twilight! discussion
Twilight
>
Do you think it would be okay for someone to start with NEW MOON?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Carrie
(last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:35AM)
(new)
Jul 23, 2008 06:09PM
My mom wants to read Twilight because I keep raving about it, but I thought Twilight was kind of boring. Do you think she could just start with NEW MOON?
reply
|
flag
Idk, because Edward Leaves, you have to actually get to know Edward in Twilight, because if she starts with New Moon, her fav. character would be Jacob because you know him better.
NEVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
My best friend did and she loves Jacob and doesn't have much tolerance for Edward. Also Bella is kind of depressing and it is hard to compare herself to the "New Moon" Bella. I would reccomend starting with Twilight, because it would be easier to understand the characters.
Well, I have a friend who read New Moon and she didn't like it very much. And when I read Twilight and was talking about it she wouldn't even read twilight. I think you have to start with the first book to really understand things.:p
I'm afraid that so much of the overall story would be lost if Twilight wasn't read first. I can't imagine skipping it. 
I would never!! She probably would like Jacob better......the first book is so important in establishing the importance of Bella and Edward's intense and special relationship. She would just think Edward is a jerk who just broke her heart!! Hope she reads the first:-)
let her read the first!!! she'll be clueless if she doesn't!!
no no no, you wont get the total feel for it, start with twilight, you'll love it!
message 12:
by
♥lil' bit :} (i put u in my popcorn tehe!!), school's out!!! okay where's my coffee?!?
(new)
Mod
message 13:
by
☼Alethia☼ change is good...sometimes..., 1 thing, 2 do, 3 words, 4 you: My cousin got married!!!!!
(last edited Jul 28, 2008 09:38AM)
(new)
Mod
You need to understand the characters and the story to get New Moon
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! U MUST NOT START WITH NEW MOON!!!!!!!! START WITH TWILIGHT!!!!!! OTHER WISE THE SIERIES DOESNT WORK!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Don't skip books. That's a No No!
No never, for one it wouldn't make sense and for two, it wouldn't make sense, and for three, it wouldn't be as interesting without the background on the characters.
NO! Definitely not! I actually thought that New Moon moved kinda slow without Edward to make it interesting (LOL), but the first part of Twilight is admittedly a bit slow, too. But you should still start with Twilight because everything about vampires and stuff is explained.
I finally got my mom to read twilight! I'm so proud of myself!!!
kewl! my mom read it. but she didnt like it that much. she tends to find something wrong with every book that I tell her to read..except for Percy Jackson and the Olympians. hmm....LOL
no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no nonononnonononononononoHow would it make since if she was so devastaded by edward leaving and laurent coming back and the search for victoria, and him trying to destroy himself
HUH? what the heck do you mean? sorry, but i can make absolutely no sense of your post.
she shoul read twilight first
message 25:
by
♥lil' bit :} (i put u in my popcorn tehe!!), school's out!!! okay where's my coffee?!?
(new)
Mod
Look i read New Moon first then Twilight. But i got the whole story straight.
message 27:
by
♥lil' bit :} (i put u in my popcorn tehe!!), school's out!!! okay where's my coffee?!?
(new)
Mod
If I read a book that's in a series, I HAVE to read them in order. So i say that she should start with Twilight. And you should definetly buy Twilight. I'ts an amazing book and this way you dont have to rent the copy, you can read it whenever you like.
You should DEFINITELY start with Twilight!
START WITH TWILIGHT. I just reread New Moon and it's been forever since I read twilight and it was a bit confusing because you don't see the relationship between bella and edward. so when you read how upset she is, you don't understand why
Besides, you can't NOT know Edward, he's pivitol to the story and the reason why Bella is so broken up and desperate
You should definitely read Twilight first, it's a tad hard to tell what's going on unless you read the first book.
Absolutely, in my school library they like have 8 copies of the Twilight book alone. Also, it is worth buying.
ditto 2 everything every1 said. except 4 the hinted part that u should like edward more than jacob. even after reading breaking dawn, i disagree.
twilight!
Books mentioned in this topic
New Moon (other topics)Breaking Dawn (other topics)
