by "s>" in front of it (If I type it all together now, it'll just do it and not show you>) At the end, type "<" followed by "/s>". Anytime you're typing a comment, click on the "(some html is ok)" link to see other things you can do -- bold, underlining, etc.
Natasha wrote: "I have a feeling that I will leave the books started but never finished until last."
I'd been thinking the same thing -- those, and the "dreaded" are so hard to even pick up!
I'd been thinking the same thing -- those, and the "dreaded" are so hard to even pick up!


