Libba Bray Lovers! discussion

People said Gemma Doyle 4 is there a movie or a fourth book. Haven't read Sweet Far Thing so no spoilers please.

Oh no, it's just a thing on Youtube. PS: Welcome Ginnie!

welcome!

thanks!!! and thanks!

So will there be a 4th book?

OMG, you know how Kristen Stewart will play Bella in Twiligt? Well, if she like dyed her hair a little more of a reddish-brown, she'd be a realy good Gemma!

HONEST opinion... what do you think?

Maybe not that good.

Um...no. Not for me. Gemma looks way different. And I don't think Kristen is going to do that good a job playing Bella either. I mean she looks like Bella...but just the way she talks about the books she just does't get how important they are to the world. I definetly do not want Kristen Stewart to play Gemma. But, its alright if you do because we all have our different opinions.

I like her, she's pretty close to the Gemma I see in my head.

He's pretty close to the Kartik I see, but not perfect.

I think he would be ok, ya not perfect. But he isnt bad looking or to old or anything so... When is the movie expected because I haven't seen or heard anything about it. I mean I know its not for a long time but, like an estimate? I really hope they do make a movie.

I think he works for Kartik, i always sorta pictured him more of a tan american despite how he is described in the book. I didnt even know they were making these books into a movie.

Me too! I pictured a really good looking tan american guy, young too. Some of the people they picked on youtube were too old.

Yeah I think he would work for him. But ugh no. Kirstin Stewart cannot play Gemma. I don't even think she'll do a good job as Bella but in the end all of them look really bad. Except for James and Carisle. I think they look okay. Oh and Esme.

Kirstin as Gemma? No way! RHW is my fave Gemma. And welcome everyone! Wow, I can't believe how many new people are here!

And I hope that they don't pick that boy for Kartik! He looks nothing like him! Tan American? Seriously?

A didn't picture him a tan american, I pictured him a good looking indian boy. I'll give you the names if any of the boys in The Cheetah Girls 3 make the cut! LOL!

I know, I was thinking that maybe the love interest of one of the girls would fit. LOL. Kartik is a good looking boy alright.

Ya haha, I just havent seen any good looking indian guys recently that would work. But maybe in cheetah girls 3 never know.

Hopefully! I'm praying!

Me too! haha They ruined the cast for twilight they had better not ruin this one as well! Kartik has to be perfect or as close as possible :)

I think Kristen can do a good job with Bella. And Cedric is growing on me. I loved the trailer!

Kristen is growing on me... Robert on the other hand(cedric)... Have you seen the picture of him with Bella as Edward on entertainment mag???? He is.... Horrible.... I almost started crying. Mike Newton is REALLY cute though and so is Jacob.

I did love the trailer though it was really cool!

I saw the magazine cover, and it was so wrong.

It was ... I am really nervous about how the movie is going to turn out should be interesting. Oh and please no one take any offense to me asking but, Is Gemma suposed to be over weight? All the auditions I watched for her, except the girl that totally should be her and everyone agrees on, are not of skinny people. Which I have nothing against people who have a mind and arent tiny, but I am just curious.

I don't think she;s supposed to be like that, but I have nothing against people who are bigger then others. The people who I know are stick thin are not the nicest or smartest people in the world. No offense.

None taken, I just always pictured her fit. I mean I am skinny and I have nothing against heavier set people like I said. Just I was a little suprised with how many auditions were... ya know...

I never got to look inside at the other pictures but ya disgusting on the front.
As for the moving coming I really hope it does come out next year. I dont know how much longer I could wait!

Gemma seemed fit, I don't have anything against bigger people either. But I think it's more about personality than anything.

Yes most definaltly.

I think she's normal, not fat def. but not skinny either.

I hate when they make movies of the books i love. I like to use my imagination not have it placed out before me. But hopefully they will choose good actors that look like the characters in AGTB.

Kirstin yes Cedric now way in space he will get my approval have you seen his chest, in the magazine photshoot. Ugh turn off

I know it's... Lets just hope he keeps a shirt on for most of the movie. lol