Never Judge a Book by its Movie discussion

This topic is where you discuss why you did or didn't like the film adaptation of the book.

I didnt like the movie: The Last Song cus first off Miley Cyrus just was not the right person for Ronnie! and second cus the book had just so much more going on then they put in the movie, third because she was a rebel for like 5 minutes then she went back to being the perfect little girl, fourth gosh why did they cast miley cyrus and her baby face!?!?! sry i dont mean to offend anybody!

I agree with you. I mean, they could have ((this is my opinion, don't hate me for it!!!)) picked a better actress for the part. And you're right, they had much more going on in the book than in the movie, and the 'rebel' part of Ronnie was my all-time favorite part. And of course, it's not in the film. Bummer.

I thought Miley Cyrus did a good job considering what a you know... ok actress she is. The fact that she didn't stay goth for very long is kinda frustrating but I read the book and enjoyed the movie, so I like them both.

Did you guys see the movie Dear John?

Love that movie!

:] me too. The only part I didn't like was how depressing John's life was. That was supposed to happen, but still, his life was completely messed up.

I saw it too, but i really did not like it. I'm not one for romance movies, but i was dragged to the movies...

lol, happens to me all the time...

I saw it but it was SO diffrent from the books and the book and the movie just pissed me off -.- I wanted a happier ending then that.

lol...It was pretty depressing. I was bummed out for a day or two after reading the book.

I beat the book up after I read it...

lol...I would do that, too. But my sister took it away before I had the chance...darn

I through it on the table and hit it and then my sister grabbed it. LOL. BTW inbox... please? lol

okay, but I'm sorry ((again)), that I have to go in a minute

Its okay. lol!

Anyways, what's another movie that you guys have some positive/negative views on?

The Notebook is a good one

Oh and Confessions Of A Shopaholic is awesome!

I LOVE Confessions Of A Shopaholic!

I never saw that one...*sigh*

I really loved The Lord of the Rings movies. They only changed little things in the movie. And I can only think of one scene that actually didn't happen in the book and it was acceptable because it could have happened in the book.

:] Oh, I know, I loved those movies! I own all three, and sometimes, when I'm bored, I just watch all three in a row. It's awesome, lol

i loved lord of the rings! and i hated notebook ssoo much

My mom is obssessed with Lord of The Rings, she has Lord Of The Rings Monopoly.

lol, if I ever found that, I would save up and buy it. lol, I can see it now...

She wanted trading cards for it too. LOL

lol :]

My mom is a dork, but my whole family is so...

lol, so is mine. Actually, I'm the dork in my family, but that's not really surprising, I guess. lol :]

My dad is the major one cause he tries to tell jokes that arent funny.

and then everyone laughs awkwardly? thats what happens in my family.

My mom tells him that he's not funny and he laughs.

lol, that's what I get at home. There's almost always one of those people in the family....at least, as far as I know...

lol yeah. And he's a techy so he knows all sorts of junk bout computer.

Have you guys ever play Lord of the Rings Risk? It's fun. The expanded version is better though, it has Mordor and Gondor, ect. on it. We don't own that one though....

I wish I could play that game! I can't even remember the last time I played Risk...I was the best in my family, which explains why none of them want to play anymore....

I have never played Risk before.

*gasp*! Say it isn't so! ((lol))

omg percy jackson movie is wayyy diff from the book i mean ares isn't even in it but hes in the book a lot and luke dosent fram percy in the book ares doessss

Soccer108 wrote: "*gasp*! Say it isn't so! ((lol))"

It is so I'm afraid.

Soccer108 wrote: "lol, if I ever found that, I would save up and buy it. lol, I can see it now..."

same here!,BTW what is the scene that was not from the books,I can't remember 'cos its been a long time since I've read the books

Stark4eva: I know! and clarisse is a big part in the sea of monsters!

i knowww

Man no one posts on here...

You know the lord of the rings movies? They were filmed where I live! NEW ZEALAND!!!! Peter jackson's from here too.

cool!!I love LOTR movies!

=] Lol, me too

I love LOTR! SO MUCH!

GAH!

They are amazing aren't they? And the scenery was really beautiful. I could hardly believe that it was New Zealand.